News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I want to leave tech: what do I do? by somenameforme on Friday July 04, 2025 @11:29AM (#44465376)
Everything that exists to make money, gradually takes it to an extreme as it becomes more difficult to make money on the up and up. Everything that doesn't exist to make money ends up existing to make money once it reaches a sufficient size - this includes nonprofits and charities.

This is one of the many reasons I tend to be vehemently in favor of decentralization. A lot of these problems are just because organizations become too large. It also feels kind of dystopic, or sterile at least, how you can be a thousand miles away and have a main street that looks largely indistinguishable from the one you just came from.

Re:I want to leave tech: what do I do? by benreesman on Friday July 04, 2025 @11:57AM (#44465619)
I don't really disagree with anything you've said, other than a vague sort of discomfort around practicality. I dislike market failures very much, I war-crime dislike engineered market failures (the two co-occur with alarming frequency).

But markets are effectively part of the natural world: if you engineer the most oppressive, regimented, panopticon nightmare prison available to human deviousness you will succeed in creating a black market, not in eliminating markets.

So any solution has to be about preventing market failures, not eliminating markets. If North Korea can't effectively inhibit markets from forming, it's a pretty convincing demonstration that no acceptable amount of anti-market intervention is going to be okay.

Re:I want to leave tech: what do I do? by spacemadness on Friday July 04, 2025 @12:23PM (#44465835)
I’m not following. I don’t think they said anything about eliminating markets, rather halting monopolies.
Re:I want to leave tech: what do I do? by benreesman on Friday July 04, 2025 @01:20PM (#44466310)
Like I said, I'm broadly sympathetic to your view. I was just pointing out that you led with "things that exist to make money..." and while the point you raise is true (or often true), its kind of an unsolved problem.

On halting monopolies I would vote and canvas for you if you ran on it.

I agree about the appeal of decentralization, I just don't know how to make it happen in a world where centralized control is enforced by MQ-9 Reaper drones with sole executive discretion on "kill or capture" of anyone and decentralization is considered a national security priority.

An example would be the people who argue that inherently sovereign and anonymous money would liberate people. What it would do is get you shot for fucking with the Mint.

Re:I want to leave tech: what do I do? by spacemadness on Saturday July 05, 2025 @12:32PM (#44473815)
I didn’t state a view. You’re talking to someone else.
Re:I want to leave tech: what do I do? by benreesman on Saturday July 05, 2025 @12:51PM (#44473942)
I suppose I'm guilty of the high crime of replying on a phone where the usernames are small, you were continuing a line of thought and I answered the renewed objections to my very reasonable point. `somenameforme` and `spacedmadness` look a lot alike at 8pt.

This is one of those comments where I'm like, I bet the big LLM can write a FireFox extension that will block HN comments by username now...