News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eli Lilly will soon release key data on its weight loss p... by timewizard on Monday March 24, 2025 @05:28PM (#43465576)
It could be the biggest drug. It might get out of phase 3. It may get approval very soon. And of course, "may be a game changer."

When the news is this fast and loose with anything that even looks like a fact how am I not to see this as rank manipulation? There is nothing critical in this article except for how hard doctors and insurance companies might be pressed to prescribe it.

Then they end with this gem:

"But Seigerman said it will also put pressure on smaller companies developing pills, such as Structure Therapeutics, to find a partner that can help them compete in the weight loss drug market with pharmaceutical behemoths like Eli Lilly. "

Oh. I see. It's not just manipulation but dumb protectionist gate keeping.

Depressing.

Re:Eli Lilly will soon release key data on its weight loss p... by RedditKon on Monday March 24, 2025 @05:32PM (#43465603)
Phase 2 clinical trials showed 14.7% mean weight reduction at 36 weeks in adults.

That's pretty substantial. Obviously no one knows what Phase 3 will show, but cynicism seems unwarranted at this point.

https://investor.lilly.com/news-releases/news-release-detail...

Re:Eli Lilly will soon release key data on its weight loss p... by timewizard on Monday March 24, 2025 @06:18PM (#43465984)
So you're telling me that in addition to this article Eli Lilly themselves only have good things to say about their upcoming product? I don't feel that's enough to claim that cynicism is unwarranted. It's a drug. There are more ways for it to be harmful than helpful. This is why we have trials and an entire federal department dedicated to this exact question.

I'd honestly be more assured if there was anything other than pure self assessed speculation at play here, and again, if Eli Lilly clearly wasn't using this article to bully smaller players in the space. You know, before they even have a released product.

This is called hacker news but the hacker mentality is almost entirely missing here.

Re:Eli Lilly will soon release key data on its weight loss p... by derektank on Monday March 24, 2025 @07:30PM (#43466517)
I don't understand what your criticism is here exactly. Of course Eli Lilly will release a press release if the results of a clinical trial are good but that doesn't make the underlying research (published in the Lancet [1]) suspect in any way. Clinical trials are overseen by the FDA and frequently conducted by third party research scientists without a financial stake in the long term success of the intervention being studied. In this case, it appears that the study authors were researchers at Velocity Clinical Research and they found significant body weight loss with side effects comparable with other GLP-1 agonists. Skepticism might be warranted, particularly until phase 3 trials are conducted, but mindless cynicism hardly seems warranted.

[1] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

Re:Eli Lilly will soon release key data on its weight loss p... by timewizard on Monday March 24, 2025 @08:13PM (#43466805)
> I don't understand what your criticism is here exactly.

The posted article is marketing and not journalism. I have learned absolutely nothing from it. It seeks to manipulate a market before the product is even released.

> but mindless cynicism hardly seems warranted.

I'm sorry that you're unwilling to consider any facts outside of your very narrow view. That does not make my comments cynical nor mindless. There does seem to be an intentional mindlessness in pretending that any of this is beyond your understanding.