News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Kerala got rich by not_kurt_godel on Friday March 28, 2025 @05:17PM (#43509884)
The connection between education and wealth is very strong. Very sad that the US has decided to pursue a trajectory towards poverty in this area.
Re:How Kerala got rich by mc32 on Friday March 28, 2025 @05:51PM (#43510181)
In popular US culture the pursuit of wealth, is framed as crass. Movies that some see as promoting wealth accumulation are often actually critiques against wealth.

Also, since the mid 60s pop culture has embraced the slacker as being hip and cool.

They guy and gal trying to get ahead are portrayed as greedy or at best blindly joining a rat-race forgoing more noble pursuits. Not so for many other cultures.

Re:How Kerala got rich by paulluuk on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:05PM (#43510314)
I think that in almost all western countries, a life spent entirely on hoarding wealth for the sake of wealth, is considered a sad life. Especially if you don't even have any loved ones to share your wealth with.

I think the same it true for most of Latin america, where many of my friends and colleagues are from. And when I was in Nepal they thought that, if anything, western people are way too much focused on gathering wealth.

Islam specifically rejects hoarding wealth, so I think that pretty much takes out most of the middle east and northern africa.

So I'm curious which other cultures you are referring to. Perhaps specifically Indian and Chinese culture?

Re:How Kerala got rich by nick__m on Friday March 28, 2025 @10:22PM (#43512171)

  Islam specifically rejects hoarding wealth, so I think that pretty much takes out most of the middle east
I don't know much about religions but I don't believe it is that clearly delineated. How would you explain Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, Qatar and Bahrain, from my limited vantage point they seem pretty much all in on their religion. Are they practicing a perverse form of Islam like the Christian who practice prosperity gospel?
Re:How Kerala got rich by blululu on Saturday March 29, 2025 @01:25AM (#43512998)
Islam is probably the most economically savvy major religion (Mohammed was a merchant after all). Unlike other religions which issue blanket prohibitions on things like charging interest or having wealth Islam is more pragmatic. Hoarding wealth is considered sinful when it means that others are going without but it is not a sin to make money, have money or be rich. The gulf states could all broadly be described as socialist. Yes they have a lot of money but pretty much everyone lives on welfare and enjoys a high quality of life (nobody is going hungry or falling ill from easily treated diseases). In a country where everyone has attained a high standard of living there is no issue with someone having a huge pile of cash. We could throw out labor issues from guest workers, but that is a bigger topic.
Re:How Kerala got rich by Gud on Saturday March 29, 2025 @03:27AM (#43513540)
Sorry but they cannot be described as socialist because workers rights are non existent. Just because there is some protection for the native Arabs doesn't mean it can be "broadly described as socialist". There is no protection for the Bangladeshis, Filipinos, Indians, etc, who are doing the work. Protecting the working class is pretty much the point of socialism. This is a ludicrous statement.
Re:How Kerala got rich by ern on Saturday March 29, 2025 @04:12AM (#43513717)
They’re welfare states, with three classes of residents. A slave-like underclass, disenfranchised expats, and citizens who get paid off by their royal families with generous benefits. Maybe the closest analogy is Ancient Rome?
Re:How Kerala got rich by Gud on Saturday March 29, 2025 @04:24AM (#43513784)
I don't think the underclass is living under slave like conditions though.

Full disclosure, I worked in Dubai for 2 years(as a disenfranchised expat), working closely with guys from above mentioned countries. I install heavy machinery.

It's true some are treated poorly, but most are there genuinely there out of free will, because they make buckets of money to send back home. One Pakistani foreman I worked with had stashed away 250k Dirhams and was going back home to start his own business.

The gulf states can/could be an opportunity for the poor, see Bin Laden family for a famous example.

More than criticizing the gulf states for using these people as cheap labor, the criticism should be aimed at their corrupt governments not giving opportunities to their own population. Ironically they are not even allowed inside Europe and the US.

FWIW my experience in Dubai changed my views on the region to a much more nuanced one.

Re:How Kerala got rich by aprilthird2021 on Saturday March 29, 2025 @02:54AM (#43513380)
There's no such thing as prosperity gospel in Islam. I researched all the major religions when I decided to become religious in my 20s. The prosperity gospel even in Christianity has very loose / 0 underpinnings in any actual theological study.

The Gulf countries became wealthy because of oil. They don't really hoard that wealth though. They are pretty famous around the world for investing that money, no? They fund universities (with many Gulf countries having their own outpost of NYU or other such prestigious colleges), arts and arts museums (there is a Louvre in the Middle East), tech startups, and of course invest in tourism to diversify their country.

They also have many horrible qualities, which are 100% not condoned in Islam like employing slaves in deadly conditions even though all nations agreed to abolish slavery years ago. Or confiscating the passports of foreign workers. Or their ethnostate mentality (similar to Israel where citizens must be of a specific blood lineage even though the majority of people living in their nation are not of that lineage). I could go on and on.

Anyways, Tl;Dr, I don't think they really hoard wealth. They do spend and invest in the world around them and find lots of charitable things (they have rebuilt Palestine a few times now, a very costly endeavor). Also, being Muslim doesn't mean they don't do anything morally wrong by that religion's standard. Same as the many charlatan "priests" of various religions in the world.

Re:How Kerala got rich by thisislife2 on Saturday March 29, 2025 @06:04AM (#43514204)
Islam is a very practical religion. And that applies to how it treats wealth and socialism.

Like many religion it emphasises the importance of being good, and doing good, to enjoy the rewards of that in the after life (i.e. it teaches delayed gratification). But it also recognizes that advocating its adherent to forego all wordly attachment and live like a saint is also not practical for society. Thus, it also pragmatically says that a muslims doesn't have to wait for the afterlife to enjoy the rewards of good deeds - God has given humans the ability to enjoy certain pleasures in life, and achieve a higher sense of spiritual enlightenment, and that too depends on the good deeds you do in this life:

    Whoever does good, whether male or female, and is a believer, We will surely bless them with a good life, and We will certainly reward them according to the best of their deeds. (Quran 16:97)
Islamic scholars interpret this as a promise from God to the Children of Adam, who do righteous deeds - deeds in accordance with the Book of God and the teachings of His Prophet, with a heart that believes in God and His Messenger. God promises that He will give them a good life in this world and that He will reward them according to the best of their deeds in the Hereafter. Some scholars say this means a life with feelings of tranquillity in all aspects of life, while some suggest it means contentment and / or happiness in this life.

More here: https://islamqa.info/en/answers/12702/is-there-reward-for-go...

That is why no muslim needs to feel guilty about the wealth they have inherited or earned provided it is done through honest means, without hurting others, and they also follow the Islamic obligations of Zakat (charity). This charity is how socialism works in Islam. Islam says that the wealth of the world doesn't belong to anyone but God. And wealthy muslims (and rulers) are just custodians of his wealth. And God commands the wealthy to share their wealth with the poor, and prescribes how this should be done (annually 2.5% of your wealth should be given to the poor and needy). Even here, Islam is very practical - it recognizes how human nature is often suspicious of helping strangers, and thus says to look for people within your own family, your own friends, your own neighbourhood, your own muslim community etc. (i.e. your own social circles) to do this kind of charity.

More on this: https://thequranrecital.com/zakat-obligatory-charity-explain...

And this kind of wealth creation, with charity, is seen in the middle-east, amongst all these middle-eastern countries you mentioned.

Re:How Kerala got rich by YouAreRONGS on Saturday March 29, 2025 @02:01AM (#43513154)
It's also commonplace in traditional Buddhist and Hindu cultures, especially a lot of the older upper class in India are obsessed with following Gandhi-like living too. You still find it in many Buddhist countries like Sri Lanka and South East Asia too.
Re:How Kerala got rich by aprilthird2021 on Saturday March 29, 2025 @02:55AM (#43513384)
The world would be a great place if the older upper classes learned from and tried to emulate Gandhi
Re:How Kerala got rich by YouAreRONGS on Saturday March 29, 2025 @02:59AM (#43513406)
A lot of the older upper class Hindus in India do actually act like that. And it's also quite common in Sri Lanka and South East Asia for the upper class to do that.
Re:How Kerala got rich by zozbot234 on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:06PM (#43510319)
A lot depends on how exactly you pursue wealth. You could say that Donald Trump and Elon Musk have both striven to "pursue wealth" in their business careers, but nonetheless they did so in very different ways. And plenty of people will likely find Donald's approach somewhat "crass" compared to Elon's.
Re:How Kerala got rich by anon291 on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:05PM (#43512358)
That's because America is fundamentally a Christian country. I know no one wants to hear this. But this zeitgeist is unmistakenly Christian.

Interestingly enough the same forces are at work in kerala, which is one of the most Christian states in India (and the ruling communists are associated with them)

Re:How Kerala got rich by mc32 on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:19PM (#43512437)
Can you expound on this idea? What does anti-wealth have to do with Christianity and how does Communism enter the frame in India?

Prior to the mid 60s seeking betterment and wealth was one of the main reasons people migrated to the US replacing religious persecution back home as the main reason to come.

Re:How Kerala got rich by aprilthird2021 on Saturday March 29, 2025 @02:57AM (#43513394)
Christianity (esp. Catholicism) and socialism have a long connection, especially in South America, which did not have the economic miracle Kerala did.

Kerala did not become wealthy from socialism, it became literate and land reform lifted many out of poverty. The actual wealth started accumulating when Keralites took advantage of opportunities to work abroad and send remittances home. That has been a major economic driver for the state and India as a whole, but they did it long before others did, largely because land reform gave people a safety net to fall back on so they could risk going abroad to earn more

Re:How Kerala got rich by Lio on Sunday March 30, 2025 @08:09AM (#43523479)
Socialism maybe the but the Roman Catholic church has a strong history of opposition to communism.

I would suggest God's Bankers: A History of Money and Power at the Vatican as for a pop-culture introduction of how the Catholic church aligned itself with fascist states including Mussolini's PNF, the Nazis and the Ustaše.

The Ustaše were particularly closely associated with the Catholic church.

Re:How Kerala got rich by anon291 on Sunday March 30, 2025 @11:57AM (#43525141)
> Roman Catholic church has a strong history of opposition to communism

India is so far removed from Europe that things work a bit differently.

The keralites were not communist the way European countries were

Re:How Kerala got rich by SandraBucky on Saturday March 29, 2025 @11:13AM (#43516168)
I was raised by a catholic system in Kerala christian heartland. For decades every Roman Catholic church required to have a school associated with it mostly primary but often secondary - managed by priests and nuns. These priests are heavily connected to Rome often visiting or getting their degree from there. I often hear Matthew 19:23-24 preached during sunday mass and many people have become content with what they have even though its barely enough.

If you ask me about communism, I would say its effects were kind of bad - overseas remittence came in as gulf nations flourished but for others from 60s till end of 90's economic opportunities were bleak. It came in power around 1956 in Kerala and a lot of privileged christians migrated to US in the following decades - with the christian cultural background they have, they integrated really well in that society.

Re:How Kerala got rich by anon291 on Saturday March 29, 2025 @12:05PM (#43516522)
Christianity in India is often framed against the prevailing religion Hinduism, for better or worse. The Indian church emphasizes things like social equality, income equality, etc. Some of the earliest labor activists and trade unionists in India were Catholic (actually Catholics in general are generally pro union across the world, see the Catholic vote here in America).

Secondly, Catholics are often setting up schools for everyone. India has always had a history of education, especially Kerala, but universal education of even the lower classes is extremely protestant. The church ended up adopting this around the time colonialism started and thus brought universal education to a widespread base in India.

Finally, the idea of touching everyone and treating them equally was against the general zeitgeist of the prevailing feudalistic highly hierarchical indian society. The first conversion attempts of the Portuguese for the south indian brahmins actually were incredibly successful (Nicholas of Tolentino). The Vatican even allows (and still allows as far as I'm aware, although no one does it) vedic rites for Catholics (malabar rites controversy).

However, no one wanted to give up untouchability. The Vatican eventually forced the missionaries to not have separate missions for touchables and untouchables, which basically ended Brahmanic conversions (and is one of the reasons indian Catholics no longer really care to do the vedic rites, since most are now from the lower class. As far as I know, some still do in Mangalore). Caste is still a problem in some christian communities in India but the bishops work to end it and it is officially condemned.

Which is to say, catholicism is associated with labor movement, equal social treatment, and universal education.

Which is also what the communists want.

It's no surprise that Kerala, being way more christian (and Catholic particularly) with a rich and prominent Christian history is thus the center of socialism.

Keep in mind also that communism in feudal countries has basically no relation to the communism you find on university campuses of america.

Now to the west. In the west, the church is seen as conservative, but the church is actually radically left wing in most parts of the world. It's only because leftism (in a global sense) is fundamentally a part of western culture that the church seems right wing because the church does not go as far as some leftist parties in the west.

Re:How Kerala got rich by evan_ on Saturday March 29, 2025 @12:23AM (#43512706)
I don't think this is true anymore. "Selling out" is now seen as a goal. Kids post fake ads on their instagrams to convince each other that they have brand sponsorship deals. Every celebrity, from reality-show nobody to AAA-lister shills for their own signature alcohol or cell phone carrier. The culture celebrates grindset mindset crypto-scam rugpulls and denigrates anyone who toils at a 9-5 as a wage-slave who'll never make it.
Re:How Kerala got rich by WorkerBee28474 on Friday March 28, 2025 @10:37PM (#43512229)
It may be strong to a point, but many countries are beyond that point. Look at how many countries there are that are better educated than the USA but have lower incomes. Japan, Germany, Canada, probably dozens more.
Re:How Kerala got rich by zoul on Saturday March 29, 2025 @01:20AM (#43512974)
Higher income does not equal higher quality of life. Which is, arguably, what really matters to people.
Re:How Kerala got rich by aprilthird2021 on Saturday March 29, 2025 @02:46AM (#43513350)
QoL is a relative metric though. If you see people around you living better than you, your QoL becomes poor even though you live better than 99% of people in the world
Re:How Kerala got rich by bakuninsbart on Saturday March 29, 2025 @10:27AM (#43515838)
Three points on that:

1. Secondary and tertiary education is not all there is to education. A self-learned software engineer might lack a capital-E education, but has still spent significant time and effort on learning.

2. Education is one of many aspects of a successful life, at least as important is conscientiousness, diligence, intelligence and luck.

3. The US benefits from many virtuous cycles. In regards to the labor force it is able to attract a lot of the best talent in the world.

Given the current political climate in the US, it seems prudent to point out that point 3 isn't just true for business-men, doctors and other nerds, undocumented immigrants are some of the hardest-working people out there. They contribute almost 100b in taxes alone, and get almost no services in return.

Re:How Kerala got rich by tonyhart7 on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:17PM (#43512426)
but US have many top ranking universities in the world, how can you believe that US is behind in education?
Re:How Kerala got rich by SJC_Hacker on Saturday March 29, 2025 @10:17AM (#43515749)
Universities accept international students, and hire faculty educated outside the US

More relevant would be K-12

Re:How Kerala got rich by azinman2 on Saturday March 29, 2025 @11:37AM (#43516342)
It’s all relevant, but there is zero doubt that the US has the best higher education in the world (although this administration seems hell bent on attacking it). There’s a reason more international students come to the US than anywhere else for higher education.
Re:How Kerala got rich by xhkkffbf on Saturday March 29, 2025 @12:35PM (#43516711)
They hire foreigners largely because they're much cheaper than Americans. The schools have little trouble getting visas for foreign professors so, of course, they maximize their profits by hiring the cheapest they can get.
Re:How Kerala got rich by SJC_Hacker on Saturday March 29, 2025 @02:01PM (#43517306)
I don't think thats the case at all

At least in STEM, its all about the ability to get grants. A professor who consistently gets grants is worth their weight in gold in "indirect" costs. Foreigner or otherwise

Re:How Kerala got rich by xhkkffbf on Sunday March 30, 2025 @11:24AM (#43524892)
Look at any department. It's rare for all of the professors to get big grants. Usually a substantial fraction are essentially paid by either undergraduate or graduate tuition. In these cases of the non-constellation professors, it's better to get someone who is both good enough and cheap.
Re:How Kerala got rich by YouAreRONGS on Saturday March 29, 2025 @01:56AM (#43513128)
Literacy is a by-product of raising living standards. It's not inherintly something that will alone lead to higher living standards.
Re:How Kerala got rich by aprilthird2021 on Saturday March 29, 2025 @02:46AM (#43513347)
While I agree, countries like the US where everyone was pretty much already literate decades ago, can and do backslide into anti-intellectualism even when living standards are rising. I have seen it myself.
Re:How Kerala got rich by YouAreRONGS on Saturday March 29, 2025 @02:50AM (#43513366)
Is that really anti-intellectualism? Do you have any examples?
Re:How Kerala got rich by peterfirefly on Saturday March 29, 2025 @09:08AM (#43515236)
Europe had really high literacy long before it reached the living standard of most of current Africa. Living standards do not have to be high for near universal literacy.
Re:How Kerala got rich by panick21_ on Saturday March 29, 2025 @04:54AM (#43513913)
Questionable. There is defiantly some connection, but in what direction is open for debate. But its also the case that the Soviet block countries had lots of educated people, but couldn't make the economy work out.

And given for how many years the US has had sub-optimal results in international education comparison, while the overall economy has done well also doesn't fit.

Re:How Kerala got rich by xhkkffbf on Saturday March 29, 2025 @12:34PM (#43516703)
Education is tricky. The wrong education can really stunt your economic competitiveness. I'm sure the Soviet world had plenty of classroom time devoted to the glory of Communism. Each classroom probably had a politruk available to help out.

Too many kids go to other universities and study similar things. It's fine to explore these ideas, but at the end of the day you've got to make someone happy or they won't pay you.

Re:How Kerala got rich by panick21_ on Saturday March 29, 2025 @01:27PM (#43517071)
They also had really good maths and other useful things. They actually did what many in the West many wanted. Their education wasn't bad, learning wrong history isn't really that economically relevant.

But yeah, if the economy can't use those people its just not effective.

Re:How Kerala got rich by human_person on Saturday March 29, 2025 @01:49PM (#43517223)
Learning wrong history can be economically relevant. So much of history is about learning patterns of human behavior. Patterns that often repeat. If you learn wrong or untrue history your understanding of and expectations for human behavior will be incorrect which will certainly cause economic issues.
Re:How Kerala got rich by panick21_ on Saturday March 29, 2025 @03:53PM (#43518160)
Maybe if you are in top level government. But for 99% of workers it doesn't matter much.

Also, much of typical school history most people learn is incredibly shallow and the waste majority of people barley remember anything. Research show this pretty clearly. So teaching something wrong, is not gone matter much.

Re:How Kerala got rich by xhkkffbf on Sunday March 30, 2025 @11:26AM (#43524905)
No one does fake history better than the CCCP.
Re:How Kerala got rich by sporkland on Saturday March 29, 2025 @04:54AM (#43513916)
I honestly can't tell if you're referring to the current administration or the previous one with this comment.

(Fun SNL video with similar confusion: https://youtu.be/8h_N80qKYOM)

Re:How Kerala got rich by inglor_cz on Saturday March 29, 2025 @07:02AM (#43514474)
I think that with TikTok and such channels squeezing out the ability to read, the entire humanity is embarking on a massive de-literatization experiment.
Re:How Kerala got rich by torginus on Saturday March 29, 2025 @08:33AM (#43515031)
That's patently not true. The connection exists only as far as if you're uneducated (and/or have subnormal IQ), you're likely to be poor, I suspect because you're not smart enough to master the basic skills to function in society, so it might be because of the latter.

Outside of the US there are very few countries where being highly educated (as in having an in-demand degree from a prestigious university) nets you anything beyond a small earnings bump over the middle class, and the people who have this are a small elite (no more than a few percent) everywhere.