News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by rw on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @01:56AM (#441490)
> "The interesting issues are social and legal," says Mikolaj Habryn, a site reliability engineer at Google. "You'll get slavery. You'll get drug dealing. Maybe there'll be polygamous Mormons. The first people involved will inevitably be those who want to do things they can't do on land, and we have to deal with that."

Is total laissez-faire at all desirable?

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @07:28AM (#441657)
Well, let's see.

Experimenting with various forms of government is what got you to where you are today.

Should we continue? Or is the system of government we have (wherever we are) the most perfect we could ever hope for?

There's no reason to think mankind must always get worse. From time to time he'll get better. "laissez-faire", in this context, is non-sensical, ie, there is no government to allow anything. The concept is beyond that.

Personally, I think some form of representative republic with three branches of government with checks and balances is the right way to go. But even in the U.S., we have virtually a permanent legislative branch by gerrymandering, an executive that is split between only two political parties for over 140 years, and a court system that seems to misunderstand its own role. Is there a reboot button? A way to start over, with perhaps time-limits on laws, a constitutional balanced-budget amendment, (insert own ideas here)

New ideas, even ones which are scary dangerous, are not to be feared. No new ideas? That's what to be afraid of.

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by anamax on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @10:10AM (#441784)
> Is total laissez-faire at all desirable?

Why do you care if someone else picks that option?

> You'll get drug dealing. Maybe there'll be polygamous Mormons.

So what?

Even if you choose to live in one of those societies, you don't have to deal (or use) drugs or "marry different".

If your choices are actually superior, you'll prevail over those who made different ones. Why isn't that enough? And, if your choices are not actually better, why are you unwilling to let them prevail....

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by pietro on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @02:23AM (#441499)
Seasteading is one way to find out.
Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by davidw on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @06:39AM (#441624)
I am not a libertarian, and think there are serious flaws with their reasoning. However, I think it's great that they're willing to go try and build something of their own. That solves a lot of problems of trying to convince everyone else to do things their way, so I really hope it goes well for them.
Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by gaius on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @08:22AM (#441684)
I am sick of people tarring Libertarianism with the Anarcho-Capitalist brush. There will not be slaves under a Libertarian government because the #1 responsibility of a Libertarian government and the duty of every good Libertarian citizen is to act to prevent coercion. With decisive physical force if necessary. Maximization of societal freedom, not individual wealth, is the Libertarian goal.

There might be indentured labour of course, but that's a whole 'nother discussion.

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by davidw on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @08:51AM (#441699)
Err.. ok, but you could have attached that to a different comment. I wasn't talking about slavery or anything, just that I'm not a libertarian, and think it has issues. Slavery probably isn't one of them.
Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by cturner on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @12:42PM (#441948)
Hmm. But what about bankruptsy? Is it compatible with strong libertarianism? If you outlaw slavery in itself, would effective slavery emerge?
Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by Prrometheus on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @11:09AM (#441854)
To belabor a common libertarian point: one virtue of the marketplace is choice. Different individuals can make different choices. This has advantages over the political system, where one choice is made for everybody.

Maybe you think Social Security is a poor investment for 14% of your income, maybe you think your local school should offer more courses in area X. Too bad. If you don't have a 51% majority, a person willing to run as a political candidate that agrees with you, two years to campaign, and millions to billions of dollars, you won't get your choice.

However, in the market for retirement products you just call up your broker. In the market for schools, you just pick the one you like best (admittedly choice is a little lacking in the school market, due to a government near-monopoly and heavy regulation).

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by davidw on Wednesday January 21, 2009 @04:55AM (#443021)
> made for everybody.

For, and by everyone (or nearly everyone), which does confer on it some amount of legitimacy. Still though, I agree that if people are able to go off and try new things, that's a good thing.

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by Prrometheus on Wednesday January 21, 2009 @12:40PM (#443507)
My sister can tell you how little a democratic voice matters from 18 years of getting outvoted by my brother and I. The Tamils in Sri Lanka, the Chinese in Malaysia, and the Sunnis in Iraq might also disagree with you about the legitimacy of mob-rules democracy.

I really don't see why people think they have some "input" in democratic decisions, other than decades of conditioning in schools run by a democratic government. Try submitting a story and getting it to the front page of Digg. You have approximately zero chance. Your influence over public policy is much, much smaller.

Once you realize that there are more than two choices for any given policy decision, in fact there are almost as many choices as there are people, then you realize how incredibly farcical your "democratic voice" is.

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by shiny on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @03:15AM (#441533)
I don't see how there would be slavery. The only people living on a seastead would be those who wanted to. I don't know how they would get slaves to come with them.

And yeah, if you don't like laissez-faire, you don't have to join a seastead that practices it. That's the whole point -- choosing your system of government.

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by gravitycop on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @03:23AM (#441537)
I don't see how there would be slavery. The only people living on a seastead would be those who wanted to. I don't know how they would get slaves to come with them.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Trafficking

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by dichro on Friday February 06, 2009 @04:41PM (#470422)
(My kibo alert has failed me, and it's far too late to comment here, but I will anyway)

Lots of situations can be interpreted as slavery, and a lot of the creative interpretations are likely to revolve around children.

The quoted comment shorn of conversational context wasn't all that illuminating, so I expanded on it here: http://syncretin.livejournal.com/73427.html

Re:Live Free or Drown: Floating Utopias on the Cheap by streety on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @07:06AM (#441645)
With the exception of slavery that quote seems to be on the tame side of what's being suggested.

The result of one of their brain storming sessions: http://www.flickr.com/photos/9742300@N06/2946735005/