I sympathize with this viewpoint, but I do think it’s important to recognize the differences here. One thing I’ve noticed from the vibe-code coalition is a push towards offloading _cognition_. I think this is a novel distinction from industrial innovations that more or less optimize manual labor.
You could argue that moving from assembly to python is a form of cognition offloading, but it’s not quite the same in my eyes. You are still actively engaged in thinking for extended periods of time.
With agentic code bots, active thinking just isn’t the vibe. I’m not so sure that style of half-engaged work has positive outcomes for mental health and personal development (if that’s one of your goals).
We basically are training prompt engineers without post validation now.
No, this would be more akin to saying, "if we don't know how to change our car's oil anymore because we have a robot that does it, soon nobody will know, while still being reliant on our cars."
For your analogy to work, we would have to be moving away from code entirely, as we moved away from horses.
> It means that I never need to write tests any more. If I do need to write tests, for some reason (maybe because the LLM is bad at it) then I won't forget how to!
Except that once you forget, you now would have to re-learn it, and that includes potentially re-learning all the pitfalls and edge cases that aren't part of standard training manuals. And you won't be able to ask someone else, because now they all don't know either.
tl;dr coding is a key job function of software developers. Not knowing how to do any key part of your job without relying on an intermediary tool, is a very bad thing. This already happens too much, and AI is just firing the trend into the stratosphere.
OK, are we worried that all the robots will somehow disappear? Why would I have to change my own oil, ever, if the robot did it as well as I did? If it doesn't do it as well as I did, I'm still doing it myself.
No, you should be worried that you (or devs who come later, who never had to 'change the oil'/ write tests themselves) won't know if the robot has done it right or not, because if you can't do the work, you can't validate the work.
And the robot isn't an employee, it's just a tool you the employee use, so when you are asked whether the test was coded correctly, all you'd be able to say with your 'atrophied' test-writing skills is, "I think so, the AI did it". See the issue now?
> If it doesn't do it as well as I did, I'm still doing it myself.
I thought your unnecessary skill atrophied and was forgotten ? How are you going to do it yourself? How do you know you're still as good at it as you once were?
No. I use a calculator, and I don't have to second-guess it. It just works. If it didn't work reliably, I would use it.
> I thought your unnecessary skill atrophied and was forgotten ?
Again, either I didn't need to do it because the AI did it well, and I forgot the skill, or it never did it well, I always did it myself, and I never forgot it. I don't understand why you're assuming that the AI will do it well enough at first that I'll forget how it's done, and that it will then somehow get bad at it so I'll have to start doing it myself again.
If those pro players go 10 years without ever pitching a ball, they'll still know all the rote technical details on an academic/ theoretical level, but their actual pitching ability will have diminished, because skills are perishable. Coding is a skill.
Observing someone else code is not practice for coding yourself, and will not maintain (nevermind improve on) your coding skills.
So some people do develop that deeper understanding, when it's helpful, and they go on to build great things. I don't see why this will be different with AI. Some will rely too much on AI and possibly create slop, and others will learn more deeply and get better results. This is not a new phenomenon.
Critical thinking skills are skills that I think are incredibly useful and, if never taught or allowed to atrophy you can get, well, this...<gesturing dejectedly around with my cane>
People not understanding basic science, arithmetic, and reading comprehension at what was once an 8th grade level, can be easily tricked in everyday situations on matters that harm themselves, their family, and their community. If we dig deeply enough, I bet we could find some examples on this theme in modern times.
Maybe we get UBI. But if Jeff Bezos and some friends own all of the production. What would they do with your UBI dollars? Where can he spend them? He can make his own yachts and soldiers.
Who is this person who's paying for useless skills, and doesn't that go against the definition of "need"?
The day you will need troubleshoot one or simply understand it is the problem.
> do I need them, or not?
Based on this comment of yours, the answer is a resounding yes, you do.
The whole point is that these LLMs build up a dependence because your critical thinking skills need not apply when a data center can average together passable answer for you.
Yeah. And that's OK. Because nobody will need to shoe horses any more!
If I forget how to write tests, what's the problem? It means that I never need to write tests any more. If I do need to write tests, for some reason (maybe because the LLM is bad at it) then I won't forget how to!
That's how atrophy works: the skills that atrophy are, by definition, the ones you no longer need at all, and this argument does this sleight of hand where it goes "don't let the skills you don't need atrophy, because you need them!".
Well, do I need them, or not?