Look at the early days of YC. Single digit millions a year was enough to stimulate the growth of a whole ecosystem of startups! Some startups are inherently capital-intensive but most don't need that much money to get to the point of basic viability. There are plenty of private individuals in Europe who could support a $10M a year incubator by themselves, not to mention the many institutions that could do this. And yet... there is no European YC and there never was.
I think it's cultural. Go talk to the top students at the top universities in the US and Europe and you will notice plenty of talent on both sides of the Atlantic - yet far different levels of ambition. Now run an experiment; pay ten of those students a hundred EUR/USD to tell everyone that they're dropping out and starting a startup. Watch the parents' reaction. Watch the professors' reaction. Watch the reaction from their doctor, their baker, their crush, their garbageman.
You already know the result, of course, it's obvious. That's your problem; and by comparison, the money hardly matters.
Oh yes. Being a failed entrepreneur is a stigma. Being a very successful entrepreneur is a stigma too. Only being a struggling or moderately successful entrepreneur is acceptable.
Americans just have a borderline delusional self-belief that other cultures really have a hard time matching
The Gulf Arabs are another group with a similar mentality but they don't have the population, freedom or education (yet) to do the same things
Consider that the European frontier is either
- west: Americas (already done)
- south: Africa (not gonna happen again)
- north/east: drang nach osten (again, not to be repeated)
- up / down? Perhaps Europe needs to focus on space and mining tech?
Russia has a frontier, and they are pretty strong in engineering, but I doubt that a SV style ecosystem is likely to form, given the… ahem… unique cultural aspects.
All said, I disagree that a frontier experience is necessary: the UK, Germany and Austria-Hungary were massive industrial modernizers while the US was still going through its westward colonization.
Is tech an exceptional field, or just the current SotA in industrial development?
Over time when farming technology improved, people could live self-sufficiently in worse places. Transportation technology changed as well. Railways, highways. And now remote working and data centers. So there have been frontiers also in the old world in that sense. The king of Sweden in the 1500s declared some eastern frontier areas as tax free for some time, as he wanted people to settle there to control those areas (in accords, some of it might have been Russia...). Many places have waxed and waned over the centuries. When Estonia gained independence for the second time, some Finnish farmers went there as there was excellent farmland that was very underutilized.
With modern knowledge you could even build up a great place to live almost anywhere. Good policies and cheap energy. Maybe fresh water is the hardest physical requirement.
Silicon Beach/Alley/Gulf/Islands within America cannot replicate it either
Without a culture of paying it forward as a reckless angel investor sometimes dressed up as a fund, already within the people that made it, none of these ecosystems get off the ground
Notably, Silicon Valley’s earliest winners were from a government funded initiative
Correction, the Gulf Arabs don't. Their autocratic leadership is though. A frequent point of contention between government and public is the private sector - the government wants them all to join the private sector and even provides locals with seed funding for most kinds of businesses. But the locals are rather risk averse and would rather stay in the cushy public sector. The few who are entrepreneurial tend to be extremely entrepreneurial though, and they have a lot of the risk-enabling capital structure in place in Abu Dhabi and Dubai
Do you believe short-term thinking is essential for successful startups?
because someone else over in the USA dropped out two years earlier than you to do this very same startup, and thus they get a head start.
Unless your novel idea is so completely novel, that nobody else but you could've done it. Most ideas are not this novel, and first mover advantage is real.
Not to mention that to make long term work out, the short term must also work out. It's a stair case - each short term period adds up and turns into long term. It is almost impossible to have a long term plan work out, if the short term is so unsuccessful that you need more funding every year.
So work on the next idea?
I'd phrase it a bit differently -- local (country) regulations, taxes and fees stifle startups in the crib.
Giving it to academia can 10x the result, but yes research is risky, that's why it's important it is founded externally.
Companies that profited from research in academia are very happy.
Overall I agree, the current European strategy is not optimal, for both Industry and academia.
This is not a meaningful statement
‘Returning money in private hands’ does not result in more startup investment, it’s not in the culture to do this.
The money will be put into real estate, bonds, or whatever.
Look at London - it has as much wealth as NewYork or LA but all the money just piles up in real estate or Fintech.
But outside those niches? Good luck getting a farm-tech startup funded, no-one will take a punt.
So it falls to the government to try and kickstart something. As flawed as it may be.
Then they put together a competition for funding that basically feels like a school exam
There are so, so many examples of British agtech companies getting funded:
https://www.lettusgrow.com/blog/2020/1/9/press-release-uk-ag...
https://edinburgh-innovations.ed.ac.uk/news/roslin-technolog...
https://fischerfarms.co.uk/fischer-farms-secures-26m-funding...
https://tropic.bio/tropic-biosciences-raises-28-5-million-se...
Uber's Series C was $361M, that's the kind of money you need to put a company on the global map.
Tax less, and prosperity follows!
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/capital-gains-tax-rates-and-allo...
In California those rates go up to 33.3% (20% federal + 13.3% state).
The US has issues, but using American issues as an excuse to ignore European issues (which in reality are a result of soverignity tussles) is ridiculous.
[0] - https://hdr.undp.org/data-center/country-insights#/ranks
For average/unambitious or unfortunate/poor people, places like Europe or Canada are much better standard of living
I guess the question becomes, which "Europe" and which "America" are you comparing. And even then, developmentally, the US isn't much different than Western or Northern Europe.
> For average/unambitious or unfortunate/poor people
I mean, youth and normal unemployment remains significantly higher in much of the Europe compared to the US [0][1] and median income after tax remains roughly on par [2], even factoring for purchasing power parity [3].
As a whole, it appears that the US is roughly on par with much of it's peers in Western and Northern Europe, and American problems appear to be overreported and European ones underreported
I personally think there is a lot of glamorization of Europe because more Americans visit Western and Northern Europe as tourists than the other way around, and attribute their tourism experience as that of a normal European, which is an unrealistic assumption.
And it's not like ambitious risk takers don't exist in Europe - look at the startup and dev scene in Sweden, Czechia, Romania, and Poland. It's clearly an institutional problem.
[0] - https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/youth-unemploym...
[1] - https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/field/unemployment-ra...
[2] - https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/median-income-after-tax-l...
In my opinion the only real issue the US has is healthcare. In all other ways even for middle class people it's better. People think Canada is some socialized heaven... yet home ownership is MUCH more realistic in say Michigan than it is just across the border in Ontario.
They are also funded by large public investors like pension funds (American and European) and sovereign wealth funds.
There is just a lot of capital sloshing around in the US, and it's fairly easy to start a firm here. The same isn't true in much of the EU.
why should it fall to the gov't? They're one of the worst funders of startups imho.
In these scenarios, the gov't isn't funding the business via equity, but grants - aka free money. This makes all the wrong incentives. Taxpayers don't feel the loss (not truly, like a private investor would), if the startup fails.
These people aren't just anti-growth. They're pro-poverty. The degrowth movement (https://ehne.fr/en/encyclopedia/themes/material-civilization...) is basically a bunch of trust-fund Marxists and tenured academics who've never missed a meal in their lives demanding that regular people live worse so they can feel morally superior. "Oh, we must shrink the economy to save the planet!" Meanwhile, China's building a coal plant a week, India's economy is booming, and the U.S. is drilling, innovating, and getting richer. But Europe? Nah, they'd rather ration meat, ban cars, and freeze in the dark while patting themselves on the back for their "ethical" decline.
In America, a 20-year-old can drop out of college, code an app in his dorm, and become a billionaire. In Europe? Good luck. First, you'll need permits from 17 different agencies, all staffed by lifers who've never worked a day in the private sector. Then, once you finally start making money, the government will take half of it to fund some bloated pension scheme for bureaucrats who retire at 55. And God forbid you try to fire a useless employee labor laws make it easier to divorce a spouse than to fire a guy who shows up drunk every day. No wonder Europe's last big tech company was Spotify, and even they're based in tax-friendly Stockholm because the rest of the continent is a regulatory warzone.
The ultimate proof that Europe's system is broken? Its smartest people leave. Engineers, doctors, entrepreneurs, they all flee to the U.S., Switzerland, or Singapore, where they're allowed to keep what they earn. The ones left behind? A shrinking workforce of aging socialists who still think the government can just print money forever without consequences. And when the economy tanks? They'll just blame "greedy corporations" instead of their own economic suicide pact.
The funniest (and saddest) part? The same anti-capitalist activists using iPhones, riding in Ubers, and ordering Amazon deliveries are the ones screaming for the destruction of the system that made those things possible. They want to abolish private property while living in nice apartments, end globalization while wearing clothes made in Bangladesh, and "eat the rich" while sipping $7 lattes. The cognitive dissonance is astounding.
If you want to see what happens when ideology trumps prosperity, just look at Europe. A once-great civilization now hostage to bureaucrats, academics, and activists who'd rather see everyone equally poor than let a few people get rich. The U.S. has its problems, but at least it still rewards hustle. Europe? It's too busy taxing, regulating, and guilt-tripping itself into irrelevance. Wake up, Europe. Capitalism isn't the problem. Your hatred of it is.
So true!! As a university professor, this nails it. It’s sad — Amsterdam, for instance, used to have such a strong culture of business. But that vitality has disappeared.
But I think your analysis of the root causes is lacking. European humans aren't different organisms than non-european humans. Culture does not form in a vacuum. It comes from base properties of the geography and experiences of humans in the region.
In my opinion, it's primarily down to 3 things:
1) Population density: Europe has 3X the population density (and subsequent urbanization) as the US. Urbanization leads to more collectivist attitudes. If you compare European attitudes to those in a high density American location like New York City, you'll be amazed how similar (in everything from religiosity to socialist economic leaning to political philosophy). It's the higher proportion of low population density areas of the US that lead to major differences in political philosophy.
2) Experience of downside risk: European risk aversion is quite easily explained by the fact they have experienced the most extreme version of downside risk imaginable in recent memory (WWII). The worst thing the US knows is a depression. Not total annihilation, fire bombing and markets going to 0.
3) Ethnocentrism: Europe's nationalist ethno-states are far less culturally diverse than the broader US. This leads to a higher capacity of empathy for strangers (because people in a mono-culture are more similar to you, you empathize with them more easily). Ironically though, this empathy is what leads to a higher percentage of GDP being driven by centralized government spending (50% in Europe vs. 30-35ish% in USA). The market is less empathetic, but ultimately more efficient and grows the overall pie faster...even accounting for the additional increase in inequality.
Growth compounds exponentially, so this gets more dramatic over time. People in podunk US Midwest States now have a higher disposable income per capita (on both mean and median measures) than people in London, a place you would traditionally think of as among the richest in the world.
But again, the US didn't get here because 'culture.' It got here due to design decisions made hundreds of years earlier. Being a multicultural society reveals base human racist leanings, which results in more individualist governance, which leads to a greater embrace of markets and private capital, which leads to faster growth.
https://archive.org/details/practical-idealism-english-ver-1...
Nordic countries have small populations due to the limitation of arable land to support humans at all. The US has no such limitation and could support vastly more population.
>Europe has 3X the population density (and subsequent urbanization) as the US.
Are you sure about that?
>...The population density in Europe is 34 per Km² (87 people per mi²).
https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/europe-popula...
>...The population density in the United States is 38 per Km² (98 people per mi²).
https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/us-population...
> every single job, iPhone, and modern convenience they enjoy exists because someone, somewhere, took a risk to make a profit.
Amazingly capitalists use things invented by socialists, like satellites, or the LED. Or things invested by Nazis and Monarchists.
Their favourite iPhone is made by communists, with minerals mined by .. well I am not sure what you call em but they are not capitalists
Every day Capitalists use public sanitation, running water, Education, GPS, police and prosecution but they imagine they could exist in a mad max world instead of dying of cholera
China has been a capitalist state since the 70s with a turn to State Capitalism in the 2010s. Furthermore, China's leadership remains anti-Welfarism, with Xi himself making speeches against expanding the already weak social safety net.
> Every day Capitalists use public sanitation, running water, Education, GPS, police and prosecution but they imagine they could exist in a mad max world instead of dying of cholera
Capitalism doesn't preclude public infrastructure. That's just a facile argument.
> the LED
The modern LED was developed by Texas Instruments and Bell Labs in the 1950s.
> like satellites
Both the US and the USSR knew about how to launch satellites in space by the mid-1950s. It was the USSR that chose to prioritize it, and the US that chose to deprioritize it.
I am measuring by the same yardstick as the OP.
If taxes to pay for public services are good capitalism, then you can’t call Europe socialist.
> The modern LED was developed by…
Whatever, take Hyperbaric welding. Will a western oil company refuse to use it because it was invented in USSR?
The fundamental accusation of the OP is totally hypocritical.
Fair enough! Didn't see their argument. Yea that was dumb.
Do you think those miners are volunteering out of revolutionary solidarity? Or perhaps "disposable cogs in the global supply chain" was the term you were looking for?
Miners were getting paid in USSR too, are they capitalist too by this logic?
Because if they do, then capitalism is horrible, and if they do not, then the argument made by the OP is hypocritical
50% of European GDP is government spending. The USSR was 70-80%. Meanwhile China is currently at 30%.
Spotify though, is Europe's own.
Clearly, he considers Stripe to be an American phenomenon.
This sounds plausible on the surface, but by putting them all in the same basket you show that you have no idea what you are talking about : it's a bit like blaming wokists for their voting for Trump because wokists are from the USA and Trump was elected in the USA...
Pedantic but counterpoint, Markus Villig.
People are also happier in most European countries than they are in the US, because the constant competition for wealth and using wealth as the measure of what everyone is worth is not good for mental health and does not lead to a peaceful society, but one where people are set against each other. Europe has problems, but fixing them with capitalism is not going to lead to better lives for most people.
Is this how american's justify selling their country to the highest bidder? "at least we're not eating toilet paper like the europeans". You know, some of the richest people in the world...
Who told you that?
Those are some big assumptions about 750 million people. Would love to see the data on this.
> In America, a 20-year-old can drop out of college, code an app in his dorm, and become a billionaire. In Europe? Good luck.
Assuming that's the case with you, right? And if not, then why not if it's so simple? Everybody knows that these cases are extremely rare, but they do happen both in the US and in the EU.
> The ultimate proof that Europe's system is broken? Its smartest people leave. Engineers, doctors, entrepreneurs, they all flee to the U.S., Switzerland, or Singapore, where they're allowed to keep what they earn.
Again, would love to see the data on this. Based on my own personal anecdata, one of the reasons why IT engineers don't move to the US despite being offered to do so is because they enjoy the other benefits of living in the EU, like high-speed rail, free health-care, free higher education, being car independent, childcare benefits and having more days off.
There is simply not enough private capital investment in Europe. The public money is inevitably passed through academic hands or other public sector bureaucrats. And it is simply an ineffective way to allocate capital. The money should be returned to private hands where it belongs and those individuals should be the ones to decide how to invest their own capital.
Why do so few Europeans get this? It’s like they just can’t stand the idea of a wealthy person investing their own money.