News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by panick21_ on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @09:08AM (#44106609)
PowerPC and POWER are not the same. PowerPC was created because Apple allied with IBM, but they wanted Motorola as a supplier. So they basically changed Motorola own RISC chip into something POWER like.

OpenPOWER used to be restricted, but because RISC-V absolutely crush the OpenPOWER fake marketing with being really open, OpenPOWER (like MIPS) after a few years have changed and are now more like RISC-V.

Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by MisterTea on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @09:57AM (#44107072)
No, The AIM alliance's goal was to create a standard Power architecture: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AIM_alliance

PPC Mac is the same PPC that Motorola developed and marketed. The key difference lies in the platform as Power PC is just a CPU ISA, it does not define a platform which includes hardware layout and booting. So you cant just buy a Motorola chip and boot MacOS because MacOS expects a Power Macintosh complete with Power Macintosh hardware and firmware.

Arm and Risc-V also do not define a platform. IBM is the one who developed a standard hardware and firmware design, the BIOS, for the Intel 8086 and thus the PC was born. The PC platform is why we think of computers as general purpose machine that boot any OS. Outside of that ecosystem it's a big mess. Arm and Risc-v do not define platforms which is not a good situation.

Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by Y_Y on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @12:52PM (#44108657)
Arm does indeed define a platform, it's called SBSA

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Server_Base_System_Architectur...

Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by lizknope on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @03:09PM (#44109837)
You are right but the only systems I have seen that support it are servers or expensive workstations from Ampere and maybe 1 or 2 others. I feel like 99% of the ARM based computing devices that people can buy for under $2000 have non standard boot systems. Do any of the Qualcomm ARM based laptops support an open boto standard?

In contrast I feel like 99% of x86 based computing devices under $2000 have standard boot systems where anyone can boot windows or Linux on them with minimal issues.

Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by MisterTea on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @06:04PM (#44111045)
Please point me to a cost effective general purpose Arm computer that uses SBSA.
Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by Y_Y on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @03:26AM (#44113508)
Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by MisterTea on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @09:38AM (#44115926)
I know this board and it is not general purpose. This is not designed to watch videos, play games or browse the web. Again, show me a general purpose Arm computer that is made for the average user.
Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by lizknope on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @04:53PM (#44120554)
It looks like something for a router or network switch. No graphics but it does have an open PCIE x8 slot. The ARM A72 is now a 9 year old CPU core. The reviews of this board are all from 4 years ago. It looks like their newer similar products have a Ryzen core that is a lot faster.

Here is an Ampere workstation but it is $3300. In my other post in this thread I mentioned $2000 as the price limit. Most consumers are not going to spend more than that on a computer.

https://system76.com/desktops/thelio-astra-a1.1-n1/configure

Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by snvzz on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @09:32PM (#44112068)
>RISC-V do not define a platform.

With a very strictly narrow lens, RISC-V is just the ISA.

In reality, a major part of RISC-V International standardization effort goes into non-ISA specs, which include the platform specs, a major focus from early on.

This is e.g. how I am able to run my VisionFive2 with a generic Debian kernel. It would be unthinkable on ARM.

Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by MisterTea on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @12:47PM (#44117949)
It's unfortunate that the spec avoided designing a clean solution to a simple problem and drags in the complexity of PC baggage such as ACPI and UEFI to avoid doing work.
Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by snvzz on Friday May 30, 2025 @01:48AM (#44133277)
>to avoid doing work

The problem with "doing work" is that work does take time.

Being late means widespread non-standardized, bespoke vendor specific solutions. Exactly the one thing RISC-V International strongly wants to avoid.

Won't go into judging ACPI and UEFI, and how misunderstood or desirable they are.

RISC-V chose to adopt these, and to standardize what the baseline platform is, and specify how ACPI and UEFI are implemented.

Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by panick21_ on Friday May 30, 2025 @12:43PM (#44137914)
Even if some their ideas are desirable, the execution very much isn't.
Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by sillywalk on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @02:49PM (#44109648)
> PowerPC and POWER are not the same.

AIUI PowerPC is essentially an extended (original) POWER.

The AIM alliance defined PowerPC which had 32bit and 64 bit modes, and IBM also added ISA extensions - the PowerPC AS or "Amazon" - for its AS/400 line.

When the POWER3 came around, the original 32Bit POWER ISA was deprecated, but still included for backwards compatibility. So all POWER chips since then implement the PowerPC ISA.

Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP... by panick21_ on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @04:35AM (#44113906)
Thanks for clearing that up.