Re:Why LLM-Powered Programming Is More Mech Suit Than Artifi...
by bluefirebrand on Monday April 21, 2025 @12:04PM
(#43753503)
> If I'm doing HTML React where there's a million examples of existing stuff, then great
I do quite a bit of this and even here LLMs seem extremely hit and miss, leaning towards the miss side more often than not
Re:Why LLM-Powered Programming Is More Mech Suit Than Artifi...
by ijk on Monday April 21, 2025 @03:46PM
(#43755698)
I think React is one of those areas where consistency is more important than individual decisions. With a lot of front-end webdev there's many right answers, but they're only right if they are aligned with the other design decisions. If you've ever had to edit a web page with three different approaches to laying out the CSS you know what I mean.
LLMs _can_ do consistency, they're pretty good continuing a pattern...if they can see it. Which can be hard if it's scattered around the codebase.
Re:Why LLM-Powered Programming Is More Mech Suit Than Artifi...
by bluefirebrand on Monday April 21, 2025 @03:56PM
(#43755791)
> one of those areas where consistency is more important than individual decisions
This describes any codebase in any programming language
This is why "programming patterns" exist as a concept
The fact that LLMs are bad at this is a pretty big mark against them
Re:Why LLM-Powered Programming Is More Mech Suit Than Artifi...
by skydhash on Monday April 21, 2025 @04:51PM
(#43756328)
Consistency is why frameworks and libraries exists. Once you start to see consistency in your UI views, that's a good sign to further refine it into components and eliminate boilerplate.
Re:Why LLM-Powered Programming Is More Mech Suit Than Artifi...
by namaria on Monday April 21, 2025 @03:57PM
(#43755805)
> LLMs _can_ do consistency
They won't even consistently provide the same answer to the same input. Occasional consistency is inconsistency.
Re:Why LLM-Powered Programming Is More Mech Suit Than Artifi...
by bcrosby95 on Monday April 21, 2025 @04:38PM
(#43756214)
My favorite is when I ask it to fix a bug, and in the part of the code that doesn't change it still slightly rewords a comment.
Re:Why LLM-Powered Programming Is More Mech Suit Than Artifi...
by snovv_crash on Monday April 21, 2025 @01:13PM
(#43754177)
> Oh and I've caught the LLM randomly inserting vulnerabilities for absolutely no reason (e.g. adding permissions to the iframe sandbox attribute when I complained about UI layout issues).
Yeah, now get the LLM to write C++ for a public facing service, what could possibly go wrong?
It's a useful tool that can accelerate certain tasks, but it has a lot of sharp edges.