News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by 0x0 on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:12AM (#4390996)
How often do you get see governments threatening to revoke the diplomatic status of an embassy for the sake of apprehending a rape suspect? Wow.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by mootothemax on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:18AM (#4391018)
How often do you get see governments threatening to revoke the diplomatic status of an embassy for the sake of apprehending a rape suspect?

You could argue the opposite side: how many embassies offer protection to famous rape suspects?

This is not an ordinary occurrence.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by furyg3 on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:43AM (#4391144)
The key word here is "suspect". We live in 2012: if you want to question a suspect you don't have to have him in your jurisdiction to do so. If you don't want to interview him in the embassy or by phone, you obviously don't care. If he doesn't want to talk, that's within his rights, and a refusal to come to your country should be interpreted as such.

The only reasons you would want a suspect extradited to your country are: to press charges and make an arrest, to torture, to make a media scene, or to 'punish' someone by detaining them even though you can't make the case stick.

The only acceptable reason is the first one, in which case you should press charges before extradition.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by ceejayoz on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:55AM (#4391207)
1812, 1912, or 2012, subjects of police investigation don't generally get to pick the interview venue.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by anthonyb on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:19AM (#4391330)
If you're only a suspect, and haven't been charged, you don't have to talk to the police at all. Picking a venue seems minor in comparison.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by ceejayoz on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:24AM (#4391357)
In the US. Not sure on Sweden's laws on that.

At this point in the US he'd probably be charged with obstruction of justice, at which point venue is again no longer up to him.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by s_henry_paulson on Thursday August 16, 2012 @12:27PM (#4392112)
In Sweden you do not have to be in the country for questioning, and JA has offered to be interviewed over phone or video link.

In the US there's the 5th Amendment to the Constitution.

Even if you know nothing of the law, surely you've at least seen a television show or movie where someone says "Am I being charged with a crime? ... Then am I free to go?"

That's all you need to say.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by glenstein on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:56AM (#4391533)
A suspect is not a convict, and the privilege of selecting a site for interview is just as likely to be abused by the state as it is the suspect.

Assange has a perfectly justified fear that the request for interview functions as a strategy for entrapping & extraditing him. The notion that this is nothing more than a disinterested preference in procedure is implausible.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by vacri on Thursday August 16, 2012 @12:23PM (#4392088)
If he doesn't want to talk, that's within his rights

This is true in the US. It's not quite true here in Australia - a refusal to talk to police can be used against you in a court of law. It's not going to make or break a case, but you can't just 'plead the 5th' here and have no consequences. I imagine it's similar in the UK as our law is quite similar to theirs.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by mryan on Thursday August 16, 2012 @01:41PM (#4392553)
It is indeed similar in the UK:

"You do not have to say anything, but it may harm your defence if you do not mention, when questioned, something which you later rely on in court. Anything you do say may be given in evidence."

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by twelvechairs on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:05AM (#4391259)
Actually arguing the opposite as you say "how many embassies offer protection to famous rape suspects" is silly, because he is not being offered asylum because he is a rape suspect so effectively its as meaningful a question as "How many embassies offer protection to people born in Townsville, Queensland".
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by toyg on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:23AM (#4391042)
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by DividesByZero on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:29AM (#4391073)
Something quite similar happened before with Roman Polanski.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Polanski#Sexual_abuse_cas...

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by mootothemax on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:31AM (#4391082)
Something quite similar happened before with Roman Polanski.

Which is why I wrote: This is not an ordinary occurrence meaning that it happens rarely, not that such things never happen.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by DividesByZero on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:38AM (#4391123)
I wasn't suggesting otherwise, merely citing another similar case that I hadn't seen posted yet.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by meiji on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:17AM (#4391012)
It's also a different thing. He's also wanted in the UK for breaching his bail conditions. So he not only has the extradition hanging over him but he's broken the law in the UK now.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by chimeracoder on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:12AM (#4391287)
I'm pretty sure nearly anybody who seeks asylum is breaking some law in their home country.

The whole point of asylum is to protect against persecution, which is usually justified in the home country under some law.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by objclxt on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:17AM (#4391320)
The problem with this argument is nobody has produced any evidence to show Assange is 'persecuted'. Sweden issued a legitimate European Arrest Warrant, and the UK allowed Assange to appeal that to the highest court.

There is no evidence that he is being persecuted by the US in this matter: if Ecuador has some they should publish it.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by justsee on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:53AM (#4391515)
> The problem with this argument is nobody has produced any evidence to show Assange is 'persecuted'.

Actually they have. Enough was presented to the Ecuadorian Government that they agreed he faced potential political prosecution. That's why he's been granted asylum.

> Sweden issued a legitimate European Arrest Warrant, and the UK allowed Assange to appeal that to the highest court.

Sweden issued an extremely unusual arrest warrant, and in the highest UK legal circles there is an opinion that the final Supreme court decision was simply wrong:

"The Supreme Court wrongly, and without any analysis, assumed that VCLT Article 31(3)(b) is applicable in the interpretation of secondary European acts such as the Framework Decision. It also neglected to look into the interpretative rules of the EU. The result was a fundamental mistake in the legal reasoning of the Court." [1]

Assange is a Western dissident. You don't have to like him or agree with WikiLeaks mission, but the actions against WikiLeaks have been highly political, and manouverings by Sweden, the UK, and the US in line with the actions of any states acting against dissidents through various channels.

[1] http://www.cjicl.org.uk/index.php?option=com_easyblog&vi...

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by gregsq on Thursday August 16, 2012 @01:37PM (#4392525)
It was of course fundamental to Assange's appeal that the validity of the extradition warrant be examined by the court, with respect to the precedents mentioned. The opinion referenced in the citation examines the claim made by Assange's own lawyers that some or all of these precedents had not been argued in court.

For the suspicious mind, it could be seen that a disinclination to examine in full the very matter presented for examination, is indicative of at worst, bias, and at worst, as argued in the citation, error. Any further avenue of appeal in the UK has been refused.

I also find it ironic that British courts are willing to refuse extradition requests for terrorism suspects, say to Jordan, when an ambiguity regarding their immunity from torture or death arises, but will apparently allow it in other cases.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by foobarqux on Thursday August 16, 2012 @12:01PM (#4391931)
The Wikileaks Grand Jury?
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by meiji on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:18AM (#4391325)
He's not a UK citizen so that's not it. The Australians aren't calling for his extradition or arrest so that's not it either.

It could just be that he had bail terms set and broke them and the Swedes want a chat about those pesky rape allegations. Don't invent something where it doesn't exist.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by jgrahamc on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:15AM (#4391006)
Or, how often do rape suspects having gone through the entire legal system in the UK decide that asking for asylum is the way to go?
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by toyg on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:30AM (#4391076)
He has not been convicted of anything, in the UK nor in Sweden, so he's not "gone through the entire legal system".

The Swedish Police officially wants him for questioning, and for that reason they requested his arrest through Interpol. The UK legal system only argued on whether there's any impediment, under British Law, which would not allow him to be extradited.

Under pressure from the current government, Lord Justices ruled that they cannot find anything of the sort. Hardly a trial or "going through the entire legal system".

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by jgrahamc on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:40AM (#4391133)
"He has not been convicted of anything"

And I did not say he had. Your entire comment is based on a false premise (that I believed that he had been convicted) that you have invented.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by toyg on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:57AM (#4391219)
Your entire comment is based on the false premise that he's "gone through the entire legal system". My comment proved that he has only skimmed the surface of extradition law, so he cannot have "gone through the entire legal system". If that were the case, a convicted murderer would have gone through the legal system and... something more?

But who cares, he's just a man. The problem here is the sanctity of the asylum principle, which is not worth losing over such a petty dispute.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by mongol on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:43AM (#4391454)
Has he not gone through the entire legal system in the extradition case though?
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by vacri on Thursday August 16, 2012 @12:26PM (#4392103)
Your last sentence is the important part that I think most people aren't really seeing.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by Tyrannosaurs on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:22AM (#4391352)
To be convicted of something he'd have to go to Sweden, something he's doing his level best to prevent.

As a result the fact he's not been convicted is potentially somewhat misleading as he's made it impossible to do so up to this point.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by lmm on Thursday August 16, 2012 @11:45AM (#4391834)
To be convicted he'd first have to be charged; the swedes are insisting that he is only wanted for questioning and will not be charged with anything (which seems somewhat at odds with the amount of effort they're putting into this).
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by papercrane on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:47AM (#4391480)
Why can't he be tried in absentia?
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by Tyrannosaurs on Thursday August 16, 2012 @11:00AM (#4391561)
I don't know enough about Swedish law to know but I would say that I think being tried in absentia is both morally wrong and likely open to legal challenge.

And what would be the point? He can't be punished as he's not there so why not just wait until you actually have him?

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by papercrane on Thursday August 16, 2012 @11:17AM (#4391656)
In the general case I would agree, but there needs to be a point where you can say that every effort was made and opportunity given and that the accused has actively refused to participate in the trial.

> And what would be the point? He can't be punished as he's not there so why not just wait until you actually have him?

I can see your point here, but after some time I would think that it would become difficult to continue with the case. Witnesses get hard to track down, evidence lost, etc..

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by politician on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:30AM (#4391075)
Isn't the crime Assange is charged with in Sweden is significantly different from what is generally understood as rape in the US? Isn't he actually being charged with having two "one night stands"?
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by _delirium on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:37AM (#4391119)
If it's as alleged, I believe it would constitute at least some kind of sexual assault in the US as well. The allegation is that he had engaged in intercourse without a condom despite the protestations of his (otherwise consenting) partner that she didn't consent to unprotected sex.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by gsnedders on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:42AM (#4391138)
But — vitally — means the partner did not consent to the sex that was had. It disgusts me how many people are arguing that non-consensual sex isn't rape if they were willing to do it under different circumstances.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by politician on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:57AM (#4391218)
I don't think anyone is suggesting what you are insinuating that they are suggesting.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by lmm on Thursday August 16, 2012 @11:53AM (#4391886)
The traditional definition of rape is "by force and without consent". Not to say this isn't immoral or indeed criminal, but it isn't rape and to call it such is unfair both to him and to rape victims.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by tdoggette on Thursday August 16, 2012 @12:35PM (#4392159)
That's the traditional definition, but it's neither a good nor a modern one.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by tzs on Thursday August 16, 2012 @12:22PM (#4392074)
The allegation for one of the cases is approximately this: they were going to have consensual sex, but the girl required that he wear a condom. One was not available, and so she refused to allow sex. They stayed in bed together, and fell asleep.

In the morning, she woke up to Assange on top of her having sex with her. She asked if he had obtained a condom and he said no. She told him to get off, and, well, he got off, but not in the way she meant--he kept going, came, and then withdrew.

That would arguably be rape in the US.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by jellicle on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:41AM (#4391443)
He hasn't been charged with anything in any country. Not publicly, anyway.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by hythloday on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:33AM (#4391092)
He's charged with rape and two counts of sexual assault.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assange_v_Swedish_Prosecution_A...

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by daveying99 on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:25AM (#4391361)
You're misinformed. He has not been charged for anything by any country. Do your reading.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by hythloday on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:32AM (#4391408)
Excuse me, that's not the case except in the most narrow and pedantic sense. Here's the English High Court denying his appeal:

"In England and Wales, a decision to charge is taken at a very early stage; there can be no doubt that if what Mr Assange had done had been done in England and Wales, he would have been charged and thus criminal proceedings would have been commenced. If the commencement of criminal proceedings were to be viewed in this way, it would be to look at Swedish procedure through the narrowest of eyes. On this basis, criminal proceedings have commenced against Mr Assange"

Link in the cousin comment.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by politician on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:48AM (#4391168)
Do you know if those charges carry the same connotation in Sweden as in the United States? IIRC, there was some confusion about what he actually is being charged with when the case was originally brought, then dismissed as unsubstantiated, then reopened.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by hythloday on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:01AM (#4391238)
Here's the transcript of the High Court decision that declined his appeal.

http://www.judiciary.gov.uk/Resources/JCO/Documents/Judgment...

"Rape - On 17 August 2010, in the home of the injured party [SW] in Enköping, Assange deliberately consummated sexual intercourse with her by improperly exploiting that she, due to sleep, was in a helpless state. It is an aggravating circumstance that Assange, who was aware that it was the expressed wish of the injured party and a prerequisite of sexual intercourse that a condom be used, still consummated unprotected sexual intercourse with her. The sexual act was designed to violate the injured party’s sexual integrity."

I would consider that to be rape, but I have no idea whether the US in general or legally would agree.

Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by rustynails on Thursday August 16, 2012 @01:03PM (#4392308)
http://www.google.com/search?q=assange%20half%20asleep Take your pick of articles. Was she asleep? Anyone who had read all of the posts in this thread knows there is something suspect about this whole case. Simply interview the man where he can't be extradited to the US and be done with it.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by paradoja on Thursday August 16, 2012 @10:18AM (#4391323)
No he is not. He is accused.
Re:Ecuador grants Julian Assange asylum by untog on Thursday August 16, 2012 @09:16AM (#4391008)
How often do rape suspects claim asylum?