Meanwhile, healthcare housing and education got way more expensive and taxes for the wealthy went down.
- History of the United States public debt: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_United_States_p...
- https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2019/jul/29/tweets/rep... (2019) :
> The deficit is the difference between the money that the government makes and the money it spends. If the government spends more than it collects in revenues, then it’s running a deficit.
> The federal debt is the running total of the accumulated deficits. [Or surpluses]
"Federal Surplus or Deficit [-] (FYFSD)" https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFSD#
"Federal Surplus or Deficit [-] as Percent of Gross Domestic Product (FYFSGDA188S)" https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFSGDA188S
It's one certain party, and the situation is worse than that -- they don't want any of the opposing party's legislation succeed that would be recognized by the people as a good thing and make that party look good.
This is why partisan politics is a pox on the people -- loyalty to party over country is literally treason but is celebrated by party members.
We could have higher taxes on the wealthy and good healthcare. But to do that, the side that claims they want that and that they believe in "democracy" would have to not only post on Bluesky about it, they'd have to (A) vote, and (B) convince (rather than demonize) the moderates who are skeptical of them. We'll see in a while if they learned that lesson from 2024.
It stinks and we should change it, but until then one needs to do a simple weighing of options and cast a best effort ballot.
The website seems to indicate that the government functioning well is not divisive, when in fact it is divisive as not everyone agrees with that being a good thing.
"Oh everything is terrible and it's only going to be terrible so I don't have to do anything to improve anything and actually it's a good thing that things are terrible". It's just a justification to do nothing and wrap it with some pseudo-intellectual clothing.
I've become a grumpy cynical (and sometimes fatalistic) man as I approach middle-age, but I think a lot of that is just trying to justify my laziness most of the time.
It requires effort to care about stuff even after bad shit has happened to you. It requires effort to look for the best in situations. It requires effort to think that maybe tomorrow could be better. It's easy to just say "fuck it, I don't care".
I find it funny, because so many people proclaim these edgy fatalistic takes, and I think that they think it makes them look cool, but fundamentally it has the absolute opposite effect for me. When I see an older person who still seems to actively care about things (even though I'm sure they've been fucked over by life like the rest of us) that is cool to me.
All of this is 100% true, but it's also incredibly draining after literal decades of being on the wrong end of abuse and hatred purely for daring to care, and hope, and try desperately to make anything even the tiniest bit better. After a point, it eventually becomes just too much effort for zero (or negative) return.
This is why I respect old people who seem to still manage to be stay optimistic and trusting of people in the world. I don’t think that’s “natural”, I think it’s an effort that these people put into seeing the world as a potentially good place.
Oh, the world is an absolutely amazing place. It's just a shame that only a handful of humans really seem to notice and / or care. The rest either take it for granted or want to strip-mine it for profit at any cost. :(
The IRS site in general is massively better now than 5 years ago, for example.
The point is that the idea that this organization existing was an unqualified good thing is a matter of opinion, not fact.
You’re allowed to have that opinion, but presenting it as fact is the part that I have an issue with.
From TFA:
> After all, having a government that functions and delivers on its promises to the public shouldn’t be divisive.
The only POTUS who wasn’t a “wolf in sheep's clothing” was George Washington.
Looks like what the country actually wants is authoritarianism, so maybe he was just the right politician in the wrong country.
He ran on a "change" platform but failed to deliver change. He propped up the rich and shot down any sort of possible ideas that would meaningfully change anything despite being given once in a generation mandate.
It dissolutioned a lot of voters, and lead to where we are now where people are desperate enough to want a strongman outsider who promises to really shake things up.
If we had gotten an actual progressive instead of a textbook neoliberal things might have been different.
LOL, no.
> bailed out the banks at our expense
TARP was passed during Bush's administration.
> expanded warrantless NSA surveillance
This is exactly the opposite of what he did. According to Snowden's leaks, he had already shut down email metadata collection soon after he took office. After Snowden's leaks, he limited and then shut down mass phone metadata collection.
> He shut down Occupy Wall Street hard,
Obama doesn't control local police. That's Bloomberg's jurisdiction.
> bailed out the banks at our expense
Putting aside that EESA was passed by GWB instead of Obama, that's like complaining that somebody educated the kids at our expense. What would have happened otherwise? Obama passed Dodd-Frank banking regulation to try to prevent this from happening again.
> wasted the biggest wave of progressive energy on a Republican's healthcare plan
That originally had a public option that couldn't go through because people like you were fooled into not voting in the midterms. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/07/11/4852289...
> successfully pushing for Hillary Clinton to run
Obama famously stayed out of the 2016 primary until Clinton was the presumptive nominee in June.
The dems are in a weird place because they have to both give lip service to their base while also doing the exact opposite.
The alternative to bailing out the banks is bailing out the people who had money in the banks. I'm mad they got away with their crimes then and I'm mad again that Biden saved Silicon Valley Bank. The execs should have gone to jail or worse and instead they got a cool trillion dollars.
Certainly Obama didn't give in to any of OWS's demands. The income gap got wider under his presidency too. The rich kept getting richer. And money sure didn't get out of politics. I'm happy to blame all the dems for being corporate stooges not just Obama.
and ofc he pushed hard for the TPP- which even the senate seemed to think was too corporate.
The plan was bit for bit Romney's. Even with the public option which he floundered on it wouldn't have brought us up to Europe. And I can't think of any other accomplishments he had with his supermajority. We didn't even codify Roe. "Change" seems to be one tolerable healthcare plan over eight years. If Trump can restructure the whole government with barely a majority I'm happy to blame Obama and the rest of the feckless do do-nothing dems for changing basically nothing with a supermajority.
& The story I heard is Biden wanted to run but Obama talked him out of it because he thought Biden was too far left.
Nothing in that Wikipedia article disagrees with what I wrote.
> The alternative to bailing out the banks is bailing out the people who had money in the banks
At the scale of the 2008 financial crisis, figuring out individual investors to help recover from bad assets is going to be far more costly than simply keeping the banks solvent.
> I'm mad they got away with their crimes then and I'm mad again that Biden saved Silicon Valley Bank
That also didn't happen. SVB is gone.
> The income gap got wider under his presidency too.
There's only so much he can do without Congress, but income inequality had begun to decrease towards the end of his presidency. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-income-gap-began-to...
> and ofc he pushed hard for the TPP- which even the senate seemed to think was too corporate.
TPP was a trade deal to increase trade between Asian countries (excluding China) and the US to reduce trade dependence between the signatory countries and China. The US negotiates provisions to ensure worker and environmental protections that these countries are not incentivized to do otherwise. Trump's withdrawal from the TPP was a disaster.
> Even with the public option which he floundered on it wouldn't have brought us up to Europe
Read the link I posted in my previous comment. Obama didn't even have the votes for a public option. Completely overhauling the medical funding system from scratch was and remains a nonstarter, both politically and logistically. A growing public option could have gradually led to a Medicare-for-All system.
> If Trump can restructure the whole government with barely a majority.
He also has the SC, which Obama never had, giving him sweeping executive power.
SVB doesn't exist in name, but they sure pulled all the stops to save the day with free money (from everyone else! I don't care if its from a tax on income or the arguably more regressive tax on all bank account holders that they went with)
The companies who put their money in the bank uninsured were taking a risk and rather than face any consequence the government decided to swoop in and bail them out.
Imagine this happening to an individual who had any sort of uninsured catastrophe.
My memory of the TPP at the time was that it forced countries to extend copyright to match our draconian measures and let companies sue countries if their laws caused lost profits.
Re: inequality, & congress, he had a super majority. I read the article, it was fine? But I don't remember there being any sort of big comeuppance. Obamas financed by the same billionaires as everyone else.
For the public option they did have the votes if they were willing to get rid of the filibuster.
& if the problem was the courts, the Democrats had a way to change that but they decided not to and refused to ever even speculate about doing so.
You originally said he expanded warrantless NSA surveillance. He did not. He contracted it in 2010 by stopping email metadata collection, as Snowden's leaks showed, and again in 2015 by stopping phone metadata collection.
> The companies who put their money in the bank uninsured were taking a risk and rather than face any consequence the government decided to swoop in and bail them out.
> Imagine this happening to an individual who had any sort of uninsured catastrophe.
Every company with more than $250k in deposits has uninsured deposits, and any company with Silicon Valley software engineers on its payroll is going to need more than $250k in deposits. The Fed did exactly what you suggested they do in the 2008 case. They guaranteed all deposits. The exact same reasoning for why you supported it in the first case applies to the second (the employees of these startups have to get paid), and there is no complexity from debts being repackaged and sold back and forth because it was all in Treasury bills. An individual with money at SVB would also have their deposits guaranteed.
> My memory of the TPP at the time was that it forced countries to extend copyright to match our draconian measures and let companies sue countries if their laws caused lost profits.
Standardizing on life+70 copyright was a very small part of the agreement. The main thing was that it cut thousands of tariffs. It also required signatories to criminalize bribery of public officials and enforce anti-corruptipn laws, putting US companies on even footing with companies in countries that don't have an FCPA equivalent, and generally improving governance in many countries. It also prohibited child labor and employment discrimination and ensured the right to collective bargaining. ISDS was an enforcement mechanism for all of these, not just IP protection.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Pacific_Partnership#Cont...
> But I don't remember there being any sort of big comeuppance. Obamas financed by the same billionaires as everyone else.
Different billionaires. The healthcare billionaires didn't like the public option.
> For the public option they did have the votes if they were willing to get rid of the filibuster.
No, they did not. Moderate Democrats were against it. Electing a few more Democrats from places without a big health insurance industry presence would have made the public option possible.
> if the problem was the courts, the Democrats had a way to change that but they decided not to and refused to ever even speculate about doing so
They did not have the votes to rewrite the constitution.
Re: SVB, I still think its important that the main customers for the bank were companies and not individuals. Particularly that they were evil silicon valley companies. I was rooting for them to go bust for their arrogance and they got bailed out regardless. Better than also bailing out the bank's investors too so it could have been worse.
Re: TPP, I believe you that there's more to it. The hubub I heard about it at the time was mostly on the IP stuff and the power it gave to companies over countries.
I guess the point I stand behind is that he had eight years and accomplished one very compromised insurance bill and not a ton else.
Yes, Obama could have done more with a better congress, and maybe Biden could have passed BBB with one too.
But in general the goal of the Democratic Party seems to be either ignoring or working directly against most agendas I have: - Ending the police state - Stopping the genocide in Gaza - Getting money out of politics - Reigning in corporations dramatically - An end to oil - Equal rights for all - An end to billionaires
And imo. Obama accomplished very little of that, and didn't even call for half of it.
Neither did Biden.
And while both of them seem to have most of the same agenda as Reagan (free trade, low corporate taxes, no worker protection, trickle down economics, messing with other countries via monetary theory) they're at least a step above the rest of Dem leadership which I consider entirety hostile.
I don't believe Obama would have ended the filibuster or stacked the courts even if given the chance. He never called for it.
I am not sure it works like that. Destruction is easy, building is hard.
This is not an official US government website.
This one down below is, tho
We just need it, there’s no question of the benefits and there were no negatives to speak about.
Thank you President Barack Obama! A true leader and patriot.