News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by Vespasian on Wednesday June 11, 2025 @11:53PM (#44254177)
Assuming that is true, does a more negative way of viewing things actually benefit you (even if it would be slightly more "accurate")?

If one has a choice (that means if there is no case of clinical depression):

At least anecdotally a bit of optimism improves my life quality a lot and results in a higher productivity, proactive solution finding and a more pleasant work environment. Constantly looking at the negative side of things (with a healthy serving of snark) contributes, in my opinion, to burnout and fatigue.

Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by farts_mckensy on Thursday June 12, 2025 @12:05AM (#44254228)
It's not difficult to imagine a number of scenarios where that perspective could bite you in the ass.

If you have a false impression of a person's character because you've jedi mindtricked yourself into not thinking the worst of people, you might end up trusting an untrustworthy person.

If you are in a toxic work environment, and you convince yourself it's not so bad, you might end up staying in a situation that is actively harming you.

We are speaking in the abstract and I can't comment on anyone else's experience. But I personally find toxic positivity and the endless drive to be more productive much more dangerous than being too negative.

Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by mlsu on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:11AM (#44254481)
The counterpoint is that seeing things “as they are” (which is the mind of a depressed person — ask me how I know) can lead you to not give people the benefit of the doubt, it can lead you to be miserly, unmerciful, pessimistic, cowardly. There is always a reason to be distrustful. But the only way good things can happen in your life is to be generous with your spirit and you should seek to do so as a matter of course, even if the rational part of your mind has inhibitions.

This isn’t to say, be foolish. But on the other hand, the mindset that leads to this kind of deprivation can be more difficult to cure, since it always appears from a place of rationality.

Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by farts_mckensy on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:32AM (#44254558)
The problem with these kinds of discussions is, we tend to get more abstract and further and further away from real-world examples. And it all hinges on what you actually value. I could come up with positive adjectives for every single negative attribute you listed. I can only speak for myself when I say that I have never regretted not giving someone the benefit of the doubt. I have regretted the contrary. Good things often just happen to people because of chance, and they attribute it to some mystical property of the universe--generosity of the spirit, for example. Conversely, being generous does not guarantee that good things will happen to you. I'm afraid it's far more random than most are willing to admit.
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by hiAndrewQuinn on Thursday June 12, 2025 @04:01AM (#44255164)
But consider, you are already agreeing to let something bite you in the ass, every moment of every day - the depression. This seems like a bad trade.

Personally I'd treat finding out my coworker intentionally stays mildly depressed to get a slight edge in their work as about akin to finding out they drink 2 or 3 beers every day ten minutes before entering the office. It probably isn't destroying their productivity right now, as I currently observe it. But what if this spirals into 5 or 6 (== what if the depression becomes worse)? What if they get themselves into another accident (== start engaging in self harm)?

Is the edge they are experiencing even real? Very few people I know who have alcoholism (depression) report being more capable at work because of it. But I have known plenty of people who have gotten fired because it turned them into people nobody else could work with.

And that's all before we even consider any possible social contagion. I don't want to slowly watch my office turn into a hall of day drinkers (phlegmatics). I'll take performative positivity any day of the week.

Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by corytheboyd on Thursday June 12, 2025 @10:29AM (#44258238)
> If you are in a toxic work environment, and you convince yourself it's not so bad, you might end up staying in a situation that is actively harming you.

I hate a toxic work environment too, but let’s be real, everything is fake at software companies, so there is no “harm” happening if you stay. So what if leadership is terrible, if you can play their little games, take their money, and not tailspin into a depression… congrats?

Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by farts_mckensy on Thursday June 12, 2025 @12:26PM (#44259594)
There's a mental cost to that. Essentially having to put on a mask and performatively "play their little games" is taxing. Some are better at it than others. But in those quiet moments, don't you ask yourself what percentage of your life you have to be a different person?
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by corytheboyd on Thursday June 12, 2025 @12:48PM (#44259861)
I ask myself a lot of things, but they all require money to do. This is just the society we made, you do some shit that doesn’t matter for a few decades, get some money, then go do whatever you want. I’m fine with it. Would I rather not do it? Absolutely!
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by farts_mckensy on Thursday June 12, 2025 @12:54PM (#44259927)
I'm saying there's a cost to that mentality. There's a personal cost, which is you giving up a part of yourself--not just your time, but your personality--to grow your net worth. And there's a societal cost to this level of cynicism being so pervasive. When the intellectual laborers of a society just go through the motions instead of being invested in what they do, the society as a whole suffers.

If you have to repeat thought eliminating clichés to justify this, it seems like there's a level of self deception going on. The chickens will come home to roost eventually.

Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by corytheboyd on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:08PM (#44260089)
Oh you’re assuming I just go through the motions. I do care about the craft of my work. Eh okay.
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by bustling-noose on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:05AM (#44254456)
I agree. While depression and negativity leads you to see things practically rather than in an optimistic and hopeful way, the quality of life and satisfaction in a little optimistic world is much better. I am yet to read Daniel Kahneman but he talks about optimism a lot.
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by mettamage on Thursday June 12, 2025 @07:27AM (#44256393)
I recommend Martin Seligman. I've read some of Kahneman's academic work. Martin Seligman changed my life with Learned Optimism.
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by bustling-noose on Thursday June 12, 2025 @08:07AM (#44256776)
Sounds like my next read. Thinking fast and slow was something I just started but it seems like something I want to read when I’m functioning better.
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by farts_mckensy on Thursday June 12, 2025 @12:35PM (#44259707)
My preferred modality: "Pessimism of the intellect, optimism of the will."
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by moffkalast on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:43AM (#44254595)
The trick is to be positive about yourself and the people you can trust, but slightly negative about the world at large.
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by vermilingua on Thursday June 12, 2025 @01:49AM (#44254619)
Unfortunately the one of the tricks of severe depression is to make you feel like that circle of people you can trust is ever-shrinking.
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by lazide on Thursday June 12, 2025 @06:50AM (#44256116)
Sometimes, unfortunately, it also is true.

The issue with all of these is that if something is a problem, it’s probably because it’s maladaptive to the actual circumstances someone is in.

And for the same reason ‘no one can tell if you’re a dog’ online, no one can tell if what you’re feeling is actually useful/adaptive or not, especially if the common root to many of the actual disorders is various degrees of bias/delusion

Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by benji-york on Thursday June 12, 2025 @06:00AM (#44255802)
Personally, I employ/enjoy a highly skeptical form of optimism.

I think things could be great, but there are many obstacles along the way to be aware of.

Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by nindalf on Thursday June 12, 2025 @06:04AM (#44255828)
That's the kind of optimistic attitude I'd expect from Emperor Vespasian, builder of the Colosseum. You're role-playing your persona really well!
Re:How Long it takes to know if a Job Is Right for You or Not by rxtexit on Thursday June 12, 2025 @07:39AM (#44256481)
It isn't true, it is obvious bullshit.

It is like making the argument that the most accurate view of life is doing nothing because we are all going to die anyway.