I probably made a mistake when i asserted that -- should have thought it over. Vision is evolutionarily older and more “primitive”, while language is uniquely human [or maybe, more broadly, primate, cetacean, cephalopod, avian...] symbolic, and abstract — arguably a different order of cognition altogether. But i maintain that each and every sense is important as far as human cognition -- and its replication -- is concerned.
If all humans lacked vision, the human race would definitely not do just fine.
Language allows encoding and compression of information about the world, which is of course incredibly powerful and increases communication bandwidth enormously (as well as tons of other stuff).
I'd say that for high level cognitive processes, hearing and speaking were an important stepping stone because for some reason evolving organs that can generate relatively high bandwidth signals in audio seems to be easier than evolving something that does that for visuals (very few Teletubby screens on tummies in the natural world).
Interesting games to think about in this sense: Pictionary/drawing games and charades.
I thought about this some more and I think the prevalence of making sounds rather than gesturing etc. is due to sound being a broadcasting mechanism that works over long distances and without line of sight.
Visually indicating that you've claimed some territory is pretty hard.
Current generative models merely mimic the output, with a fuzzy abstract linguistic mess in place of any physical/causal models. It's unsurprising that their capacity to "reason" is so brittle.
Language can exist entirely independently from senses and cognition. It is an encoding of patterns in the world where the only thing that matters is if anybody or anything wielding it can map the encodings to and from the patterns they encode for (which is more of a sociological/synchronisation challenge).
Does C, or Java, 'make no sense' because it 'ignores lower level cognition'?
There are many parts of non-programming languages that similarly have nothing to do with embodiment. Some of them are even about incredibly abstract things impossible in our universe. One could argue that for many fields genius lies in being able to mentally model what is so foreign to the intuition our embodiment has imbued us with or to be able to find a mapping to facilitate that intuition. Said otherwise: the experience our embodiment has given us might limit how well we can understand the world (Quantum Mechanics anyone?).
Again, embodiment is interesting and worth pursuing, but far from a requirement for far-reaching intelligence.
It makes sense in context, but that context includes the machine on which the compiled code runs. Without the underlying machine, there's no real purpose for C or Java. I'm open to the idea that 'lower level cognition' may be as relevant to language as the machine is to C or Java.
They do express algorithms, don't they?
Helen Keller begs to disagree. Language and cognition were clearly linked for her.
> It wasn't until April 5, 1887, when Anne took Helen to an old pump house, that Helen finally understood that everything has a name. Sullivan put Helen’s hand under the stream and began spelling “w-a-t-e-r” into her palm, first slowly, then more quickly.
> Keller later wrote in her autobiography, “As the cool stream gushed over one hand she spelled into the other the word water, first slowly, then rapidly. I stood still, my whole attention fixed upon the motions of her fingers. Suddenly I felt a misty consciousness as of something forgotten–-a thrill of returning thought; and somehow the mystery of language was revealed to me. I knew then that ‘w-a-t-e-r’ meant the wonderful cool something that was flowing over my hand. That living word awakened my soul, gave it light, hope, joy, set it free! There were barriers still, it is true, but barriers that could in time be swept away.”
"one plus one equals two" can be understood and worked with without ever feeling water over your hand. It is a priori knowledge (see Hume's fork for an explanation).
You have to understand that the richness of language linked to cognition is due to your experience with that part of language and resulting romantization of it. It doesn't mean that it is a core defining feature of language, even though it feels that way (and as touching as that anecdote is).
"Understood" and "worked with" are completely different.
The complete absence of embodiment is several degrees removed from "feeling water over your hand." LLMs have no sensory apparatus to relate the word "one" to actual, discrete, singular objects. The most rudimentary calculator can represent and compute "1+1=2", but I doubt any philosophical tradition or even an educated layperson would claim calculators "understand what 1+1=2 means." The "understanding" part has nothing to do with the accuracy or truthfulness of the computation; it comes from the relation of the abstract statement to counting of actual objects.
Maybe? Are you just outlining the thesis, or saying this should be self-evident?
> It is an encoding of patterns in the world where the only thing that matters is if anybody or anything wielding it can map the encodings to and from the patterns they encode for (which is more of a sociological/synchronisation challenge).
Yes, and my point is, current genAI utterly fails in unpredictable / bizarre ways because it only mimics the abstract encodings, ignorant of patterns in the world. Obviously some people argue "next token prediction is all you need," but that's a claim that is far from self-evident.
> There are many parts of non-programming languages that similarly have nothing to do with embodiment. Some of them are even about incredibly abstract things impossible in our universe. One could argue that for many fields genius lies in being able to mentally model what is so foreign to the intuition our embodiment has imbued us with or to be able to find a mapping to facilitate that intuition.
I would say this misses the point. The meaningfulness of abstractions, even ones that are unintuitive or unphysical or illogical, come from our embodied experience. Our enjoyment of even the most absurd fiction comes from our ability to simultaneously comprehend what it is "about" and what is "possible." Both relate to experience-of-reality and mean nothing in a vacuum.
> Said otherwise: the experience our embodiment has given us might limit how well we can understand the world (Quantum Mechanics anyone?).
I agree that we are limited in some ways by our particular embodiment. e.g. There's a huge spectrum of sensory experiences - colors, sounds, smells ... - which we know other animals have that we do not.
As I understand, where we disagree is on the why. I would say our capacity for understanding comes from our embodiment, therefore it's only natural that the limits of our embodiment also limit our understanding. After all we could imagine that if we had direct sensory experience of quantum effects, we would understand QM better or at least easier. In some fuzzy way, (no embodiment => poor understanding) and (embodiment => better understanding) is evidence for (embodiment <=> understanding). I suppose your argument is a counterfactual that we might be able to imagine a (no embodiment & some understanding) so (no embodiment =/> poor understanding), but I don't see the evidence that this is not just imaginable but actually possible in reality.
Only octopuses, elephants and apes are in a similar league with regards to dexterity and finesse.
In that case, all the processes and pathways in your brain are relying on and tied to those senses, so losing them might also disrupt or affect those pathways and how they function.
It may be, that we are not using touch for anything important as adults. But babies rely on touch to explore their surroundings. They stick anything into their mouth, why? Because a tongue is the most touch-sensitive organ. They are exploring things by touching them with their tongues.
I can only guess what people get from that, but my guess is they get understanding of geometry and of surface properties of objects, which you'll have problems to get by processing photos or texts.
> your comment was specifically about intelligence.
Talking about intelligence, I do not believe that LLMs can match humans without deep understanding or 3d-space and material science^W intuition. It needs touch and temperature sensitivity at least. Probably you can replace it with billions of words of texts describing these things, but I doubt it.
Another thing to remember is that the senses we have aren't the only ones in biology and far from the only ones possible. In fact, anything that gives you another type of information about the world (you're modeling) is a different sense. In that sense (ha), AI has access to an incredibly vast and varied array of senses that is inaccessible to humans. Lidar is a very simple example of that.
I don't think touch and temperature sensitivity are needed to achieve it, but I do agree that training with senses specifically for understanding 3D space is very important. At the very least binocular video.
So AI developers understand limitations and trying to remove them. It will help, but it will not make AI vision to be on par with a human's.
> In that sense (ha), AI has access to an incredibly vast and varied array of senses that is inaccessible to humans. Lidar is a very simple example of that.
I don't think that current uses of lidars have anything to do with intelligence. Not every neuro-net is about intelligence.
> I don't think touch and temperature sensitivity are needed to achieve it,
I'm sure they are. To understand forms you need to explore them with touch. The ability to understand forms by just looking at them is an acquired skill. Maybe it is possible to train these abilities without the touch, but how? I believe it will take a shitload of training data, and I'm not sure it will be good enough.
Temperature sensitivity is a big thing, because it allow you to guess thermal conductivity of a thing by just looking at it. It allows to guess wetness of a thing. It allows us to guess temperature of things by looking at them: like you see sun shining, fire burning, people touching things and yanking their hands from hot things. Or just how about a person that cautiously trying to learn a temperature of a thing, at first measuring infrared radiation, then a quick touch, then a touch for a longer time, and finally a long sustained contact: how could you understand all these proceedings without your own experience of grasping the hot thing, crying from a pain and dropping the thing on your feet?
These are just obvious ideas from top of my mind. What else comes from temperature sensitivity I don't know and no one is, because no one really knows how people learn to use their senses and to think. There are theories about it, but they are more of descriptive nature: they describe what is known without having a lot of a predictive power. Because of this the optimism of AI crowd seems overinflated. They don't know what they are trying to do, and still they believe in their eventual success.
Probably you can learn it by thinking, but can LLMs think, while training? You can learn it as a pattern of a behaviour, without understanding the meaning of it, but then you'll hallucinate this pattern all the time, just because some of the movements were close enough.
> At the very least binocular video.
I'm not sure that people can learn 3d by looking. At least they do not just rely on a binocular vision to learn it. They touch, they lick. They measure things in different ways (by sticking it in mouth, by grasping, by climbing on top of it or falling from it, by hugging it), they measure distances by crawling or walking along them. They are finding a spot where they can see what happens behind a pack of tree, or maybe behind something else. People not just using more senses, they are acting also, which allows them to learn causal relationships. Watching binocular video is not acting, so you can get correlation only without any hope to learn how to distinguish correlations from causations, and at the same time it is much more limited in a data available.
Science says that 80 or 90% of information people get is coming from their vision? I'm skeptical about this, because I don't know how they measure "information", but in any case human vision was trained with support from other senses. I wouldn't be surprised, if at certain stages of a baby's development other senses are more advanced and are used to get labelled data to train vision.
I respectfully disagree. Touch gives pretty cool skills, but language, video and audio are all that are needed for all online interactions. We use touch for typing and pointing, but that is only because we don't have a more efficient and effective interface.
Now I'm not saying that all other senses are uninteresting. Integrating touch, extensive proprioception, and olfaction is going to unlock a lot of 'real world' behavior, but your comment was specifically about intelligence.
Compare humans to apes and other animals and the thing that sets us apart is definitely not in the 'remaining' senses, but firmly in the realm of audio, video and language.