it's like self-driving cars -- if we had a dedicated separate road network just for self-driving cars, and required that they all communicate with standard protocols, then we'd have self-driving cars by now -- but that's not actually the goal of FSD. the goal is to have cars that can use existing infrastructure and co-exist with human drivers.
Who is actually hurt if I publish an llms.txt or MCP in addition to my existing content?
First, whatever you mean by "we", we can do more than one thing at a time. Second, there are advantages to designing a protocol with formal semantics.
> We are bending over backwards to make the internet easier to interact with for AI than for humans.
I'm detecting an emotional reaction here, which I can understand and sympathize with, but I have a feeling it is distorting a full understanding of MCP's role.
Also, in terms of level of concern about AI; MCP in particular strikes me as probably much lower down the list. That said, one might view it as part of a general trend of people sacrificing our "humanity" (including privacy and control) for a little bit of convenience -- which I grant is concerning trend.
MCP seems like we have given up on making the models good or smart. We are bending over backwards to make the internet easier to interact with for AI than for humans.
If general intelligence is on the horizon, this all seems a colossal waste of time. (Not your resume. I mean the general direction of AI development.)