News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by ChuckMcM on Friday August 10, 2012 @05:23PM (#4368330)
So one wonders at what point you uplink to a satellite with ejectable flash drives which, when full, detach, make a gravity sling shot pass to leave orbit and then burn for a rendezvous with earth 9 months later. If I did the math right a 1TB drive returned from Mars in 9 months would be an effective bandwidth of 470K bits per second (or 47K bytes per second)
Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by eupharis on Friday August 10, 2012 @06:21PM (#4368589)
While we are dreaming, it would be better to have said flash drive picked up by a spacestation, refueled in orbit, and shot back to Mars.

Hmm. If storage continues to improve as fast as it has been, once the space infrastructure is there, this might be cost effective. We have a lot of data to send.

In particular, we are going to need to have a local cache of the internet on Mars. At best, the average minimum latency is 225 million kilometers / the speed of light = 12.51 minutes.

Vast data barges, roaming the solar system, keeping everyone in sync....

Building an interplanetary Internet is going to be very, very fun.

On a related note, never underestimate the bandwidth of a truck filled with...

Well I was going to say blueray disks. But the cheapest I can find bluray disks are 3 cents per gigabyte. 3 TB harddrives are easily had at 5 cents per gigabyte. If the data only needs to go 60 miles, then 120 drives ($18,000) in a truck would get 1 TB/sec, or 8,000 mbps...

Ouch. I'll go with a megabit connection. Once upon a time that sort of thing worked for bulk data ;)

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by mdwelsh on Saturday August 11, 2012 @09:59AM (#4370094)
An Interplanetary Internet is not a joke: It's been a serious field of study for a while. There is a SIG on the topic, and lots of work has been done to think about how Internet protocols would work across interplanetary distances and frequent disconnections:

http://www.ipnsig.org/aboutstudy.htm

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by mkramlich on Friday August 10, 2012 @11:26PM (#4369320)
> In particular, we are going to need to have a local cache of the internet on Mars.

I predict somewhere today at Google an engineer just got an idea for his 20% project. "Red Cache"

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by eupharis on Friday August 10, 2012 @11:56PM (#4369377)
I hope so. The trick would be, after there is a cache of the Internet on Mars, to only have to send the changes, not the whole Internet again.

Straight snapshots would probably be the only viable option though. And maybe make the policy, once a decade do a complete update. And every year, do "any webpage accessed by colonists in the past year will be updated. And the top 5-15% of webpages by popularity on Earth."

And during the year, the top 5% of webpages, and any webpage with specifically Mars relevant content would be updated "wirelessly."

The numbers would change constantly, depending on bandwidth and costs and whatnot. But the question "how to build the best asynchronous shadow Internet given such and such constraints" is fascinating.

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by merlincorey on Saturday August 11, 2012 @02:01PM (#4370593)
Did you know -- there are more ports on the internet than just 53 and 80?

-- A message from your friendly local hacker wizard

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by alinajaf on Saturday August 11, 2012 @05:49AM (#4369816)
The only thing your plan doesn't account for is how we get the updates from the web developers on Mars :-)
Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by packetslave on Saturday August 11, 2012 @12:48AM (#4369469)
Perhaps, but I just got an idea for an interview question...
Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by tankbot on Friday August 10, 2012 @07:44PM (#4368863)
We need to find some hive-mind aliens and dissect them in order to develop philotic protocols for instant transmission.

0 latency on funny cat videos from Uranus.

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by arrrg on Friday August 10, 2012 @05:55PM (#4368475)
Latency matters, too. Often all the data is necessary to make decisions so (for example) only immediately transmitting a limited subset of the data is not really an option.

It’s not like that rover is driving around autonomously. It has some autonomy, but it can’t decide what’s interesting and what’s not, what has to be investigated and what not.

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by ChuckMcM on Friday August 10, 2012 @08:24PM (#4368950)
True enough, but it would help in answering the critics who want NASA to return a 1080p/120fps 3D movie from mars. Send the movie via the flash drive.
Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by adestefan on Friday August 10, 2012 @09:57PM (#4369136)
The initial problem is building and sending the camera to Mars.
Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by DavidSJ on Friday August 10, 2012 @09:23PM (#4369074)
Unfortunately, to do a gravitational slingshot, you need a body other than the one relative to which you want to accelerate. So you can use Mars to accelerate relative to the Sun, but not relative to Mars.

This means if you're already in Mars orbit you need fuel(TM) to escape. One might consider a slingshot around Deimos or Phobos but I don't think that'd be helpful enough to justify its cost (could be wrong, but I've never seen it suggested in any Mars->Earth mission plan).

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by zandor on Friday August 10, 2012 @05:40PM (#4368410)
Sounds like a modern take on the Corona satellites.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corona_(satellite)

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by kleim on Friday August 10, 2012 @07:09PM (#4368761)
I see one huge issue: if you lose the flash drive, you lose ALL of the data you collected. At least you a assured to get part of the data when it is broadcast.
Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by InclinedPlane on Friday August 10, 2012 @06:14PM (#4368568)
Timeliness is quite important. In order to plan where to go and what to do next you need results from what you've just done. Without that you're just fumbling around blind.
Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by eric-hu on Friday August 10, 2012 @10:07PM (#4369160)
Such drives would be far more expensive than what we use daily. Factor in electronic shielding needed to prevent soft-errors from cosmic rays: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_ray#Effect_on_electronic...
Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by rodion_89 on Friday August 10, 2012 @05:44PM (#4368423)
470K bits == 58.75K bytes

(assuming 8-bit bytes)

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by ChuckMcM on Friday August 10, 2012 @07:10PM (#4368767)
Typically bytes are coded 8N1 (or 1 start bit, one stop bit, and 8 data bits) so 10 baud gets you 1 byte. Hence the nominal divide by 10 (this is 8b/10b encoding)

But in a pedantic sort of way, the computation should add extra bits for ECC since the drive has ECC bits already embedded in it, so a 1TB drive probably has more than 10 Tbits it is probably closer to 15 - 20 terabits.

Re:Mars to Earth at an average of 29 kbits/s by bluesmoon on Friday August 10, 2012 @06:26PM (#4368608)
you also need parity bits