This is not considered valid in Israel.
In Israel October 7 is considered a massive failure of intelligence. No one in the top 30 of any Israeli intelligence agency that Oct 7 was going to happen.
hamas came to power in 2006 after usa forced election (against will of PA that was afraid that hamas will win). after this usa was horrified by outcome and trained/sponsored PA to take over gaza and depose hamas. PA failed and it forces were shot/thrown from roofs/dragged behind bikes and supporters tortured into obedience.
as outcome PA ceased paying salaries to it employees in gaza and foot the bill for infrastructure/etc.
there was massive outrage in media that "hundreds of thousands of people in gaza will starve now because they have no money to buy food" that forced Israel to allow money transfers from Qatar
1) Israeli government willingly favored Hamas governing the Gaza strip and completely cut off the Palestinian authority
2) Israeli government ignored their own intelligence and even allowed money and weapons transfer from Qatar to Hamas
3) Israeli intelligence knew October 7 was gonna happen and did little to prevent it
4) While October 7 is one of the most despicable acts of crime and terror ever happened, it has not happened in a vacuum. It has happened by people who are literally living in the hell and open prison the Israelis have created for them