News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by gbalduzzi on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:07AM (#43993478)
I know this is not the right place for this but english is not my first language.

How is "have" the correct verb here? Shouldn't it be "has"? Like, the crew is the subject, and it has 35 seconds.

I'm trying to understand what I'm missing here, because I'm sure BBC did not make a mistake

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by christudor on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:18AM (#43993535)
If a noun denotes a group of people – even if it's technically a singular noun – it's okay (but not compulsory) to use a plural verb.

The sentences 'Real Madrid have performed well this year' and 'Real Madrid has performed well this year' are both grammatically acceptable, and probably used roughly the same amount.

A related example is the word 'none' (= 'not one'). Technically it should govern a singular verb (e.g. 'None of the players is good enough') but you'll now see it a lot with a plural verb (e.g. 'None of the players are good enough').

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by poizan42 on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:18AM (#43993825)
"none" is saying something about all of the players, so how would that be singular? The word "none" is always used in a plural context, like if there is only one player then you won't say "none of the player"
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by christudor on Thursday May 15, 2025 @09:28AM (#43994859)
I'm talking about the verb that follows 'none', not the noun.

'None of the team was [singular] prepared' and 'None of the team were [plural] prepared' are both correct.

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by poizan42 on Thursday May 15, 2025 @01:46PM (#43997469)
You said

> A related example is the word 'none' (= 'not one'). Technically it should govern a singular verb

And I'm questioning why you think "none" should technically govern a singular verb when "none" is normally a non-singular subject.

I'm sure both are being used, and at the end of the day what is correct is determined by how a significant amount of people are using the language. But I just don't understand why you think a singular verb would be more "technically correct"

Did you mean that because you could replace none with "not one" then it should be singular? But that only works because the 'not' applies to the whole sentence, so the remainder is about 'one', i.e. "not (one of the team was prepared)". But that doesn't work for the word none because you can't read it as the 'not' applying to a singular part-sentence.

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by umanwizard on Friday May 16, 2025 @06:03AM (#44003563)
There are dialectal differences here. “Real Madrid have” is common in British English but would be very rare, possibly to the extent of striking native speakers as an ungrammatical mistake, in American.
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by Thorrez on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:10AM (#43993784)
Ok:

"The crew who have..."

"The crew that have..."

"The crew which have..."

"The crew that has..."

"The crew which has..."

Not ok:

"The crew who has..."

The reason that last one isn't ok is that "who" refers to a person or people, not an object. "Crew" can either refer to a singular object or a plural group of people. Put together, "crew who" must refer to a plural group of people, so needs a verb that matches plural.

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by StevenWaterman on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:10AM (#43993493)
Both "has" and "have" sound ok to me here as a native speaker.

Both of these can describe the same event:

- The cows have 10 seconds to enter the field

- The herd has 10 seconds to enter the field

In the case of "crew", the word can either mean

- The people who are part of the crew (like "the cows")

- The crew as a collective unit (like "the herd")

Which is why both sound ok

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by OJFord on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:01AM (#43993729)
You would have to say 'which has', but then yes it works (and is more correct than 'who have').
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by BlindEyeHalo on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:10AM (#43993490)
This might help: https://www.writingclasses.com/toolbox/ask-writer/are-words-...

In short:

When you’re referring to the collective noun as a unit, treat it as singular:

The band lost its spot in the top ten this week. When you’re referring to the individuals within the group, treat it as plural:

The jury had to sign for their ID badges.

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by gbalduzzi on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:14AM (#43993514)
In Italian we don't have this distinction, when we use a collective noun we always treat it as singular (unless there are multiple collection, like multiple crews). Thank you for the explanation
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by mon_ on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:24AM (#43993555)
Doesn't your advice contradict the BBC's phrasing? Collectively, the band lost its spot in the top ten. And, collectively, the crew has 35 seconds to prepare the stage for the next performer.
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by rsynnott on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:29AM (#43993899)
I think this is to some extent a British English vs US English thing; it's certainly more common to treat words like crew/company/etc as plural in British English. The linked article is being overly prescriptive, though. Both are basically fine.
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by aitchnyu on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:37AM (#43993608)
I once read a Wikiepedia article starting with "Pink Floyd are..." and immediately hit edit. I saw a banner comment saying its correct according to British English. Since then I've noticed lots of "Company are...". I also wonder why India uses "Company is...". My guess is Britain adopted it after Indian independence.
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by OJFord on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:04AM (#43993741)
It's often proscribed, many style guides say 'the company is/has', sort of de-personifying it to the entity rather than the people that work there.

I think it's an Americanizm to say e.g. 'Apple have released a new iPhone'.

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by foldr on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:17AM (#43993819)
No, it’s actually more common to do this in British English than in American English, so it’s a “Britism” if anything.

https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=Brit...

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by aitchnyu on Friday May 16, 2025 @01:54AM (#44002212)
Was it commonly used in (for example) 1900? It wasnt taught to Indian students like me, who had English books with Cambridge and Oxford logos.
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by OJFord on Friday May 16, 2025 @06:11AM (#44003607)
It wouldn't be taught here either, it's a colloquialism/corruption, whether from American influence or not. Long may you keep it (and so many other things) out of Indian English!
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by m2fkxy on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:11AM (#43993501)
it depends on what flavour of English you speak. British English for instance tends to use plural for collective nouns.
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by pfortuny on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:11AM (#43993503)
This is a place where uou can use either. There is IIRC a letter of JRR tolkien where he discusses this very issue. "The crew" can be thouth of as "a set of people" (so you can say The crew has) or "severa people" (so you can say "the crew have").
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by senko on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:07AM (#43993763)
Using plural for companies, orgs or teams is common in British English.

For example "Apple have released a new iPhone".

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by idw on Thursday May 15, 2025 @07:12AM (#43993791)
Sometimes the BBC does make mistakes but this seems to fit their style guide:

"Treat collective nouns - companies, governments and other bodies - as singular. There are some exceptions: ... Sports teams - although they are singular in their role as business concerns (eg: Arsenal has declared an increase in profits) Rock/pop groups"

So treating a crew, like a team, as plural makes sense.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsstyleguide/grammar-spelling-punctu...

Both approaches are regularly used, so it is now more of a style choice, hence being in the style guide.

The Economist style guide says Brits are more likely to use plural and Americans singular but writers need to make a judgement in context: https://www.economist.com/johnson/2010/09/20/style-guide-ent...

Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by eu on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:16AM (#43993532)
as a plural noun, it refers to the individuals part of the crew. similar to people, flock
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by pipodeclown on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:16AM (#43993525)
'Crew' implies that it is a group of people doing this and therefore they have 35 seconds. You can reconstitute the sentence to check what you should use. In this case you could say in your head:" the crew as a team check the video feed. They have 35 seconds to do this." If this was referring to an individual it would be: "Peter checks the video feed, he has 35 seconds to do this."
Re:The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eur... by CoastalCoder on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:49AM (#43993664)
Even native English speakers disagree on this.