He’s one of the most knowledgeable persons in the world on the topic. It’s like saying that the ceo of BMW isn’t citable on conversations about expected cost decreases in electric cars.
Any environmental topic is susceptible to a huge amount of groupthink. The world isn’t so binary as people make it out to be. It is far from truth that LLMs=bad for environment, any more than computers=bad for the environment.
What I mean is that I have a healthy level of skepticism with Altman. He has to constantly battle for funding. Surely, he must be knowledgeable about LLMs, but he's the CEO of the largest AI company in the world, his PR needs to give "most knowledgeable person in the world on the topic" but I think that title should go to all of the engineers and developers working on these technologies and not a capital founder.
All that said, I agree that LLM's being bad for the environment is a complex topic. I think it would be more accepted if people had safety nets and could be excited for AI to take their job instead of having to be terrified, or if AI isn't just used as another tool for increasing wealth inequality.
Altman mentions a 150x increase in efficiency, you claim that trend will continue through to gpt6. At that point these models would be 22500 as efficient as they currently are, which would mean generating a 10 hour long video would cost around the same amount of electricity as running your microwave for 15 minutes. Will you have some introspection if that doesn't come to pass?
1/ did not exist before
2/ does not replace/reduce previous/other power (some, very much more critical and essential) usages.
3/ a LOT of tasks are still way more energy/time-efficiently done with regular existing methods (dedicated software, or even by hand), but are still asked/improperly routed to AI chatbots that ... statistically guess the answer.
It also leads to automation and efficiency, even if it isn’t a fully linear path.
AI isnt a waste. We can’t let environmental consciousness get in the way of rather natural human development. Especially CO2. (I have different opinions about biodiversity because of the irreversible loss. I also believe that we have the technology to pause and reverse climate change — but don’t pursue it because of degrowth ideologies)
While “economic value” =/= “solving climate change” without enough tax revenue costly transitions are impossible.
It's revealing that for some, it's easier to imagine Earth without life than Earth without capitalism.
For _who_ really?
Shareholders of AI tools producing companies?
Shareholders of companies that pretend to replace people and verifiable working processes with poorly understood black boxes?
(I can't help but notice the _same_ playbook as with crypto, NFTs, Web3, metaverse, and the same enabling-hardware provider).
Value, automation, efficiency will not solve the climate change challenges, if they are not directed towards it aggressively, as well as humanity acceptance and well-being.
Alas, they are directed towards a very little few bank accounts. Violence and subjugation, in many of their forms, is directed towards the others. It's not by accident.
I found this article to be a little too one sided. For instance, it didn’t talk about the 10x reductions in power achieved this past year — essentially how gpt4 can now run on a laptop.
Viz, via sama “The cost to use a given level of AI falls about 10x every 12 months, and lower prices lead to much more use. You can see this in the token cost from GPT-4 in early 2023 to GPT-4o in mid-2024, where the price per token dropped about 150x in that time period. Moore’s law changed the world at 2x every 18 months; this is unbelievably stronger.” https://blog.samaltman.com/three-observations