News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by 1970-01-01 on Sunday April 13, 2025 @01:14AM (#43670257)
Same feeling here. ATSC 3.0 with DRM and persistent Internet requirements tells me this is going to be the downfall of OTA television. I can see ATSC 4.0 being a discounted ISP subscription paired with some OTA location checks via BPS.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by throwing_away on Sunday April 13, 2025 @04:04AM (#43670986)
There is 1 provider for ATSC3 DRM (which is already rolling out in major markets): Google Widevine.

There is 1 operating system for ATSC3 DRM: Android.

There are several SoCs that can be used for "Level 1 Widevine".

When a SoC is compromised and the key is leaked from the TEE, all models of that device with the key are now untrusted for Level 1.

I think people should just be aware of the state of play.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by geerlingguy on Sunday April 13, 2025 @09:54AM (#43672819)
At NAB someone asked one of the ATSC folks what would happen if the key is compromised and someone didn't connect a receiver to the Internet. The answer was "the receivers have many built in public keys. They should last the lifetime of the device."

Concerning because they could have a situation like with some 4K blu ray discs, your hardware becomes obsolete because DRM requires that cat and mouse game...

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by WorldMaker on Monday April 14, 2025 @04:27PM (#43685950)
Also with some manufacturers believing the lifetime of a device should be less than 5 years and ideally less than 3 years, and are treating software/firmware support in those lifetimes, there's a lot of perverse incentives hidden behind anyone suggesting "for the lifetime of the device". As bad as some of the old cable monopolies were, they were at least sometimes held to Ma Bell's "the lifetime of a device is supposed to be 60 years" standards (which Ma Bell didn't always follow either, but that's another matter). I realize the ATSC exists primarily to sell new standards, but maybe we need ways to get back to longer planning horizons than 3-5 years.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by lxgr on Sunday April 13, 2025 @10:34AM (#43673107)
Wow, and all that to encrypt hours of ads with a few minutes of the 20th rerun of some show in between...
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by sznio on Sunday April 13, 2025 @12:37PM (#43674005)
When you can't innovate, financialize.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by lxgr on Sunday April 13, 2025 @12:49PM (#43674098)
But what even is the business case here? I get the idea of encrypting pay TV, but isn't the entire point of free broadcast TV that it's... free?

It would be a different story if the DRM were available ubiquitously, e.g. in the way that arguably Widevine is for online streaming (but certainly not broadcast TV). Are rightholders that afraid of unauthorized out-of-market rebroadcasts that they'd rather obliterate their reachable market with stunts like that?

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by tonyarkles on Sunday April 13, 2025 @05:42PM (#43676074)
Yeah, if I squint and think back to the reasoning from previous generations of tech like this it’s that they don’t want people to be able to make bit-perfect recordings to save and share. By putting DRM on the broadcast stream they’re trying to make sure that it’s only usable as a one-time broadcast.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by Marsymars on Sunday April 13, 2025 @07:30PM (#43676638)
Free as in beer. See what happened to Aereo.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by Lammy on Monday April 14, 2025 @02:08AM (#43678507)
> But what even is the business case here? I get the idea of encrypting pay TV, but isn't the entire point of free broadcast TV that it's... free?

This should be a big clue that the spying is the point, and all the DRMs of the world are justification for spying instead of the other way around. Total Information Awareness is the path to completing the Great Work.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by gruez on Sunday April 13, 2025 @10:59AM (#43673277)
>When a SoC is compromised and the key is leaked from the TEE, all models of that device with the key are now untrusted for Level 1.

Has this actually happened? Especially for "appliances" like set-top boxes or blu-ray players, as opposed to something like a tablet which are presumably easier to hack.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by throwing_away on Monday April 14, 2025 @07:47AM (#43680267)
Yes, it happens all the time, especially as the devices age.

L1 devices remotely downgrade to become L3 devices. This has different effects depending on content provided from "totally unavailable" to "lower resolution".

It's both DRM and planned-obsolescence in one.

The qualifier: https://developer.android.com/privacy-and-security/security-...

The list: https://android.googleapis.com/attestation/status

The dev docs: https://github.com/doridori/Android-Security-Reference/blob/...

I'm not sure if it's confirmed, but it's believed Level 1 video output contains a watermarking scheme that ties the key to the media, so if it's leaked they can disable the key that leaked the content.

You can search around and find tons of angry consumers shouting into the void about widevine errors on older consumer devices.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by Alive-in-2025 on Sunday April 13, 2025 @02:36AM (#43670584)
So atsc 3 won't work unless you have some continuous "i'm user xyz watching this channel at time x.y.z" going back to the broadcaster?

Why would anyone use atsc 3? It's not free over the air, you can't spoof it?

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by TeMPOraL on Sunday April 13, 2025 @03:57AM (#43670951)
It's not like anyone's gonna ask them. Networks will just label this as ${network name}'s HYPER NEXT GEN 10G TV EXPERIENCE (HNG TV), market the shit out of it, and offer free ESPN on it, tack on some Paramount HBO Supermax Plus for $0.99/year and throw in a half-decent Smart TV as a sign-on bonus, and adoption will skyrocket.

TV networks in the US are a living proof that, with enough marketing spend and a pinch of confusion in the offer structure, you can sell people on anything. Half the time you can just offer sportsball access and people will switch.

It's how previous versions of broadcaster overreach happened, and why Smart TVs succeed despite their shortcomings.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by bayindirh on Sunday April 13, 2025 @05:42AM (#43671485)
I came to the same conclusion when I saw a whole armada of new TVs from every manufacturer in the eve of any World Cup. Plus TVs tailored for football has a special mode called "sports" which make football arguably look/feel better.

That kind of pumping makes me sad and sick.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by pridkett on Sunday April 13, 2025 @07:54AM (#43672099)
Or, the manufacturers will lose patience with slow adoption, the mess that is widevine DRM (what? Your TV isn’t based on Android? No, you can’t have DRM!), and customers really not caring because basically none of the broadcasts make the visual picture substantially better right now, so there is no incentive to move.

That’s what happened to LG [0]. They dropped ATSC 3.0 tuners. I’m sure this cost them precisely 0 sales as the industry incompetence destroys the broadcast industry.

[0]: https://www.theverge.com/2023/9/30/23897460/lg-drops-atsc-3-...

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by lotsofpulp on Sunday April 13, 2025 @07:56AM (#43672106)
> TV networks in the US are a living proof that, with enough marketing spend and a pinch of confusion in the offer structure, you can sell people on anything. Half the time you can just offer sportsball access and people will switch.

The cratering market values say otherwise. Few people under 40 even care about “TV”, and live sports distribution contracts (and the associated gambling) are the only thing holding it up.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by aydyn on Sunday April 13, 2025 @12:46PM (#43674081)
False, the majority of under 40 are still watching "TV" but just through intertube streaming. netflix, apple TV, amazon, and so on, all except apple have ads too.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by lxgr on Sunday April 13, 2025 @02:03PM (#43674623)
That's not really "TV", though (at least unless you'd also consider people buying a film or show on VHS or DVD "television").
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by WorldMaker on Monday April 14, 2025 @04:35PM (#43686020)
Some of it is still linear like broadcast, if that's your personal distinction. Pluto, for instance, has a surprisingly large audience. The return of linear TV is also a big buzzword in streaming today with a lot of the majors experimenting with or already reintegrating linear TV options (partly because services like Pluto proved it out, partly because some of the streamers realized linear again is the ultimate endgame of Netflix-like binge watching and YouTube-like autoplay and want to skip the intermediate steps and return to the original thing).
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by lxgr on Monday April 14, 2025 @05:48PM (#43686684)
Yes, there definitely is linear programming over the Internet, both free and paid.

We've finally come full circle: Linear broadcast TV -> TiVo (finally, no more missed episodes!) -> VOD, i.e. Netflix, Max, Hulu etc. (why linear broadcast everything to everyone if we can just OTT stream everything individually?) -> FAST, i.e. Pluto TV etc.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by lotsofpulp on Sunday April 13, 2025 @01:08PM (#43674230)
The post I responded to mentioned TV networks, not TV. In a thread discussing over the air TV, I took that to mean linear programming sold by CBS (soon to be Skydance), NBC (Comcast), ABC (Disney), and Fox (also Disney, I think), and the CW (Nexstar).

The crux of the matter being that even if OTA channels didn’t track people’s location, it wouldn’t matter since OTA itself going the way of the dodo.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by WorldMaker on Monday April 14, 2025 @04:44PM (#43686110)
Fox TV stations are now Fox Corp, aka "New Fox", the more direct successor to News Corp. Disney bought most (but not all) of News Corp's TV studio and film studio but knew it couldn't get past the FCC if it bought the TV stations (especially the sports stations).
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by TeMPOraL on Sunday April 13, 2025 @05:24PM (#43675962)
I too used to think TV is dead and no one is paying for cable anymore, but every now and then I keep hearing it's still alive and well, and that's always in association with some big sportsball events; I can believe that their customers nowadays are almost entirely sports fans, but then the pull they have with that segment is still strong. In my mind, the term "ESPN" registers as "something to dangle in front of US customers to get them to buy some TV plan".
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by geerlingguy on Sunday April 13, 2025 @09:54AM (#43672825)
It's being marketed as "NEXTGEN TV" so not far off.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by ThinkingGuy on Sunday April 13, 2025 @10:35AM (#43673118)
Remember during the switch to digital TV, when marketers convinced half the population that they needed to buy a new "digital antenna" to keep viewing the same channels?
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by philistine on Sunday April 13, 2025 @08:19PM (#43676910)
This is so user-hostile that I don't believe there will be any adoption. It will have to be shoved down the throat of those who use broadcast, which are overwhelmingly older and more remote.

ATSC first generation will probably outlive this DRM-driven abomination.