Yeah, nah. Fourthed!
Does anybody introduce itself like that?
It's like when your date sends subtle signals, like kicking sleeping tramps in the street and snorting the flour over bread at the restaurant.
(The shocking thing is that the expression would even make sense when taken properly - "we have organized our workflows through AI-intelligent systems" -, while at this time it easily means the opposite.)
> Does anybody introduce itself like that?
Yes, I've started getting job posts sent to me that say that.
Declaring one's company "AI-first" right now is a great time-saver: I know instantly that I can disregard those companies.
...by you. Meanwhile, plenty of us have found a way to enhance our productivity during deep work. No need for the patronization.
In my mind you cannot do deep work while being interrupted constantly, and LLM agents are constant interruptions
Deep work happens in a sensor deprivation tank. And you have to memorize everything you thought through, and write it down (with quill pen) after you emerge.
Anything else isn't really deep. Sorry, you posers.
Instead of
> Meanwhile, plenty of us have found a way to enhance our productivity during deep work. No need for the patronization.
you could have written
> Personally, I found doing X does enhance my productivity during deep work.
Why it's better: 1) cuts out the confrontation (“you're being patronizing!”), 2) offers the information directly instead of merely implying that you've found it, and 3) speaks for yourself and avoids the generalization about “plenty of people”, which could be taken as a veiled insult (“you must be living as a hermit or something”).
Next:
> You can do better than a No true Scotsman fallacy.
Even if the comment were a No True Scotsman, I would not have made that fact the central thesis of this paragraph. Instead, I might have explained the error in the argument instead. Advantages: 1) you can come out clean in the case that you might be wrong about the fallacy, and 2) the commenter might appreciate the insight.
Reason you're wrong in this case: The commenter referred entirely to their own experience and made no “true programmer” assertions.
Next:
> Essentially, this is a skill issue [...] Dunning–Kruger curve [...] chose to assume that you knew better. [...]
I would have left out these entire two paragraphs. As best as I can tell, they contain only personal attacks. As a result, the reader comes away feeling like your only purpose here is to put others down. Instead, when you wrote
> You could have asked for tips
I personally would have just written out the tips. Advantage: the reader may find it useful in the best case, and even if not, at least appreciate your contribution.
Soulofmischief’s main point is that meesles made an inappropriate generalization. Meesles said that something was impossible to do, and soulofmischief pointed out that you can't really infer that it's impossible for everyone just because you couldn't find a way. This is a perfectly valid point, but it wasn't helped by soulofmischief calling the generalization “patronizing”.
Bluefirebrand pushed back on that by merely stating that their experience and intuition match those of meesles, but soulofmischief then interpreted that as implying they're not a real programmer and called it a No True Scotsman fallacy.
It went downhill from there with soulofmischief trying to reiterate their point but only doing so in terms of insults such as the Dunning-Kruger line.
I find agent mode incredibly distracting and it does get in the way of very deep focus for implementation for myself for the work I do... but not always. It has serious value for some tasks!
It's possible that the domain or the complexity of the problems are the deciding factor for success with AI supported programming. Statements like 'you'll be left behind' or 'it's a skill issue' are as helpful as 'It fails miserably'
I think there's still room for thought augmentation via LLMs here. Years back when I used Obsidian, I created probably the first or second copilot-for-Obsidian plugin and I found it very helpful, even though GPT-3 was generally pretty awful. I still find myself in deep flow, thinking in abstract, working alongside my agent to solve deep problems in less time than I otherwise would.
pushing back against judgement and condescension is not judgemental and condescending.
> may not really exist
I'm open to reading over any resources you would like to provide, maybe it's "real", maybe it isn't, but I have personally both experienced and witnessed the effect in myself, other individuals and groups. It's a good heuristic for certain scenarios, even if it isn't necesarily generalizable.
Meanwhile, you have absolutely been judgemental and condescending yourself. If you really keep the open mind that you profess, you'll take a moment to reflect on this and not dismiss it out of hand. It does not do you any favors to blissfully assume everyone is wrong about you and obliviously continue to be judgmental and condescending.
I think if you read my own comments again you will realize I make no such assumptions at all, and have been open to criticism from those who made a genuine attempt to give feedback.
How do you work deeply with them? Looking for some tips.
Additionally, when working on microservices and on issues that don’t seem too straightforward, I use o3 and copy the whole code of the repo into the prompt and refine a plan there and then paste it as a prompt into cursor. Handy if you don’t have MAX mode, but a company-sponsored ChatGPT.
Sure, you could just add a shortcut too.
After a while, it turns into a habit.
I’m in VSCode doing my thing, and it’s in a terminal window that occasionally needs or wants my attention. I can go off and be AI-Free for as long as I like.
After a couple hours of coding something felt "weird" - turns out I forgot to login to GitHub Copilot and I was working without it the entire time. I felt a lot more proactive and confident as I wasn't waiting on the autocomplete.
Also, Cursor was exceptional at interrupting any kind of "flow" - who even wants their next cursor position predicted?
I'll probably keep Copilot disabled for now and stick to the agent-style tools like aider for boilerplate or redundant tasks.
If I give it to an llm most of my time is spent debugging and reprompting. I hate fixing someone elses bug.
Plus I like the feeling of the coding flow..wind at my back. Each keystroke putting us one step closer.
The apps I made with llms I never want to go back to but the apps I made by hand piece by piece getting a chemical reaction when problems were solved are the ones I think positively about and want to go back to.
I always did math on paper or my head and never used a calculator. Its a skill I never have forgotten and I worry how many programmers won't be able to code without llms in the future.
I'm fascinated by how different workflows are. This single feature has saved me a staggering amount of time.
Me, I use this all the time. It’s actually predictable and saves lots of time when doing similar edits in a large file. It’s about as powerful as multi-line regex search and replace, except you don’t have to write the regex.
Didn’t like any of the AI-IDEs, but loved using LLMs for spinning up one off solutions (copy/paste).
Not to be a fan boy, but Claude Code is my new LLM workflow. It’s tough trying to get it to do everything, but works really well with a targeted task on an existing code base.
Perfect harmony of a traditional code editor (Vim) with an LLM-enhanced workflow in my experience.
Or have the ai write the entire first draft for some piece and then you give it a once over, correcting it either manually or with prompts.
The AI doesn't seem to be adding any extra value? It's not like it is more accurate that SO, or that it produces answers any faster, honestly
It just is much less trustworthy imo
AI agents are much better for me because 1) they don't constantly interrupt your train of thought and 2) they can run compile, run tests, etc. to discover they are incorrect and fix it before handing the code back to you.
But I'm forced to write in Go which has a lot of boilerplate (and no, some kind of code library or whatever would not help... it's just easier to type at that point).
It's great because it helps with stuff that's too much of a hassle to talk to the AI for (just quicker to type).
I also read very fast so one line suggestions are just instant anyway (like non AI autocomplete), and longer ones I can see if it's close enough to what I was going to type anyway. And eventually it gets to the point where you just kinda know what it's going to do.
Not an amazing boost, but it does let me be lazy writing log messages and for loops and such. I think you do need to read it much faster than you can write it to be helpful though.
I think this is true but pair programming can work for most circumstances.
The times where it doesn't work is usually because one or both parties are not all-in with the process. Either someone is skeptical about pair programming and thinks it never works or they're trying to enforce a strict interpretation of pair programming.
I've been doing this a while. This is most of my work
Maybe not for many cases
I mentioned this elsewhere but I find it absolutely impossible to get into a good programming flow anymore while the LLM constantly interrupts me with suggested autocompletes that I have to stop, read, review, and accept/reject
It's been miserable trying to incorporate this into my workflow