News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pron on Saturday March 22, 2025 @10:39AM (#43445930)
Generics, interfaces/traits/concepts, macros, conditional compilation, const functions/constexpr. These are four or five different features in C++ or Rust, some of which are quite complex, all expressible as one simple construct: comptime.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by kobebrookskC3 on Saturday March 22, 2025 @12:05PM (#43446707)
how does zig express a trait like Send https://doc.rust-lang.org/std/marker/trait.Send.html which ensures that values can safely be moved to another thread, for example when spawning a thread? https://doc.rust-lang.org/std/thread/fn.spawn.html
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by throwawaymaths on Saturday March 22, 2025 @02:22PM (#43447550)
if you want that you will need a proof checker or something.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pcwalton on Saturday March 22, 2025 @08:15PM (#43449779)
Such as the one Rust provides, and that Zig cannot, due to not being memory safe.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by rc00 on Saturday March 22, 2025 @08:30PM (#43449852)
It sounds like you haven't seen projects like this yet:

https://github.com/ityonemo/clr

They're popping up all over. For some reason, Zig folk want Rust things and Rust folk want Zig things.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pcwalton on Saturday March 22, 2025 @11:58PM (#43450807)
I have seen projects like that, and they're a prime example of what I mean when I want to see arguments in favor of Zig that rely on what Zig can do now, and not what it could potentially do in the future. Ten years ago, C++ folks were also promising memory safety with the ISO C++ Core Guidelines; you don't hear much about that anymore, because it turns out it can't be done while keeping the resulting language C++ (for example, seanbax's work for C++, which is far more advanced than this project, is really awesome, but is essentially a different language).
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by rc00 on Sunday March 23, 2025 @12:11AM (#43450857)
And what about all the promises of things making it out of Rust Nightly?

When it comes to Zig, one crowd says it's too early because it's not 1.0 fast enough. And now, are you saying that the feature development is basically done? What point are you trying to make?

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pcwalton on Sunday March 23, 2025 @12:18PM (#43453899)
The point I'm making is that I don't believe Zig can be made meaningfully memory safe without breaking compatibility to the extent that memory-safe Zig would effectively be a different language, any more than C can.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pron on Sunday March 23, 2025 @08:21PM (#43456912)
I tend to agree, but writing code in a memory-safe language is not the goal. The relevant goal on that particular front (and it is not the only goal people have when writing programs) is to maximise the resulting program's correctness within some effort budget and other requirements (such as memory consumption etc.). Using a memory-safe language is one approach toward achieving that goal, but if that safety comes at a cost of added effort, then showing that's the best approach depends on claims that are hard to verify without a lot more empirical data. The only theoretical justification could be that more soundness results in more practical correctness, but if that were the case then there are languages that offer more soundness than Rust. In other words, if Rust is generally superior to Zig because it offers more soundness, then other languages are superior still. Indeed, soundness is not considered the best approach to attaining every property in general because it can be more expensive than other approaches that achieve the desired outcome, and Rust clearly recognises that.

Rather, both languages' correctness-related claims rely on them being in some better or worse effort/correctness sweet spot, and that can only be measured empirically for those two specific languages. Crucially, results comparing Rust to C or C++ are not relevant. Zig offers more soundness than C, and even if it offers the same soundness as C++ (and I disagree -- I think it offers more) the language's claim is that its simplicity assists correctness. We can only tell to what extent that is true with more empirical observation; I don't think there can be any good guess made here regarding the size of the effect.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by kobebrookskC3 on Monday March 24, 2025 @09:45AM (#43461003)
some correctness matters more than others. for a web browser, i would rather use a browser that is buggy/janky/crashy but doesn't give random websites arbitrary native code execution over a browser that is logically correct except for giving random websites rce. the languages that are more sound than rust are probably worse among some axis like ease of use, expressivity or performance. even if they weren't, they're probably not going to buy me much more than a slightly less buggy/janky/crashy browser, once you no longer have exploitable memory safety bugs.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pron on Monday March 24, 2025 @11:11AM (#43461990)
Sure, but once soundness starts trading off other properties that may be important even for that kind of correctness, it is not necessarily the best approach. You don't care what the cause of the exploitable remote execution vulnerability is, and remote code execution is a real vulnerability even in fully memory-safe languages.

If you look at MITRE's CWE Top 25 [1], #2 (Out-of-bounds Write) and #6 (Out-of-bounds Read) are soundly eliminated by both Zig and Rust. It is only when it comes to #8 (Use After Free) that Rust's additional soundness comes into play. But because it comes at a cost, the question is to what extent eliminating #8 adversely impacts the other top vulnerabilities, including those higher on the list. It may be the case that eliminating the eighth most dangerous vulnerability through sound language guarantees may end up being worse overall even if we're only concerned with security (and it isn't the only concern). We can only try to assess that through empirical study.

[1]: https://cwe.mitre.org/top25/archive/2024/2024_cwe_top25.html

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by throwawaymaths on Sunday March 23, 2025 @10:25PM (#43457408)
if you looked at the clr project you would find a credible claim that it doesn't have to be an "effectively different language", that there is a real possibility that "minor annotations are sufficient".

> I don't believe

Of course, we're debating against a belief, and you have plenty of reasons to not believe it that it will be impossible to be swayed by any sort of evidence, and you will always find a way move the goalposts.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by baranul on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @09:21PM (#43489472)
If people are referring to what Zig or any other language could possibly do, as something valid to be taken under consideration, then it should at least be explicitly stated in their roadmap.

Otherwise, it can be construed as just another wish list or feature request, that main developers have no plans to implement.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pcwalton on Saturday March 22, 2025 @12:41PM (#43446951)
How do you typecheck generics, with type inference, with comptime?

Or, more generally, address all the issues raised in [1]. You're saying that comptime can fully replicate all the features that a proper generics system has, which is plainly false.

[1]: https://typesanitizer.com/blog/zig-generics.html

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pron on Saturday March 22, 2025 @02:44PM (#43447688)
I would say these are more differences than issues, and that some of those presented as more fundamental ones are actually quite small. Suppose that instead of `fn foo (comptime T : type, ...) { typecheck(T); ...}` Zig introduced just a tiny bit of new syntax to allow you to write something like `fn foo (comptime T : typecheck(T), ...) { ... }` -- i.e. the type constraints would be part of the signature -- would you then say it had generics rather than templates? Personally, I have not made up my mind on whether or not such an addition would be very valuable, but even if it is, it can be done later. That small addition would address most "issues" in the article, which I would say are more about IDE support than anything else. But even without it, what you want to know is known at compile time, and the article admits that the compilation errors are already better than those you get with C++ templates (I would say much better).

Now, I'm not saying that Zig's choices always dominate and that all languages would be better off with its approach; far from it. I am saying that it introduces a novel tradeoff that is especially compelling in cases where not only generics but also macros, conditional compilation, and constexprs are otherwise required. In a language like Java these extra features are not required, and so Zig-style comptime would not simplify the language nearly as much.

But even in cases where all these features are needed, I don't think everyone would take Zig's choices over C++'s or Rust's, or vice-versa. To those, like me, for whom language complexity is the biggest problem with C++ or Ada (I used Ada in the nineties), Zig is a revolutionary step forward. I don't think any low-level language has ever been this simple while also being this expressive.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pcwalton on Saturday March 22, 2025 @08:10PM (#43449757)
It's interesting that so many replies in this thread (and indeed, most Zig threads) are along the lines of "yes, it doesn't do X today, but Zig could just add X". I'd really like to see arguments in favor of Zig that rely on what it can do today, rather than what it might do someday. After all, you don't extend Rust the same courtesy, and Zig is not that young of a language. And in PL circles Zig has a bit of a reputation for promising things that it has yet to deliver (e.g. static detection of potential stack overflows, which I'm convinced just can't be done in a useful way in the presence of higher order functions).
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pron on Saturday March 22, 2025 @11:01PM (#43450590)
> It's interesting that so many replies in this thread (and indeed, most Zig threads) are along the lines of "yes, it doesn't do X today, but Zig could just add X".

That wasn't my argument.

> After all, you don't extend Rust the same courtesy

Given that my aesthetic issue with Rust is that it has too many complicated features, I don't see how that courtesy could be extended. There is, indeed, an asymmetry between adding features and removing them, but the aesthetic "points" I'm awarding Zig is not due to features it could add but due to features it hasn't while they've not yet been shown to be critical.

I think it's fairly obvious that any feature in any language was added to add some positive value. But every feature also has a negative value, as it makes the language more complicated, which in aggregate may mean fewer programs would be written in it. The challenge is balancing the value of features with their complexity. Even those who prefer Rust's aesthetics to Zig would admit that Zig's novel approach to power/simplicity balance is something we have not seen in programming language design in many years.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pcwalton on Saturday March 22, 2025 @11:51PM (#43450784)
> The challenge is balancing the value of features with their complexity. Even those who prefer Rust's aesthetics to Zig would admit that Zig's novel approach to power/simplicity balance is something we have not seen in programming language design in many years.

I disagree. Minimalism in systems language design has been done over and over: see Go for the most recent example. Comptime is something that C++ was already doing in the form of constexpr since 2011 and a space that D had explored for over a decade before Zig came around in the form of "static if" and so forth (in addition to lots of academic work, of course). Stripping out template metaprogramming in favor of leaning heavily on compile-time function evaluation isn't novel either. I think you find the set of features that Zig has to be personally appealing, which is fine. But the argument that it's anything novel is weak, except in the trivial sense that every language is novel because it includes some features and leaves others out (but if every language is novel, then the word "novel" has no meaning).

From my vantage point, Zig is essentially a skin on a subset of C++, one that is in practice less safe than C++ because of the relative immaturity of tooling.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pron on Sunday March 23, 2025 @09:46AM (#43452903)
I've been doing low-level programming for over 30 years now, and Zig's use of comptime as a simplifying feature is nothing at all like C++'s or D's (it is more conceptually similar to the role macros play in Lisps). Denying how revolutionary it is for low-level programming seems strange to me. You don't have to like the end result, but clearly Zig offers a novel way to do low-level programming. I was excited and thoroughly impressed by Rust's application of substructural typing despite being familiar with the idea long before Rust came out, even though the overall language doesn't quite suit my taste.

Minimalism is also, of course, not a new idea, but unlike in Go, I wouldn't say minimalism is Zig's point. Expressive low-level languages have always been much more complex than similarly expressive high-level ones, something that many of us have seen as their primary problem, and Zig is the first one that isn't. In other words, the point isn't minimalism as a design aesthetic (I would say that explicitness is a design aesthetic of Zig's much more than minimalism) but rather reducing the complexity that some have seen as the biggest issue with expressive low-level languages.

What was so impressive to me is that we've always known how macros can add almost infinite expressivity to languages that could be considered minimalistic, but they carry their own set of severe complexity issues. Zig showed how comptime can be used to offer much of the power of macros with almost none of their cost. That, too, is revolutionary even without considering the low-level domain specifically (although high-level languages have other options).

Finally, if you want to talk about "safety in practice", considering more than just the language, I don't think we can know without empirical study, but the same claim could be made about Rust. Both Zig the language and Rust the language are safer than either C or C++ (the languages), and Rust the language is safer than Zig the language. But as to their relative safety (or correctness) "in practice" either now or in the future, only time and empirical study will tell. Clearly, languages that offer more soundness, like Idris or ATS, don't always work so well in practice. So I admit I don't know at this time whether Zig (the gestalt) offers more or less correctness in practice than C++ or which of Zig or Rust offers more correctness in practice, but neither do you.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by gw2 on Sunday March 23, 2025 @11:59PM (#43457704)
> Zig is essentially a skin on a subset of C++, one that is in practice less safe than C++

Give it a rest please. Given your association with Rust, endlessly attacking competing languages is not a good look, regardless of whether your points are technically correct or not.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by hollerith on Monday March 24, 2025 @12:11AM (#43457731)
Looks fine to me.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pjmlp on Sunday March 23, 2025 @02:30PM (#43454774)
So Mesa, Cedar, Modula-2, Object Pascal, Oberon,... don't count?
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pron on Sunday March 23, 2025 @08:02PM (#43456833)
Of course they count, but they never reached Zig's expressivity/simplicity ratio. For example, Oberon doesn't have generics. You could argue that Zig doesn't have dynamic dispatch as part of the language, but it's expressive enough for that to be done in a library (https://github.com/alexnask/interface.zig). Put simply, Zig can do pretty much anything C++ can with the same expressivity (by programming languages X and Y having the same expressivity I mean that there is some small constant C such that any program in X could be written in Y in a number of lines that is within a factor of C compared to X).
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pjmlp on Monday March 24, 2025 @03:35AM (#43458427)
Modula-2 and Oberon Pascal evolved to have generics, if that is the "expressiveness problem".

Also all the ones I mentioned, supported binary libraries, which apparently is not something the Zig folks are too keen in supporting, other than C like ABI.

For me any systems language that doesn't support binary library distribution isn't that relevant to me, and yes that is also something that I regularly complain about in Rust, and not only me. Microsoft has a talk on their Rust's adoption where this is mentioned as a problem, only relieved thanks to ubiquity of COM as mechanism to delivery binary libraries on Windows.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by pron on Monday March 24, 2025 @10:56AM (#43461829)
I agree that good separate compilation is valuable, but having a full ABI for natively-aot-compiled languages is rather difficult once generics are involved. Even C++ doesn't have one (and if you think about it, even C punts on separate compilation once macros are involved). I think the only such language that offers one -- and not quite to the full extent -- is Swift.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by baranul on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @01:23AM (#43479113)
Another aspect of this argument, is that Zig is supposedly not about adding many features, in order to live up to its claim of being a small and simple language, with an emphasis on systems programming. Where on the other hand, Rust's pitch is not promising small and simple.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by creata on Saturday March 22, 2025 @10:02PM (#43450365)
> would you then say it had generics rather than templates?

I think pcwalton's "generics" vs. "templates" distinction mostly boils down to parametric typechecking, which Zig's design just can't do. (Can it?)

Although, I vaguely remember some example showing that even Rust in some cases allows a type definition X<T> even when there exists a T such that X<T> would fail to typecheck.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by throwawaymaths on Saturday March 22, 2025 @02:11PM (#43447500)
1. if you wish, you absolutely can check for "extra constraints" on a passed type (or even an anytype parameter) using comptime reflection and the @comptimeError builtin.

2. if you want to restrict the use of a function to comptime (why you would want to is beyond me) it is possible to do with @inComptime builtin.

the only tricky bit is that your function could try to call a function inaccessible to you because it's transitively restricted and you'd have a hard time noticing that from the code but it's not possible for that code to be compiled (barring errors by the zig team) so its more of an annoyance than a problem.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by creata on Saturday March 22, 2025 @01:53PM (#43447407)
I don't think pron was saying that Zig has a feature-by-feature match for everything that Rust's generics can do. I think his point is that comptime can handle what the target audience of Zig wants from generics. In that regard, I don't think the criticisms there are that big a deal.
Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by SkiFire13 on Saturday March 22, 2025 @12:54PM (#43447037)
Comptime can only properly express half of them:

- generics: comptime can implement some kind of polymorphism, but not at the type level. In other words it implements a templating system, not a polymorphic type system;

- interfaces/traits/concepts: comptime implements none of that, it is plain duck typing, just like "old" C++ templates. In fact C++ introduced concepts to improve its situation with templates, while Zig is still behind on that front!

- macros: comptime solves some of the usecases where macros are used, but it cannot produce arbitrary tokens and hence cannot fully replace macros.

I do agree that it can neatly replace conditional compilation and const functions/const expr, but let's not make it seem like comptime solves everything in the world.

Re:Crabtime: Zig's Comptime in Rust by throwawaymaths on Saturday March 22, 2025 @02:14PM (#43447515)
in practice aside from interfaces the only thing you can't do at comptime is to generically attach declarations (member functions, consts) to a container type (the best you can do is to do it on a case by case basis).

you could probably cobble together an interface system with @comptimeError, but because of the time order of compilation stages, a failed method call will trigger the compiler error before your custom interface code, making it effectively useless for the 90% of cases you care about.

if I'm not mistaken in principle a small change to the compiler could amend this situation