A button that always shares content with the general public should be called "Publish".
(We'll discuss cache invalidation next time.)
And shared ChatGPT chats are often indexed by Google, so they become public. Although I agree it's not exactly the same because of the lack of builtin discovery
As for google I assume it’s true if you post your chat somewhere (I.e Reddit). For most of shares these chats never end up being on the internet (I.e stay in private chats in messengers). So it is different again.
Overall it is pretty much predator behavior exploiting people’s need to share their chats to get them doing something unintended and good for Meta. This being said whole idea of an app with chats as posts is quite lame, so not sure if it will stick.
Do you mean creating the sharing link would make the chat log public? It will be interesting to read other people's chat on a specific topic, but googling "topic site:chatgpt.com" seems to just return Custom GPT stuff.
I didn't know this. I think I have used share button to share chats with personal stuffs with close people thinking that the chat is as close as possible to "unlisted" youtube videos. Hope that OpenAI implements something similar or even something with a password.
I think Meta fully expected this feature to be used by people who are excited about their conversation with the AI and wants to share it publicly. Just like we see with OpenAI Sora.
There's not much to win for Meta if users instead are unknowingly sharing deeply personal conversations.
That's really what you think? And what they think? That people are so enamored - in droves - with their exchange with a chatbot that they're trying to share it for the world to see?
Maybe I'm the old fogey who doesn't get it, but it's just hard for me to believe that this is something many people want, or something that smart people think others earnestly want. Again, I may be the outlier here, but this just sounds crazy to me.
I don't personally think the feature makes a lot of sense in Meta AI.
However it's a lot more likely their product team genuinely thought it might do, than it is likely they intentionally wanted to give users a bad experience and risk more bad press (again, Meta would benefit nothing from people sharing by mistake).
It has problems for sure, but if you aren't "enamored" with AI then I don't think you've actually tried to use it.
I am incredulous that a primary use case of a genAI chatbot is sharing your chat conversation publicly. It's easy to see why people would do this for genAI images, videos, or even code; I even understand some occasional sharing of a chat exchange from time to time. But routine, regular interest, from regular people, of just sharing their text chat? I do not understand that at all.
META expectations=/= expectations of a reasonable human that has used other "share" buttons before.
Sharing to a text message is private. In contrast, sharing to social media platforms such as Twitter, Reddit, Pinterest, and LinkedIn makes the content public. The destination determines the audience.
That is the TYPICAL share behaviour. If what META is doing with their new app is obscuring this typical behaviour and a "share" click directly going to the public, that would violate the defacto behaviour users are accustomed to when using the share button.
It just opens a modal so you can choose to post. You have to make a second click to confirm.
If you index on chat apps, you're correct, if you start from Meta's social apps, which they said they have, you are incorrect.
It seems to be mostly generated pictures though.
To think that anything used on AI is going to stay private is nice, but not likely.
I agree with you that privacy right now is fragile at best. Disagree that it needs to be.
Please explain. I don't think that privacy should ever be fragile.
https://www.cnet.com/tech/services-and-software/184-million-...
> The records exhibit multiple signs that the exposed data was harvested by some type of infostealer malware.
Maybe. Maybe today, maybe tomorrow.
As others have mentioned, the core problem with Meta today is the dark patterns. They move, edit, and remove UI elements specifically to optimize against whatever behavior they want the user to take. I'm always amazed when things end up posted, shared, or alterated in a way I did not intened or can't even remember having taken an action against. Things just seem to happen with Meta products… even for accounts that are idle.
And if you spend enough time with Meta products, you'll start to realize that no two users are guaranteed to have the same experience. There is no standard experience. The experience changes based on region and langauge and honestly who knows what else. They are constantly testing and optimizing for dark patterns in production. Spend an hour with the Meta Business Suite. The entire platform is essentially a dark pattern labyrinth of broken links, broken features, and UI elements that go nowhere or to deprecated functions. One team is trying to get you do X and use feature Y, and another team is trying to get you to do Z and use feature W. Business Suite just mashes it all together. You could freeze the codebase today and study Business Suite for months and you'd find that it's dark patterns all the way down.
> Meta shouldn't have to do this
And couldn't either. How would they know if users shared unknowingly?
Why would Mozilla integrate a random 3rd party service without asking?
Why would Mozilla send your browsing history to Cliqz?
Why would Mozilla integrate Google tracking without ability to block?
Why would Mozilla sell your data?
Why would Mozilla install a telemetry service that gets reenabled after update even if you disabled it?
Why would Mozilla lie like this?
Because it's Mozilla.
In the app there is a "Share" button at the top right. After clicking you see an interstitial with a big "Post" button at the bottom. When you click that button, the chat is shared.
Am I seeing something different than anybody else? Why would Mozilla lie like this? Most of the "demands" are already satisfied.
> Shut down the Discover feed until real privacy protections are in place.
Everything is already private by default and you can see what is public.
> Make all AI interactions private by default with no public sharing option unless explicitly enabled through informed consent.
This is true already
> Provide full transparency about how many users have unknowingly shared private information.
Meta shouldn't have to do this
> Create a universal, easy-to-use opt-out system for all Meta platforms that prevents user data from being used for AI training.
This already exists (EDIT, looks like only for EU users. Personally I don't believe this is related to the public sharing claims)
> Notify all users whose conversations may have been made public, and allow them to delete their content permanently.
This already exists