Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP...
by MisterTea on Wednesday May 28, 2025 @12:47PM
(#44117949)
It's unfortunate that the spec avoided designing a clean solution to a simple problem and drags in the complexity of PC baggage such as ACPI and UEFI to avoid doing work.
Re:OpenPOWER Foundation – Open-Source / Open Hardware PowerP...
by snvzz on Friday May 30, 2025 @01:48AM
(#44133277)
>to avoid doing work
The problem with "doing work" is that work does take time.
Being late means widespread non-standardized, bespoke vendor specific solutions. Exactly the one thing RISC-V International strongly wants to avoid.
Won't go into judging ACPI and UEFI, and how misunderstood or desirable they are.
RISC-V chose to adopt these, and to standardize what the baseline platform is, and specify how ACPI and UEFI are implemented.
With a very strictly narrow lens, RISC-V is just the ISA.
In reality, a major part of RISC-V International standardization effort goes into non-ISA specs, which include the platform specs, a major focus from early on.
This is e.g. how I am able to run my VisionFive2 with a generic Debian kernel. It would be unthinkable on ARM.