News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD's Freshly-Baked MI350: An Interview with the Chief Ar... by behnamoh on Friday June 20, 2025 @10:07PM (#44333895)
> these people

we're talking about the majority of open source developers (I'm one of them). if researchers don't get access to hardware X, they write their paper using hardware Y (Nvidia). AMD isn't doing fine because most low level research on AI is done purely on CUDA.

Re:AMD's Freshly-Baked MI350: An Interview with the Chief Ar... by qualifiedeephd on Friday June 20, 2025 @10:13PM (#44333920)
Serious researchers use HPC clusters not desktop workstations. Currently the biggest HPC cluster in North America has AMD GPUs. I think it'll be fine.
Re:AMD's Freshly-Baked MI350: An Interview with the Chief Ar... by pjmlp on Saturday June 21, 2025 @04:38AM (#44335788)
Before they became serious researchers they were once upon a time students learning with what their laptops were capable of.
Re:AMD's Freshly-Baked MI350: An Interview with the Chief Ar... by Certhas on Saturday June 21, 2025 @02:58AM (#44335229)
So nVidia has a huge software lead because of open source developers like you? Or because people employed by nVidia write closed source high performance drivers and kernels? Or because the people employed by Meta and Google that wrote Torch and Tensorflow built it on nVidia?

I am really sympathetic to the complaints. It would just be incredibly useful to have competition and options further down the food chain. But the argument that this is a core strategic mistake makes no sense to me.

Re:AMD's Freshly-Baked MI350: An Interview with the Chief Ar... by regularfry on Saturday June 21, 2025 @09:52AM (#44337617)
Nit: just writing Torch/TF isn't what made the difference. Having them adopted by a huge audience outside those orgs is, and that's bottlenecked on the hardware platform choice.

AMD has demonstrably not even acknowledged that they needed to play catch-up for a significant chunk of the last 20 years. The mistake isn't a recent one.

Re:AMD's Freshly-Baked MI350: An Interview with the Chief Ar... by wisty on Saturday June 21, 2025 @10:42AM (#44337975)
Also theano, keras ... nvidia made it easy to develop on so that's what people use.
Re:AMD's Freshly-Baked MI350: An Interview with the Chief Ar... by imtringued on Saturday June 21, 2025 @01:45PM (#44339331)
You don't have to beg for good software quality from Nvidia. Everything else is built on top of that foundation. That's all there is to it.
Re:AMD's Freshly-Baked MI350: An Interview with the Chief Ar... by motorest on Saturday June 21, 2025 @03:10AM (#44335326)
> if researchers don't get access to hardware X, they write their paper using hardware Y (Nvidia).

There are plenty of research institutions that can easily spend >$250k on computational resources. Many routinely spend multiples of that volume.

They'll be fine.

Re:AMD's Freshly-Baked MI350: An Interview with the Chief Ar... by impossiblefork on Saturday June 21, 2025 @06:06PM (#44341069)
Many institutions don't.

Look at China. A couple of years ago people thought people in China weren't doing good AI research, but the thing is, there's good AI research from basically everywhere-- even South America. You can't assume that institutions can spend >$250k on computational resources.

Many can, but many can't.