What if I don't have an alternate HN account? Or what if I do have one, but it has barely any posts? How can you tie this account back to my identity?
Stylometry.net is down now, so it's hard to make any arguments about its effectiveness. There are fundamental limitations in the amount of information your writing style reveals.
How do you know it didn't miss 10x more than it found? Like, that's almost definitionally unprovable.
How do y’all establish ye Theory Of Stylometry, O Phrenology Majors?
O, @dang confirms it on Mastodon or something??
More seriously, why is this essential?
That language could be recognized by a deterministic finite automaton!
You're missing the point, it doesn't have to be practical, only the illusion of it working is good enough.
And if authoritarian governments believe it works well enough, they are happy to let a decent fraction of false positives fall through the cracks.
See for example, polygraph tests being used in court.
You also assume people are meticulous in taking precautions and never make mistakes. People whose access to information is restricted (such as by the great firewall of china) won't even know stylometry exists.
Even if it doesn't identify all cases, the chilling effect is enough.
Authoritarians are not known for their attention to false positive rates.
---
You didn't even try to address that dissent will be identified before it reaches a sufficiently conscious and intentional level to even consider taking precautions.
Most people don't have alts for normal usage and tying an account to IP to real person is easy for the government. The only difficulty is identifying opponents at scale.
---
Finally, please don't dismiss arguments by employing the "sufficiently snarky comment" technique.
Is this like a sufficiently smart compiler? :)
Stylometry is well-studied. You'll be happy to know that it is only practical when there are few suspect authors for a post and each author has a significant amount of text to sample. So, tying a pseudonymous post back to an author where anyone and everybody is a potential suspect is totally infeasible in the vast majority of cases. In the few cases where it is practical, it only creates a weak signal for further investigation at best.
You might enjoy the paper Adversarial Stylometry: Circumventing Authorship Recognition to Preserve Privacy and Anonymity by Greenstadt et al.