Yeah I was thinking of landing it without the cables, inside a protective box and then opening the box once all the dust and debris has settled or blown away. You wouldn't need any airbags as the current system is able to achieve a descent of only 1.5mph, meaning it could be placed gently on the surface.
Right, but even after the dust has blown away your rocket downdraft has basically dug a pit that your rover is now at the bottom of.
Re:Mars rover Curiosity lands today
by HeyLaughingBoy on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:08PM
(#4341780)
You also need to consider that the landing may be successful but the vehicle's drive system may be rendered inoperable for any number of reasons. In that case, you'd want the surrounding ground to be as undisturbed/uncontaminated as possible so you could still do some science in that location without being able to move around.
Re:Mars rover Curiosity lands today
by waterlesscloud on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:51PM
(#4341896)
There would be some value, possibly even more value in studying the Marian subsurface a bit...
Re:Mars rover Curiosity lands today
by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday August 06, 2012 @02:55PM
(#4346615)
Refer to what I said about the thrusters contaminating the soil. There are better ways of looking underground if that's your intent.
The martian atmosphere is really thin (I've heard it said that it would pass for vacuum in a high school science classroom). They've got that giant parachute doing as much deceleration-through-atmospheric-drag as possible, and it's still not enough. (And as a sibling post said, fancy atmospheric manoeuvring would require huge wings)
>Another thing is the crane mechanism, which is to protect the rover from the debris kicked up from the rocket motors. I was wondering why the rover couldn't just be encased in a simple lightweight protective box and then placed directly on the deck?
A box with rocket motors on? That'd still churn up the ground that the rover then has to drive through to go anywhere.
Or do you mean dropping it without the cable? The current rovers (MER) were deployed that way, with airbags, but this one's too big to do that with.