You can't land on Mars with just a parachute anyway, not with a 900 kg payload. The main problem with Mars is that its atmosphere is just dense enough that it complicates things but not dense enough that it's really helpful.
Regarding parachutes, is it not the case that if you need more performance, that you simply increase their size?
[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=S...
The effectiveness of a parachute grows at a square of your airspeed. This means that every planet has a minimum speed you can successfully slow down to using parachutes with a given system. For realistic loads and conventional materials, on Mars that is about 50m/s. Which is just too fast.
It's one thing to say it, it's another to design it such it has a chance of working. Telescoping mechanisms with deployable aerodynamic structures sounds very complicated to me, compared to the thrusters they're using.
> You could possibly then put a tractor rocket at the end of this shaft to slow descent and keep the rocket plumes away from the main body and the ground.
The sky crane already does this.
> Regarding parachutes, is it not the case that if you need more performance, that you simply increase their size?
'Performance' is lots of things, presumably you mean drag. Increasing the diameter does increase the drag, but it also increases the opening forces, which requires a stronger structure, which means more mass. You don't have the luxury of much margin when every gram in your landing system has cost the us taxpayer thousands of dollars and is a gram that you can't use for science.
Perhaps the most similar landing was by Viking, which made the final descent on rockets. Those thrusters were expressly designed (that is, compromised) to produce as little disturbance of the landing site as possible. The only thing Curiosity is doing that is really new is the sky crane. If there are any errors in understanding the dynamics of rocket plus lengthening pendulum in Mars gravity, then all is lost. I think it is likely that some extra attention has been paid to this part of the mission.
http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/events/lectures_archive.cfm?year=200...
> I haven't heard the reason's why some of the more conventional mechanisms weren't used.
What's a conventional mechanism when you're landing on another planet?
They do exactly that. But Mars' atmosphere is so thin that terminal velocity of the capsule is still supersonic.
> I can imagine a system where the capsule pitches up near the end of its run so that it starts gaining altitude and then deploys a parachute for landing once it has reached its apogee.
Parachutes don't help enough in 0.007atm. Even with the biggest chutes possible (remember: they're heavy!), you'd still be hurtling towards the ground like a missile.
> Another thing is the crane mechanism, which is to protect the rover from the debris kicked up from the rocket motors. I was wondering why the rover couldn't just be encased in a simple lightweight protective box and then placed directly on the deck?
Weight. Believe it or not, the sky crane delivers more payload to the surface.
> I appreciate that their system probably is the best design as they are a smart bunch, however I haven't heard the reason's why some of the more conventional mechanisms weren't used. > > Does anyone have any links to the other designs that were considered and rejected?
http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/2009000...
Also, that kind of blunt body is stable hypersonically, but unstable supersonically. As soon as you get to a mach number where a parachute can deploy stably (about mach 1.8 and below) you deploy it to stabilise the thing, and of course the drag is much greater than entry body alone.
>> Another thing is the crane mechanism, which is to protect the rover from the debris kicked up from the rocket motors. I was wondering why the rover couldn't just be encased in a simple lightweight protective box and then placed directly on the deck?
The point of the sky crane is not just to avoid kicking up dust, this notion seems to have become the received wisdom in the media though. The reasons include:
-Having rovers drive off from on top of things is difficult, it puts the CoG of the lander right up and if you have to drive off a sloped ramp having landed on a slope, the ramp can be really very sloped.
-Rocket forces nearer the ground can be quite an interesting control problem, in terms of the forces generated when you're near the ground and where all the exhaust goes.
-Having rocket fuel tanks landing on spikey rocks has the potential to really ruin your day.
-Knowing when to turn the rocket engines off (i.e. successfully detecting landing) is actually quite a hard problem. It's a very noisy problem, and getting it wrong was what destroyed Mars Polar Lander (i.e. it thought it landed when it was still up in the air, and so fell out of the sky). The skycrane has the rocket motors on the whole time and goes off an crashes.
Lots of this is explained in the video I linked to somewhere else in this family of comments.
The martian atmosphere is really thin (I've heard it said that it would pass for vacuum in a high school science classroom). They've got that giant parachute doing as much deceleration-through-atmospheric-drag as possible, and it's still not enough. (And as a sibling post said, fancy atmospheric manoeuvring would require huge wings)
>Another thing is the crane mechanism, which is to protect the rover from the debris kicked up from the rocket motors. I was wondering why the rover couldn't just be encased in a simple lightweight protective box and then placed directly on the deck?
A box with rocket motors on? That'd still churn up the ground that the rover then has to drive through to go anywhere.
Or do you mean dropping it without the cable? The current rovers (MER) were deployed that way, with airbags, but this one's too big to do that with.
I can imagine a system where the capsule pitches up near the end of its run so that it starts gaining altitude and then deploys a parachute for landing once it has reached its apogee.
I appreciate that their system probably is the best design as they are a smart bunch, however I haven't heard the reason's why some of the more conventional mechanisms weren't used.
Another thing is the crane mechanism, which is to protect the rover from the debris kicked up from the rocket motors. I was wondering why the rover couldn't just be encased in a simple lightweight protective box and then placed directly on the deck?
Does anyone have any links to the other designs that were considered and rejected?