News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by energy123 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @05:25AM (#44403347)
Your views on this question are going to differ a lot depending on the probability you assign to a conflict with China in the next five years. I feel like that number should be offered up for scrutiny before a discussion on the cost vs benefits of export controls even starts.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by spaceman_2020 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @05:36AM (#44403401)
I'm not American. Ever since I've been old enough to understand the world, the only country constantly at war everywhere is America. An all-powerful American AI is scarier to me than an open source Chinese one
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by throwaway290 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:25AM (#44403628)
As Russian I only recently started to understand that russian government was at wars for a lot of its existence from USSR times: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_involving_Russia#.... Many invasions and wars in places Russia should have no business in. Most of them not publicized in the country. Unlike US it was not spreading liberal values of individual freedom and against violent dictatorships, actually maybe the other way around
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by Thlom on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:00AM (#44403773)
The US is not at perpetual war to spread "liberal values".
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by throwaway290 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:55AM (#44404019)
I didn't say it is always the goal but if one country prevails over another country somewhere then usually it means first country's values propagate
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by rescbr on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:23AM (#44403877)
> against violent dictatorships

Then look up Latin America’s history, where the US actively worked to install and support such violent dictatorships.

Some under the guise of protecting countries from the threat of communism - like Brazil, Argentina and Chile, and some explicitly to protect US company’s interests - like in Guatemala

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by throwaway290 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @08:00AM (#44404041)
> Chile

Yes fuckups happened. But then for results Russian intervention see CCP and how many people died from their hands and policies

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by CamperBob2 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @02:30PM (#44406971)
Well, that's different. The Russians meant well, you see.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by CamperBob2 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @11:13AM (#44405250)
Well, at least protecting Latin American countries from the threat of communism was a nice thing for us to do, wasn't it? Communism would certainly have done more harm than we did.

The lesson of present-day America is that democracy is too important to be left to the people.

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by jaggs on Saturday June 28, 2025 @11:37AM (#44405469)
Mmmm...
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by vbezhenar on Saturday June 28, 2025 @12:31PM (#44405971)
Communism is good. By "protecting" them from communism, you doomed them to the horrors of capitalism.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by CamperBob2 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @02:25PM (#44406930)
You don't have to hold a gun to someone's head to get them to practice capitalism. People will trade labor, goods and services voluntarily unless you go out of your way to stop them.

And spare us the false equivalence bullshit that we all know is coming.

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by andrekandre on Saturday June 28, 2025 @10:09PM (#44409807)

  > trade labor, goods and services voluntarily
small nitpick, but trading != capitalism

capitalism is using capital (money, materials, and employees/work) as inputs to produce finished products with the goal of re-investing those profits into said production or into other markets

simply trading or rendering services can be done without the need for constant growth/profits or investment as capital over time (e.g coops, traditional businesses etc)

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by throwaway290 on Sunday June 29, 2025 @12:20AM (#44410333)
That's not the definition of capitalism I see in my dictionary.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by CamperBob2 on Sunday June 29, 2025 @08:50AM (#44412713)
It's just a case of the Redditification of HN. "Anything I don't like is capitalism. Either that, or the CIA is to blame. ... Wait, why not both?"
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by throwaway290 on Sunday June 29, 2025 @12:19AM (#44410330)
> You don't have to hold a gun to someone's head to get them to practice capitalism. People will trade labor, goods and services voluntarily unless you go out of your way to stop them.

This is an important point. The only way communism "works" is top down enforcement.

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by rescbr on Saturday June 28, 2025 @09:01PM (#44409501)
Ehhh… don’t forget that I wrote “under the guise”.

Lots of US companies got a lot of money out of those US-supported dictatorships, while destroying local businesses and torturing and killing people. Those were also the era of closed-off economies, hyperinflation and environmental destruction, so what the local people got out of it?

So yeah, thanks for protecting us from the dictatorship of the proletariat and fucking up our economies for decades. And I’m not also defending USSR and their imperialistic practices disguised as making the people as equal as possible - fuck them as well!

There’s an old book called “Confessions of an Economic Hitman” that gets into some details of how the US supported those dictatorships under Project Condor and other CIA programs. Is it 100% truthful? Maybe not, but the gist of it is.

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by CamperBob2 on Sunday June 29, 2025 @08:49AM (#44412702)
Yeah, it's always someone else's fault, isn't it.

The proles have let us both down. All my life, I was led to believe that a "dictatorship of the proletariat" would involve a bunch of morons wearing red hats, casting one last vote against their own interests to tear down the established order. So at least that turned out to be technically correct.

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by diggan on Saturday June 28, 2025 @05:55AM (#44403494)
> probability you assign to a conflict with China in the next five years. I feel like that number should be offered up for scrutiny before a discussion

Might as well talk about the probability of a conflict with South Africa, China might not be the best country to live in nor be country that takes care of its own citizens the best, but they seem non-violent towards other sovereign nations (so far), although of course there is a lot of posturing. But from the current "world powers", they seem to be the least violent.

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by energy123 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:11AM (#44403561)
What is the security competition between South Africa and the US that would justify such an analogy?

China is peaceful recently, at least since their invasion of Vietnam. But (1) their post-Deng culture is highly militaristic and irredentist, (2) this is the first time in history that they actually can rollback US influence, their previous inability explains the peace rather than lack of will (3) Taiwan from a realist perspective makes too much sense, as the first in the island chain to wedge between Philippines and Japan, and its role in supplying chips to the US.

The lesson we should learn from Russia's invasion of Ukraine is to believe countries when they say they own another country. Not assume the best and design policy around that assumption.

If you want to read some experts on this question, see this: https://warontherocks.com/?s=taiwan

The general consensus seems to be around a 20-25% chance of an invasion of Taiwan within the next 5 years. The remaining debate isn't about whether they want to do it, it's about whether they'll be able to do it and what their calculation will be around those relative capabilities.

Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by layer8 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @05:57AM (#44403503)
Are you saying that large-model capabilities would make a substantial difference in a military conflict within the next five years? Because we aren’t seeing any signs of that in, say, the Ukraine war.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by randomname93857 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:44AM (#44403715)
We do see the signs and reports, you just have to look. LLMs are being adopted to warfare, with drones or otherwise, there is progress there, but it's not currently at the level of "substantial difference". And 5 years is huge time from progress perspective in this domain - just try to compare LLMs of today with LLMs of 2020.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by Davidzheng on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:31AM (#44403660)
small scale drones are in use in that conflict. On device AI would be a game-changer no?
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by layer8 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:14AM (#44403839)
It’s not impossible, but also highly nontrivial. Apart from the actual AI implementation, power supply might be a challenge. And there is a multitude of anti-drone technology being continuously developed. Already today, an autonomous drone would have to deal with RF jamming and GPS jamming, which means it’s easily defeated unless it has the ability to navigate purely visually. Drones also tend to be limited to good weather conditions and daytime.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by energy123 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @07:43AM (#44403963)
In terms of countermeasures, what's the difference between having a human drone pilot and having an AI (computer vision plus control) do it over cloud? I know I'm moving the goalposts away from edge compute, but if we are discussing the relevance of GPU compute for warfare it seems relevant.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by layer8 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @09:27AM (#44404573)
Assuming human-level AI capabilities, not much of a difference, obviously. But I also don’t think that human operators are a bottleneck currently. Cost, failure rate, and technical limitations of drones is. If you are alluding to superhuman AI capabilities, that’s highly speculative as well with regard to what is needed for drone piloting, and also unclear how large the benefits of that would be in terms of actual operational success rate.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by energy123 on Saturday June 28, 2025 @06:14AM (#44403571)
GPUs are used for signals intelligence today.
Re:DeepSeek R2 launch stalled as CEO balks at progress by tazjin on Saturday June 28, 2025 @05:37AM (#44403416)
> depending on the probability you assign to a conflict with China in the next five years

And on who you would support in such a conflict! ;)