D) the child remains with the legally resident / citizen parent or their immediate families
In these cases they have legally resident parents, just not the one who the child was with when snatched without due process. They’re being denied the ability to coordinate the handoff of the child to the other parent or family who can take responsibility. ICE is not allowing the families to coordinate the child’s care - they’re isolating the parent from their broader families, denying due process, access to legal representation, and unilaterally deporting US citizen children who have other options but were denied the ability to access them.
In the United States our constitution assures -all people- due process and basic human rights. There is no carve out that if you’re visiting the country or otherwise not a citizen that you can be summarily detained, deprived of liberty, and handled however the government chooses including extraordinary rendition to third countries for indefinite imprisonment without recourse. Nothing that is happening is allowable, or even defensible because however you feel about immigration - every action being taken could be taken to tourists, students, or other guests if allowed under the premise only citizens enjoy protections.
And in these cases, even citizens are being given no deference - and the fact they’re toddlers should be even more frightening.
Here’s a quote from the release that basically implies ICE is murdering one child summarily:
“””a U.S. citizen child suffering from a rare form of metastatic cancer was deported without medication or the ability to consult with their treating physicians–despite ICE being notified in advance of the child’s urgent medical needs.“””
So, the headline as written dramatically understates the situation, and the proposed dichotomy is false. There are many other options, spelled out in the law and regulation and requirements - even constitutionally - and they’re being ignored as an apparent matter of political policy.
Is that true? I re-read the article (but didn’t google for other sources), but nowhere could I see that definitively stated.
It would be interesting if the deportable mother of one of these minors (e.g. the one who is pregnant) decided to leave them with other family in the US rather than stay together as a family, but it is of course her right to make such a decision.
PDF: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.lawd.21...
Having deportation as an actual threat, reduces the amount of people who attempt to break the rules since they know there are consequences.
e) Amnesty if living here for awhile and not causing a ruckus.[0] US is huge, it needs more people not less.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Reform_and_Control...
There was a perfectly cromulent immigration plan ready to be voted on by Congress before Trump threw a tantrum because it would have hurt his election chances.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Reform_and_Contr...
Would be nice if we had more housing for that.
Illegally immigrating to the US is a civil violation, not a criminal one, and far less of a threat to US safety than going 5mph over the speed limit or running red lights. It is entirely lawful for the executive and judicial branches to use discretion and compassion in cases when under-18 US citizens are involved.
It can be both, depending on the situation:
• First-time illegal entry into the U.S. (like crossing the border without inspection) is a criminal misdemeanor under federal law (8 U.S.C. § 1325).
• Unlawful presence (like overstaying a visa) is usually a civil violation, not criminal. It can lead to deportation but not criminal charges.
You benefit from this monstrosity that takes advantage of people and leaves them destitute and you know it deep down. If yall support this don't ever delude yourself into thinking you're a good person.
I mean sure. But let's let the next Democrat who's in charge determine that kidnapping or maybe even voting wrong are crimes that merit summary deportation. After all, if they're good citizens, they can always return.
The history of suspending habeas corpus is strikingly one way. Maybe we'll be the first society to defy that trend. But the end game we're heading to is mass political violence.
That means you have the following options:
a) deport nobody, i.e. you don't apply the law
b) deport just the parents. What do you do with the minor children? Separating them from their parents (different countries) would be cruel.
c) deport the entire family, including the US minors. Since they have US citizenship, they can always return to the US.