Re:There Are No New Ideas in AI Only New Datasets
by actionfromafar on Tuesday July 01, 2025 @08:21AM
(#44433164)
Regarding visual communication, I think you downsell posturing, gesturing and facial expressions a little. They may not be as high bandwidth as talking but they are very low latency and pretty stealthy if necessary.
Re:There Are No New Ideas in AI Only New Datasets
by dinfinity on Tuesday July 01, 2025 @12:33PM
(#44435593)
Well, there is sign language, so I guess you're right. It would be interesting to see how high bandwidth gesturing can be compared to speaking.
I thought about this some more and I think the prevalence of making sounds rather than gesturing etc. is due to sound being a broadcasting mechanism that works over long distances and without line of sight.
Visually indicating that you've claimed some territory is pretty hard.
Re:There Are No New Ideas in AI Only New Datasets
by actionfromafar on Tuesday July 01, 2025 @05:07PM
(#44438017)
I was thinking more about "low level" communication which can be gleaned from body language, frowns, smiles, gaze, winks, pointing etc. Perhaps not very information dense, but very fast.
Language allows encoding and compression of information about the world, which is of course incredibly powerful and increases communication bandwidth enormously (as well as tons of other stuff).
I'd say that for high level cognitive processes, hearing and speaking were an important stepping stone because for some reason evolving organs that can generate relatively high bandwidth signals in audio seems to be easier than evolving something that does that for visuals (very few Teletubby screens on tummies in the natural world).
Interesting games to think about in this sense: Pictionary/drawing games and charades.