News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by alejohausner on Thursday March 27, 2025 @05:20PM (#43498322)
For me, the problem with this setup (and with most high efficiency LED lights) is the lack of red wavelenghts. Real sunlight has a substantial amount of energy in the very red end of the visible spectrum (700 nm) and also of course quite a bit in the infrared. These lamps have two spectral peaks: a narrow peak in the blue range, around 450 nm, a broader peak in the green, centered around 580 nm. That greenish peak falls off sharply, and has almost no energy in the red end.

The color sensitive cones in our eye have three peaks of sensitivity, the S cones in the blue range, the M cones in the green, and the L cones in yellow. The L cones are what your brain uses to see red colors, but they are actually pretty insensitive to deep reds like 700 nm. That’s why you THINK that LED lamps produce red, because they stimulate your L cones, but they do so without actually emitting much red energy at all!

Our bodies are sensitive to deep red light. The cytochrome in our mitochondria respond to it. There’s an experiment where shining red lights on the skin improved sugar metabolism. That makes sense, because we naked apes evolved under red-rich sunlight.

So these lamps may look like sunlight, but they’re missing some crucial wavelengths.

Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by fouronnes3 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @05:23PM (#43498352)
That's a good point, but not much I can do about that. Such a DIY project is limited to off the shelf LED suppliers. It would be cool to do such a lamp with both the high CRI and some infrared, also for heating (infrared lamps are a thing after all).
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by alejohausner on Thursday March 27, 2025 @07:49PM (#43499634)
I don’t think manufacturers will make LEDs with strong deep-red emission. If they made LEDs that emitted lots of red light, they probably would have a peak in the red end of the spectrum. But since they’re not monochromatic single-wavelength sources like lasers, there would be a spread of wavelengths around that red peak, including substantial infrared emission. And that IR emission makes heat, and now you’ve created an inefficient lamp, similar to the old incandescent filament lamps.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by ajolly on Thursday March 27, 2025 @09:40PM (#43500479)
I'm just a customer of some their other products but... https://getchroma.co/products/skylight. (Of course as you know you're now drawing a ton of power for things other than lumens)
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by zokier on Thursday March 27, 2025 @07:38PM (#43499538)
> These lamps have two spectral peaks: a narrow peak in the blue range, around 450 nm, a broader peak in the green, centered around 580 nm. That greenish peak falls off sharply, and has almost no energy in the red end

Check figure 1h in the datasheet of the LEDs author used https://otmm.lumileds.com/adaptivemedia/832eef99dd3139f98fa9...

The second peak is near 650nm and while it drops fairly quickly there is still decent amount of power at even 700nm. In short, they perform far better than your stereotypical crappy white LEDs.

Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by alejohausner on Thursday March 27, 2025 @07:56PM (#43499674)
Yes, I saw those spectra. No, I don’t see very much energy emitted for wavelengths >700 nm.

If you look at spectra for stereotypical crappy white LEDs, they’re really no different. Everyone uses the same light emitting compounds, it seems to me.

Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by ankitml on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:07PM (#43498735)
Yep, that was my first assessment. Cant call it sun without NIR.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by fouronnes3 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:15PM (#43498813)
Can't call it sun without gravitational confinement nuclear fusion either.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by ankitml on Friday March 28, 2025 @10:05AM (#43505589)
you do you. NIR is the part of sunlight that makes you "feel" good or alive or whatever nice thing you are looking from being outside.. Ill stick with NIR is essential component for calling stream of photons as sun-like.. or not sun-like.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by agensaequivocum on Saturday March 29, 2025 @08:51PM (#43520138)
Or lack of flicker.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by firju55 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:50PM (#43499140)
If the metric you're looking for is most accurate spectrum including deep red, near and far infrared (heat), then a good old incandescent filament light is the most efficient device. Not LEDs.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by genewitch on Thursday March 27, 2025 @09:57PM (#43500593)
In the winter a couple incandescent lights per room is often enough to warm it up. I went out of my way this winter to "seal up" my house, and the equivalent of 2-3 bulbs per room is enough to keep them livable - with a sweater and a cap, and maybe socks. I cannot stand artificial heat, something about kt makes me physically uncomfortable, and i just want to leave an area with artificial heat. I'm fine with fires and incadescent bulbs, though.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by crazygringo on Thursday March 27, 2025 @05:33PM (#43498453)
> So these lamps may look like sunlight, but they’re missing some crucial wavelengths.

Which means they're also not going to give me a tan... bug, or feature?

Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by lll-o-lll on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:13PM (#43498795)
Tan is the other end of the spectrum (UV)
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by crazygringo on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:20PM (#43498855)
They said crucial wavelengths, plural. I took that to its natural conclusion. ;)
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:24PM (#43498908)
It also won't be a great disinfectant, both in literal and figurative senses of the phrase.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by drewolbrich on Thursday March 27, 2025 @05:50PM (#43498588)
My issue with this setup is that it doesn't emit as many neutrinos as the Sun.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by ketralnis on Thursday March 27, 2025 @05:54PM (#43498637)
Have you considered taking neutrino supplements?

The nice thing about them is that they're flavour changing

Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by gblargg on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:23AM (#43502125)
My neighbor takes them so I get the benefits too.
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by aljgz on Thursday March 27, 2025 @06:21PM (#43498871)
Good that you get your sunborn nutrino fix even in cloudy days (and much of it even at night)
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by baueric on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:22AM (#43502119)
I have noticed after a distant super nova I always feel better
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by gregwebs on Thursday March 27, 2025 @08:54PM (#43500128)
What you want is at odds with energy efficiency and is therefore being made illegal https://blog.medcram.com/uncategorized/new-department-of-ene...
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by x-complexity on Thursday March 27, 2025 @09:08PM (#43500239)
Again, another regulatory decision that makes a niche worse off overall....

Abuses of a carve-out aside, having a "Sunlight mimicking" exemption would solve this, with the added conditions that they have to actually stick to the EMF outputs of the sun to get this approval. The article itself does this with “General Wellness Lamps”.

Otherwise, the only non-reg way to solve this would be to find infrared & red LEDs and make the supplementary light sources yourself.

Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by cenamus on Friday March 28, 2025 @04:09AM (#43502776)
I mean, wouldn't an IR carbon filament heater suffice? Probably a bit longer wavelengths, but you can still see it glow, so you're getting at least a bit close to the visible spectrum
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by KolibriFly on Friday March 28, 2025 @03:03AM (#43502383)
That's a really interesting point, and one I hadn't considered in depth...
Re:I tried making artificial sunlight at home by puzzlingcaptcha on Friday March 28, 2025 @09:01AM (#43504877)
You can get LEDs which mimic the spectrum of natural light more closely, but these are usually specialty products (often specifically branded as sun-like). Here's one example https://www.greesled.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/ab24a411...

In comparison, the LEDs chosen by the OP have a fairly poor power distribution spectrum. At 4000K the color temperature is also too low to mimic daylight, which is at around 5500K. This is all well as an artistic choice but probably doesn't get you any benefits for seasonal affective disorder.