Putin (Russia) is to blame for the war, but that's irrelevant to this issue. Ukraine is still responsible for the consequences of its actions. Putin starting the war makes it legitimate for Ukraine to assassinate Putin, for example; but if killing Putin makes Ukraine less safe or causes other negative outcomes, Ukraine is responsible for choosing the best set of outcomes. Maybe Russia will use tactical nukes - is that what Ukraine wants? They need to assess the risks and make the best choice; blame is irrelevant.
be careful whom you are advising to back down in fear.
Why not find solutions that work?
> back down in fear.
It's not about fear - it's not about blame, or 'should', or anything but consequences, lives and property, blood and treasure. The destruction of a war with Russia would be immense.
Why don't you find solutions that protect Ukraine and prevent war with Russia?
Your proposal?
Ukraine does have to balance nuclear stability, and I expect they have - I can't say if they made the right choice, but it's a very serious question. On HN people can dismiss it in a thousand ways, but it's not a serious analysis.
I would guess that the primary things that should happen are,
NATO, especially the US, needs to make it clear that they will spend whatever it takes for however long it takes to win. If Russia believed that, they would leave Ukraine now. NATO and the US have order of magnitude more economic resources than Russia - Russia can't compete if NATO seriously invests.
And Ukranians need to defend their country. A large portion of their population refuses to fight. That undermines manpower, a critical issue; it raises questions in Russia's mind about Ukraine's motivation to win, which prolongs the war; and it must raise questions in international leaders' minds (though none talk about it, I would guess so they don't undermine support for Ukraine).
I don't know that either of those things will happen, and the status quo sadly continues.
For me, NATO needs to secure the left of the Dnipro river. This would free up manpower and material on Ukraines side, to fully focus on the front-lines. It would also send a clear message to Russia that we mean business.
Also, when Russian jets fly over NATO territory, they should be shot down, just like Turkey did.
I have the feeling the West is giving enough material for Ukraine to survive, but not enough to really push back.
Offensive use of nukes, even implicitly threatening offensive use of nukes, is a step too far for everybody.
The bandwagon to war, which is what you've joined, is the biggest mistake you can make. Almost no dynamic - maybe besides ethnic nationalism - kills more people and destroys more societies and nations.
It is not. This is what you're asking from Ukraine.
Unlike you, I want this war to end in a way that it doesn't pop up again in a few years. Russia has a long history of wars of aggression. In the past two decades, they took land from Georgia in 2008 and got away with it. Took Crimea and the Donbas in 2014 and got away with it. Do you really think Putin will stop if this invasion will also turn out to be successful?
Demanding Ukraine to surrender will only strengthen Putin and his belief that he can continue waging war. Rewarding him with more land will no more deter him from further aggression than it did with Hitler in 1938 and 1939.
This is the best opportunity to stop him and prevent WW3. Every expert recognizes this. It's only Putin's propaganda that tries to convince us that surrendering to him will somehow being peace. But if you listen to what Russian media and politicians are saying, you'll hear that they're already talking about Moldova, Lithuania, Estonia and even Poland. Putin has spoken about his desire for a Eurasian empire from Vladivostok to Lisbon. That might sound ridiculous, but he could get it if people keep surrendering land to him. The only way to stop him is to stop him.
> This is what you're asking from Ukraine.
No, life isn't as simple as you want it to be. You need to make decisions that accomplish and balance many complex problems. 'It's the other person's fault' may simplify things in your mind, but your failure to make a good decision will have the same outcome regardless.
And the fact that Ukraine is so unwilling to condemn their future generations to Putin's oppression is a massive stroke of luck for other European countries who might otherwise be next in Putin's plans. Keeping the war confined to Ukraine and ensuring a Ukrainian win there, is by far the best option for European security. Strengthening Putin is the worst option, and giving him a victory here will do exactly that.
The consequences are no different than when we tried that in the 30s. Appeasement doesn't work. Bullies and madmen only respect force.
If "neener neener I'll nuke you" works for Putin to take literally all of Ukraine, why would they stop? Why wouldn't China take something? Why wouldn't India? Why wouldn't the US?
PACO Putin and his shills like you who spread their belligerent saber rattling propaganda are notorious for threatening nuclear war at the drop of a hat, exactly like TACO Trump and his shills' singular and predictable move is bluffing about nuclear tariffs, mass deportations, throwing political opponents in jail, annexing Canada, invading Greenland, filing frivolous lawsuits, building walls, getting Mexico to pay for it, canceling Obamacare, and rolling out a mythical health care plan any day now, and then every single time chickening out and never delivering, like clockwork.
Speaking of setting your watch by it, as I write this, Amsterdam is testing its air raid sirens at noon on the first weekday of the month, just like clockwork. And I am familiar enough with the pattern that I don't shit my pants and duck and cover.
Maybe there's a reason Russia named it the BUK BUK BUK Missile System, which they smuggled across Ukraine's border and shot down MH17 with -- a plane with 298 innocent civilians, the Netherland's 9/11: because it's a chicken's weapon they used for a cowardly attack against defenseless civilians, which they still deny responsibility for in the face of overwhelming hard evidence. If that doesn't prove you can't trust a word Putin says, how much more evidence do you need?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buk_missile_system
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_17
Even RACO Reagan's most ardent supporters admit that SDI was a bluff, and as someone who grew up within the blast radius of Washington DC during the 80's, I am sick and tired of listing to hyperbolic belligerent bullshit like "My fellow Americans, I'm pleased to tell you I just signed legislation which outlaws Russia forever. The bombing begins in five minutes."
https://www.upi.com/Top_News/World-News/2014/08/11/Flashback...
>"Reagan blurts out what he is thinking, that is, to outlaw Russia and to start bombing in five minutes. This is a joke. But this is also a secret dream which was allowed to escape. It is simple-mindedness, mildly speaking, which characterizes the view of the president on world problems."
Reagan's bluffs and blusters may have led to the downfall of the Soviet Union, but that's because they were gullible, totally fell for it hook line and sinker, and now that Putin's learned from that, it's the only trick he has in his book, because he realized how well it worked on him for Reagan. And Putin certainly knows he doesn't need to fear a cluck that comes out of his pet TACO's beak.
You're not only gullibly FALLING FOR IT, you're actually AMPLIFYING and perversely PERPETUATING it, the textbook definition of an unwitting useful idiot, putty in Putin's hands.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_risk_during_the_Russia...
Russia repeatedly threatens nuclear escalation whenever things don't go their way, routinely rattling their nuclear sabers with aggressive rhetoric from Putin, Medvedev, and Lavrov. Despite these dire warnings and bold "red lines," each threat has ultimately fizzled out with Russia retreating quietly, making the entire ordeal seem more like theatrical posturing than genuine strategy. Every time they've hinted at nuclear strikes or global annihilation as retaliation, reality sets in, they chicken out, and the world moves on—until Russia inevitably tries the same bluff again.
2022 February 27: President Putin placed Russia's nuclear forces on high alert, warning of unprecedented consequences if the West intervened in Ukraine. Despite the escalation, no nuclear actions followed.
2022 April 24: Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov warned of a "real" danger of nuclear war, cautioning the West against underestimating the risks. The threat was not acted upon.
2022 May 12: Dmitry Medvedev stated that NATO's military aid to Ukraine increased the risk of a full-scale nuclear war. No nuclear measures were taken.
2022 September 21: President Putin announced partial mobilization and threatened nuclear retaliation if Russia's territorial integrity was threatened. The nuclear threat did not materialize.
2023 March 25: President Putin declared plans to deploy tactical nuclear weapons in Belarus, marking the first such deployment outside Russia since the Soviet era. The weapons were stationed but not used.
2023 July 30: Medvedev warned that a successful Ukrainian counteroffensive could compel Russia to use nuclear weapons to defend its territory. No nuclear action ensued.
2023 October 1: Medvedev threatened that British soldiers training Ukrainian troops would be legitimate targets, implying potential nuclear escalation. The threat was not acted upon.
2024 February 25: President Putin suspended Russia's participation in the New START treaty, citing U.S. and NATO actions as threats to Russian security. No nuclear deployments or tests followed.
2024 September 25: President Putin warned that any conventional attack on Russia could provoke a nuclear response, signaling a shift in nuclear doctrine. The warning did not lead to any nuclear action.
2025 June 1: Following Ukraine's drone strikes on Russian airbases, Russian officials, including Medvedev, issued renewed nuclear threats. No nuclear response occurred.
Why don't you change your opinions since they are indefensible, and you're demeaning yourself as Putin's useful idiot by continuing to hold them in the face of proof that you're wrong?
It's a bit naive to think you should avoid escalation now to risk an even higher risk in 20 years.
Russia can stop this war at any moment. It's fully their decision if they want to shoot nukes or not. None of the consequences of military operations of Ukraine should be placed in their shoes. And you claim you are not blaming Ukraine, but on the other hand you actually are.
Blame Putin for being a vicious bully, not the kids he's brutalizing for provoking him by defending themself from the assault.