The companies that fire workers and replace them with AI are short sighted. Eventually, smarter companies will realize its a force multiplier and will drive a hiring boom.
Absent sentient AI, there will always be gaps and things humans will need to fill, both foreseen and unforeseen.
I think in the short term, there will be pain, but overall in the long term, humans will still be gainfully employed, it won't per se look like it does now, much like we saw the general adoption of the computer in the workplace, resources get shifted and eventually everyone adjusts to the new norms.
What would be nice is this time around when there is a big shift, is workers uniting to capture more of the forthcoming productivity gains than in previous eras. A separate topic, worth thinking about none the less.
but it is just another enabler. The issue is how _effective_ it is. It's eating the simple copy-writing, churnalism, pr-Repackage industry. looking at what google's done with the video/audio, thats probably going to replace a whole bunch of the video/graphics industry (which is where I started my career.)
Unless inflation ceases, 2K won't hold forever. It would barely hold now for a decent chunk of the population
But if "AI" increases productivity by 10% in an industry, it will tend to reduce demand for employees. look at say internet shop vs bricks and mortar: you need far less staff to service a much larger customer base.
manufacture for example, there is a constant drive to automate more and more in mass production. If you compare car building now vs 30 years ago. Or look at raspberrypi production now vs 5 years ago. They are producing more Pis than ever with roughly the same amount of staff.
If that "10%" productivity increase happens across the service sector, then in the UK that's something like a loss of 8% of _total_ jobs gone. Its more complex than that, but you get the picture.
Syria fell into civil war roughly the same time unemployment jumped: https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/SYR/syr...
In software development, a theoretical 20% increase in productivity without a 20% increase in demand could technically mean that somewhere in between 0% and 20% of your workforce is now unnecessary. And this is indeed true across many other industries.
And I fully agree we don't need 100% unemployment to have catastrophic results. Hell, 10% unemployment is already enough to make things pretty grim out there.
But you will agree that "AI increases productivity that reduces the amount of labor needed" is substantially different from "AI replaces humans". Framing is important if we want to have a meaningful conversation and speak the same language.
You are 100% spot on! thats the thing that really annoys me about futuroligist breathlessly saying "a new economy!" and all that junk, is that its just like the advent of steam, electricity, or the telegraph or lorries, or desktop computing.
The thing that futurloigist _forget_ is that these things caused unemployement, and huge social change.
AI-driven corporations could buy from one another, and countries will probably sell commodities to AI-driven corporations. But I fear they will be paid with "mirrors".
But, on the other hand, AI-driven corporations could just take whatever they want without paying at some point. And buy our obedience with food and gadgets plus magic pills to keep you healthy and not age, or some other thing. Who would risk losing that to protest. Meanwhile, AI goes on a space adventure. Earth might be kept as a zoo, a curiosity. (I took most of this from other people's ideas on the subject)
Don’t forget persistent inflation, which is how they make a profit off printing money. And remember persistent inflation is healthy and necessary, you’d be going against the experts to say otherwise.
Ah, well no, high inflation means that "they" loose money, kinda. Inflation means that the original money amount that they get back is worth less, and if the interest rate is less than inflation, then they loose money.
"reasonable" inflation means that loans become less burdensome over time.
However high inflation means high interest rates. So it can mean that initially the loan is much more expensive.
So, to be clear, you are saying you imagine the odds of any kind of intelligent life escaping that, or getting into that situation and ever evolving in a way where it can reach space again, or just not being interested in robots, or being interested on doing space research despite the robots, or anything else that would make it not apply are lower than 0.000000000001%?
EDIT: There was one "0" too many
In the event of mass unemployment level AI, cash stops being the agreement between humans. At first, cash value of services&goods converge to zero, only things that hold some value are what AI/AI companies care about. People would surely sell their land for 1M$ if a humanoid servant costs 100 dollars. Or pass a legislation to let OpenAI build 400GW data center in exchange for 100$ monthly UBI on top of your 50$ you got from a previous 20GW data center permit.
Human demand for things is basically unlimited, and capital will ostensibly be concentrated within the upper class who reaped all the benefits of ai automation. Monetary velocity within that upper strata of society will probably be only slightly lower than what we have now overall, the rich would just be paying for more things and more expensive things. If I had to guess there would still be plenty of economic activity, just amongst the people who actually have money to transact.
Talks of exponentials unabated by physics or social problems.
As soon as AI starts to "properly" affect the economy, it will cause huge unemployment. Most of the financial world is based on an economy with people spending cash.
If they are unemployed, there is no cash.
Financing works because banks "print" money, that is, they make up money and loan that money out, and then it gets paid back. Once its paid back, it becomes real. Thats how banks make money (simplified) If there aren’t people to loan to, then banks don't make profit, they can't fund AI expansion.