News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by Dylan16807 on Friday June 20, 2025 @05:39PM (#44332368)
That logic seems crazy to me. Extra hundreds of miles are also just nice to have, and with the same material that goes into a 500kg car pack you could make 10000 double life phone batteries and sell them for $100 each. There's more per-cell overhead in the phone batteries but is it worth a million dollar drop in revenue?
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by harry8 on Friday June 20, 2025 @07:37PM (#44333136)
I’m out for 2-3 days. Better take an external battery for the phone. Done.

Doesn’t work with a car.

Really easy to work around Apple’s utterly crap battery life. If it were better that would be nice to have.

Going a certain distance so can’t take an ev at all. It’d be nice if you could, if your usage is mostly very urban, sure that’s just nice. Gotta visit Dad on the farm a dozen times a year or whatever? That’s not your life so you don’t see it as essential even if the rest of the driving is much shorter range.

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by nicoburns on Friday June 20, 2025 @07:57PM (#44333254)
It really should work with a car (there's no reason why they couldn't support additional external battery packs in the trunk or as a trailer, etc).
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by harry8 on Friday June 20, 2025 @10:24PM (#44333989)
for $10, right?
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by mitthrowaway2 on Friday June 20, 2025 @11:27PM (#44334236)
Renting a U-Haul starts at $19.95 per day...
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by harry8 on Saturday June 21, 2025 @12:03AM (#44334396)
Uh. How much do car batteries cost again?
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 21, 2025 @12:37AM (#44334551)
A hell of a lot less than entire trucks.
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by harry8 on Saturday June 21, 2025 @12:49AM (#44334603)
I think maybe there’s some cross thread confusion.

The comparison I’m making is an external phone battery is $10. Replacing an ev battery is, hell i dunno, $10.000?

Not needing an external phone battery would be nice.

Needing external ev batteries is far more likely to be cost prohibitive. Adjacent to this thread people have raised size and weight issues as well. I didn’t even bother going that far because the straight up price puts it in a different ball park to an external phone battery.

Hope we’re all on the same page again!

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 21, 2025 @01:36AM (#44334806)
Right, that's the discussion up to a certain spot.

Then the GP had a counterargument to EV batteries being expensive, by suggesting you could rent one for your three day trip for a pretty small amount of money.

And not only would that charge be quite small compared to everything else going on with your car, the further you drive with the extended battery the more you save by electricity being cheaper than gasoline. And that includes having to pay for depreciation.

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by harry8 on Saturday June 21, 2025 @10:06AM (#44337720)
Well something is up because i simply do not see that counter argument anywhere in this thread. Crazy huh?
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 21, 2025 @11:11AM (#44338175)
"Renting a U-Haul starts at $19.95 per day..."

So in the scale between $10 and $10000, it would be like renting a big piece of road equipment, not buying one.

To be clear the middle paragraph of my post was explaining why they said that, and the last paragraph was me adding my own commentary. I wasn't suggesting they were implying the part about gas savings, that was all me.

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by mitthrowaway2 on Saturday June 21, 2025 @01:42PM (#44339300)
(Thank you Dylan16807, your interpretation is correct, and I apologize to harry8 because I didn't realize that my comment would read so cryptically when I wrote it).
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by harry8 on Monday June 23, 2025 @12:02AM (#44352355)
Fair enough.

Go on then, show us your estimate for the cost of renting a fully charged towable battery for 2-3 days.

I'm struggling to see it being much cheaper than renting an ev for 2-3 days if such a thing were wished into existence.

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by Dylan16807 on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @05:15PM (#44371145)
> I'm struggling to see it being much cheaper than renting an ev for 2-3 days if such a thing were wished into existence.

Even if it was the same price, lots of people don't want to rent a car, and many of the reasons they have for that don't apply to renting a battery pack.

But I'd be surprised if it wasn't a lot cheaper. If I think about a non-towed battery, it costs 1/5 as much as a car, needs 1/10 as much storage space on shelves, and can be kept in service for hundreds of thousands of miles. Towed units would be harder to store and have a bit more wear but should still be a lot smaller and cheaper than cars. A small trailer that could carry a battery is only a thousand bucks retail. You'd probably want some cooling, in the end maybe it's 1/4 the cost of a car and takes up 1/6 of a parking space? Still sounds like a cheap rental.

And as for the price of "fully charged", they can have the same price per kWh as a supercharger and have massive profit margins. So that's an amount you'd have to pay anyway and not a downside to renting.

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by margalabargala on Saturday June 21, 2025 @12:10AM (#44334426)
The reason is that batteries are heavy.

Want an extra 100 miles of range? That's 600lbs of cargo. A person can't place that in a trunk, and a trailer would probably barely extend range due to the extra drag and efficiency loss.

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by Dylan16807 on Friday June 20, 2025 @11:57PM (#44334363)
It's obviously more valuable to double the range of a car compared to a phone.

But is it multiple thousands of times more valuable? I don't think so.

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by maximus-decimus on Saturday June 21, 2025 @02:20PM (#44339588)
I don't understand your point. EV batteries won't cost multiple thousands of times more for the exact same battery that would go in a phone. If you pay 1000 times more for 1000 times more battery, I don't see the problem. If anything, they probably want 1000 times more demand so they can gain economies of scale.
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by Dylan16807 on Saturday June 21, 2025 @04:13PM (#44340423)
> If you pay 1000 times more for 1000 times more battery, I don't see the problem.

We know that "if" isn't true. That's the problem with the argument for only making EV batteries. A car battery is five thousand times as big as a phone battery and it's only hundreds of times as expensive.

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by ashdksnndck on Saturday June 21, 2025 @12:13AM (#44334432)
To fix iPhone battery life, create an automation that turns on battery save mode when battery dips below 80%. Works really well. I figure they don’t build this functionality into the settings because people would use it instead of buying a new phone when the battery degrades.
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by gmac on Saturday June 21, 2025 @04:25AM (#44335732)
Similarly, I use an automation that turns on low power mode any time the phone’s not charging. Not found any real downsides to this.
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by MostlyStable on Friday June 20, 2025 @06:08PM (#44332570)
Consumers seem to disagree with you on the first part. I personally think that current battery tech is fine for EVs (I have an EV with a 260 mile range, and only a 77kW max charge rate, and I think it's fine even for 10+ hour road trips), but a segment of the consumer space wants more than that.

I personally thought that the more interesting part of the article was where they claimed to be able to add 800 miles of range in 12 minutes. At those kinds of charge rates, my ideal EV would probably have a 300ish mile range that I could charge from 10-80 in <10 minutes (although I believe that part of the way they get those charge rates is with large battery packs, so a smaller pack would probably not charge as fast).

Additionally, while the specs for EV sedans are currently fine, batteries are only barely good enough for larger, less efficient vehicles. Maybe the killer app here isn't a sedan that goes 1000 miles, but a truck or SUV that can go 500.

The point is, whatever your and my opinions on the adequacy of current EV charging, the market seems to value improved battery specs more highly in the EV space than it does in the phone space (or maybe it doesn't and BYD is making a mistake by keeping their batteries for their cars instead of selling them to phone manufacturers).

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by actsasbuffoon on Friday June 20, 2025 @07:00PM (#44332903)
EV batteries degrade more quickly when charged too far above half-way. As a result, your ideal EV might actually have 600 miles of range and you’d just leave it half-charged most of the time.
Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by MostlyStable on Friday June 20, 2025 @08:22PM (#44333398)
From everything I've heard/read you can pretty safely go to 80-90% of listed state of charge (manufacturers often also include a hidden buffer for exactly this reason).

My car, which like I said has a 260 mile range, I only charge to 80% unless I'm going on a long road trip. So for 90%+ of the time, it's never charged more than 80% (and I very rarely discharge it to less than 15%). For most people, a 300 mile range like I describe would be plenty to be able to not need 100% charge except on rare occasions. But even if it's not for you, or for some people, I very specifically said "my ideal EV". A 600 mile range that I almost never use is just extra weight that I'm carrying around and decreasing efficiency, and isn't actually providing much real battery protection. I am absolutely not someone who drives 360 miles a day (which is what you could do if you were doing an 80% to 20% discharge on a 600 mile battery every day. I'm pretty confident that stats suggest that very few people drive that much on a regular basis. The 150 miles I get from the the 80% to 20% range on my current battery is already more than enough.

Re:BYD begins testing solid-state EV batteries in the Seal by ikt on Sunday June 22, 2025 @02:24AM (#44344347)
don’t know why you’re being downvoted, seems reasonable to me