News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI's energy footprint by dr_dshiv on Wednesday May 21, 2025 @06:47AM (#44050094)
It is also additional value creation.

It also leads to automation and efficiency, even if it isn’t a fully linear path.

AI isnt a waste. We can’t let environmental consciousness get in the way of rather natural human development. Especially CO2. (I have different opinions about biodiversity because of the irreversible loss. I also believe that we have the technology to pause and reverse climate change — but don’t pursue it because of degrowth ideologies)

Re:AI's energy footprint by t_tsonev on Wednesday May 21, 2025 @07:08AM (#44050215)
No amount of value, in the economic sense, will solve climate change.
Re:AI's energy footprint by SirHumphrey on Wednesday May 21, 2025 @08:39AM (#44050849)
Well, somebody must buy solar panels, batteries, (nuclear reactors) and finance the whole research process.

While “economic value” =/= “solving climate change” without enough tax revenue costly transitions are impossible.

Re:AI's energy footprint by Juliate on Wednesday May 21, 2025 @09:01AM (#44051011)
Very capitalistic reasoning.

It's revealing that for some, it's easier to imagine Earth without life than Earth without capitalism.

Re:AI's energy footprint by Juliate on Wednesday May 21, 2025 @09:00AM (#44050999)
> It is also additional value creation.

For _who_ really?

Shareholders of AI tools producing companies?

Shareholders of companies that pretend to replace people and verifiable working processes with poorly understood black boxes?

(I can't help but notice the _same_ playbook as with crypto, NFTs, Web3, metaverse, and the same enabling-hardware provider).

Value, automation, efficiency will not solve the climate change challenges, if they are not directed towards it aggressively, as well as humanity acceptance and well-being.

Alas, they are directed towards a very little few bank accounts. Violence and subjugation, in many of their forms, is directed towards the others. It's not by accident.

Re:AI's energy footprint by cdblades on Wednesday May 21, 2025 @10:45AM (#44052037)
> It is also additional value creation.

Give some concrete examples and stats?

> It also leads to automation and efficiency, even if it isn’t a fully linear path.

Ditto.