Re:What Happens When Clergy Take Psilocybin
by bowsamic on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @07:13AM
(#44297744)
Well it isn’t a fallacy because if you reason without presuppositions you do uncover the absolute truth
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What Happens When Clergy Take Psilocybin
by haswell on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @08:58AM
(#44298599)
> if you reason without presuppositions
This cannot be accomplished, and the conclusion that such a feat leads to absolute truth is philosophically untenable.
Re:What Happens When Clergy Take Psilocybin
by bowsamic on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @12:29PM
(#44300949)
Yes it can. Hegel did it in the Science of Logic
Re:What Happens When Clergy Take Psilocybin
by haswell on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @01:01PM
(#44301259)
Many people have made philosophical claims. That does not make them categorically true, and Hegel certainly has his critics.
Re:What Happens When Clergy Take Psilocybin
by jrflowers on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @03:43PM
(#44303070)
I used to know a guy that read some Hegel and then claimed dominion over Knowing the Truth and I used to piss him off by saying shit like “dogmatic people are slaves to their fears” and “discourse is a form of oppression”
Re:What Happens When Clergy Take Psilocybin
by quesera on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @04:52PM
(#44303832)
And what elevates Hegel over any other philosopher, prophet, god, or performance artist?
Re:What Happens When Clergy Take Psilocybin
by jrflowers on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @10:19PM
(#44306093)
Hegel is extremely satisfying on an emotional level to some readers. The idea that you —yes you, the reader— not only stand at the precipice of unfettered genius by the mere fact of possessing any critical faculty, but you also already possess the requisite tools to seize and contemplate the infinite truths of the universe, is very seductive.
Like everybody loves being told that they are smart, and Hegel tells the reader that they can be superlatively intelligent. It’s a hella thrilling idea to entertain, and the best way to keep that feeling going is by believing that it’s true, and the best way to convince yourself of that is to write defenses of Hegel.