News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by ajsnigrutin on Friday March 21, 2025 @11:55AM (#43437165)
But if it doesn't work on a state level, why would it work on a national level or a global level?
Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by arrosenberg on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:17PM (#43437484)
Internally the US has free movement of both labor and capital, so any single state trying broad social programs without federal support will run into free rider and arbitrage problems pretty quickly. Since the US can control its border and currency, it’s less likely to be a problem if it’s a national program.
Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by moduspol on Friday March 21, 2025 @01:13PM (#43438338)
That's true, although there's a pretty strong overlap of UBI proponents and supporters of pro-immigration policies.

If you want to say, "Of course UBI can't work if we allow whoever wants it to move here and receive it," I agree, but that's often not a qualifier made by proponents.

Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by _DeadFred_ on Friday March 21, 2025 @03:07PM (#43439764)
Libertarians (the biggest pure open borders as their actual platform people) are pro UBI now?
Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:32PM (#43437721)
> any single state trying broad social programs without federal support will run into free rider and arbitrage problems pretty quickly

Internationally, capital and labour are also mobile. If the argument for UBI is basically North Korea, I’m not seeing it.

Put simply, if a UBI scheme doesn’t work at the state level, it won’t federally in the long run.

Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by dmoy on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:53PM (#43438043)
> Isn’t the argument UBI will promote growth?

Some types of growth, yea that's the theory. But I don't think there's any theory of UBI with freedom of movement between borders where UBI isn't present. If every single person who doesn't want to work shows up to your state, you won't be able to keep UBI running.

> Internationally, capital and labour are also mobile.

Capital yes. Labor ... not really? Even historically immigrating to the US is kinda difficult. Immigrating into any developed country is hard.

> If the argument for UBI is basically North Korea, I’m not seeing it.

No it's not even NK. It's socialism but no central planning. NK (and really any prior long running example of socialism in US history) doesn't do free market do decide e.g. who picks up the trash.

So it could well be that UBI works, but a lot of grunge jobs just don't get done. Maybe people are happier and have more free time, but there's fewer janitors so things are dirtier, and a much higher percentage of money goes towards paying people to farm so good is way more expensive.

Things definitely wouldn't be the same as they are now, even if it did hypothetically work.

> Put simply, if a UBI scheme doesn’t work at the state level, it won’t federally in the long run.

There could easily be things that break it at the state level (especially, freedom of movement of people), that don't apply federally.

It might also fail at a federal level, but you can't claim there aren't major differences between a single state UBI and a federal UBI

Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:55PM (#43438081)
> don't think there's any theory of UBI with freedom of movement between borders where UBI isn't present

Then you need to define categories of good and bad people. And explain why the former will stay (or continue to immigrate). In the long run, borders are porous. If it doesn’t work at the state level, and it doesn’t cause inflation, I’m deeply sceptical about the claim that it doesn’t require categorising by productivity.

Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by dmoy on Saturday March 22, 2025 @03:58AM (#43444274)
It's definitely more porous going out. So yeah, UBI needs to be not so bad that people can do better elsewhere that's easy enough to immigrate into. The same is true of basically any policy though, that's not really a unique thing to UBI.
Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by echoangle on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:05PM (#43437298)
> States don’t have monetary policy and are limited to taking debt in fiscal policy.

Because this doesn't apply to countries, only states.

Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by windward on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:07PM (#43437323)
Don't let the Eurozone hear that
Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by arrosenberg on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:14PM (#43437432)
Those programs were all established prior to the EuroZone. A single European country would find it much harder to do today for the reasons stated.
Re:The Road Not Taken Is Guaranteed Minimum Income by dmoy on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:27PM (#43437643)
The fed does have the ability to control monetary policy.

This is akin to why some problems in the EU - individual countries gave up monetary policy rights, which means they have to do what Germany wants w.r.t. the euro. They can't control interest rates like the US Fed can, can't expand or contract money supply, and have fewer tools to deal with problems that arise.

Imagine if NYC couldn't build buildings over 1 story because of a state law. That would complicate adding new residents. It might work for awhile and they could get creative, but eventually it would become untenable.

---

This is not all to say that there aren't any problems with UBI specifically. We haven't really tested that level of socialism anywhere with still trying to also do free market and no planned economy.

It could well be that a lot of stuff wouldn't get done, or at least not done as much. There's a lot of shit jobs that are done for cheaper now because people gotta eat & put a roof over their head.

Unless you do a U"B"I solution which isn't actually covering the basics, but is lower than necessary.