News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by Animats on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @02:42AM (#43841949)
Start with a fingerprint check before you even talk to them.[1] Then ask for a REAL ID at the interview, take fingerprints again, and match with the ones from the pre-screen fingerprint check. You need to be signed up with a driver's license verification service to validate the ID.[2]

It takes that level of verification to become a security guard or a school bus driver. Anybody in computer security should be doing this.

[1] https://www.sterlingcheck.com/services/fingerprinting/

[2] https://www.aamva.org/technology/systems/verification-system...

Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by Gathering6678 on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @03:09AM (#43842086)
Are you serious about this?

I live in China, a supposedly autocratic country and one with universal ID, and even companies here don't take fingerprints. ID will be shown when you are officially onboard. I can't say for all, but for most companies (at least the ones without the need for a security clearance), requiring ID at interview will be seen as a red flag, and requiring fingerprint would probably be put on social media and name shamed, if not straight up reported to the authorities.

Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @03:24AM (#43842157)
Not a typical job but one in a high security environment, seems somewhat understandable.

Not that I’d do it. The paradox that security for a firm means zero privacy for me is too much to bear these days.

Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by Gathering6678 on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @04:16AM (#43842499)
I have some experience working for financial institutions with access to highly confidential information, and haven't been required to produce my fingerprint for, like, ever.

Again, I can't say for all, and I'm sure there are certain companies and positions which require such measures, but I could not imagine requiring fingerprints (or even ID during interview) to be acceptable in most cases.

Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by Spooky23 on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @06:49AM (#43843387)
You probably worked in divisions where the auditors didn’t issue a finding yet, or outside the regulatory scope.

It’s pretty common in finance, government and human services. Amazon is very aggressive with this - contractors in their facilities get regular background checks.

Usually the employee goes to a third party run by a company like Idemia to collect the biometric. I can’t imagine not collecting the ID information of perspective employees - that’s just asking for fraud.

Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by hiatus on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @08:53AM (#43844515)
You didn't have to do an in-person background check that included fingerprinting? When I worked at a bank this was required. It was run by a third party company not at the office.
Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by Gathering6678 on Monday May 12, 2025 @11:42AM (#43964295)
No, but I didn't deal with money directly. I dealt with corporate governance and capital market related information for the company, so perhaps other people needed to have their fingerprints taken.
Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @04:21AM (#43842519)
In a high security environment, you can get a report from law enforcement; in the Netherlands this is called a "declaration around behaviour" (??), which is basically a signed / authenticated document saying "this person was not involved in financial crimes" - you need to have it specified for a category of crimes, the previous is for example one I had to get to work at a bank as a contractor.

I don't know what the equivalent in the US is, but https://www.fbi.gov/how-we-can-help-you/more-fbi-services-an... seems similar enough.

I'd trust an FBI report more than taking their fingerprints and the like.

Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by Animats on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @04:19PM (#43850202)
The way it worked for a real US high security job (TS/SCI) was that the clearance process was totally separate from the employer. The fingerprints and polygraph exams were done off premises. The famous SF-86 form[1], all 130 pages, had to be filled out, but nobody at the employer ever saw it. The checking and processing were done by the FBI or a unit in DoD.

(The current SF-86 only wants your residence addresses for the last 10 years. Used to be "List all residences from birth".)

[1] https://www.opm.gov/forms/pdf_fill/sf86.pdf

Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by Animats on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @03:08PM (#43849450)
If you're under attack by a foreign government, this isn't optional.
Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by philipallstar on Thursday May 01, 2025 @12:46PM (#43860175)
> I live in China, a supposedly autocratic country and one with universal ID, and even companies here don't take fingerprints. ID will be shown when you are officially onboard. I can't say for all, but for most companies (at least the ones without the need for a security clearance), requiring ID at interview will be seen as a red flag, and requiring fingerprint would probably be put on social media and name shamed, if not straight up reported to the authorities.

You're in a much more authoritarian country, and that would be using your non-universal, national ID. How do you authenticate someone coming in from overseas?

Answer: your authoritarian government doesn't let them in, or authenticates them for you in a joint process with your HR department.

Re:What It Takes to Defend a Cybersecurity Company from Toda... by Gathering6678 on Monday May 12, 2025 @11:38AM (#43964247)
For overseas workers, a. it is quite difficult for foreigners to get a working visa in China (though I suppose it's more of an immigration issue rather than the country being authoritarian); b. companies would probably use their passports. So you're kind of correct. However, my point still holds: fingerprints for interviewees, even in China, is at best extremely uncommon, and at worst (?) illegal in most cases.

Btw, I am nitpicking here, but by universal I meant used across the whole country, i.e. national.