News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by wtmt on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:01PM (#43384792)
In such cases in the U.S., where judicial orders are not heeded, what are the consequences for the executive (and the agencies it controls) and what are the remedies practically available (something that can be put into action) for the judiciary for contempt of court?

To what extent can the executive get away with disobeying judicial orders (without filing appeals)?

Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by mullingitover on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:23PM (#43384885)
If the executive branch is ignoring court orders, the constitution is de facto suspended. It’s in the ‘constitutional crisis’ phase when they’re threatening to ignore the courts. When they’re actually doing it, there is no longer a working constitution.

The remedies are to pray that the US Marshals don’t break their oath to the constitution and are willing to arrest their bosses for contempt of court when the courts order it.

Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by from-nibly on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:59PM (#43385065)
The problem is you can't just arrest your bosses. That would be a military coup.
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by mullingitover on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:09AM (#43385126)
If the leaders of the DOJ commit federal crimes do they just get a pass? Of course not. The marshals must do their jobs and arrest people the courts lawfully order them to, regardless of their title. That’s not a coup, that’s the constitution working normally.

The coup already happened when the executive usurped the judicial branch’s authority.

Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by TheNewsIsHere on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:18AM (#43389485)
Something I’ve noticed is that a surprising (to me) number of people I generally think of as “smart” say things like that.

“You can’t arrest your boss” or “if the President is in charge of the executive, why can’t he decide these things?”

And it continues to surprise me. I take these queries in good faith with respect to the people in my life that I know who respond in this way.

But it leaves me wondering how others think the world works. Do people want to live in a world where one branch has unchecked power and may disregard with impunity the checks and balances in our government?

Why shouldn’t and why can’t a rogue President be contained by lawful means? Why shouldn’t the Marshal’s be able to arrest someone at the direction of the court? That’s how it works for everyone else.

It’s by no means an unsettled question as to whether Presidents are accountable to the law and Constitution. They are. Full stop.

Is it just that having a President that actively ignores and breaks laws in plain sight is just so new? How long do we wait for the novelty to wear off?

Of course the functioning of all of this is predicated upon good faith and the absence of an almost complete takeover of the system by bootlickers.

Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by Volundr on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:38PM (#43390327)
> I take these queries in good faith

Especially if these are people in your own life instead of randoms on the Internet, it's probably worth revisiting this. A great many people I know in my life saying things like this were spinning a very different yarn when it was Obama, the ACA or his executive orders. Or Biden doing... Well anything. In other words it's not good faith. It's a post-facto rationalization to justify whatever Trump is doing.

It's of course harder to do this exercise for a random stranger on the Internet. It's always possible this person was arguing the same for other Presidents. But I'd bet dollars to donuts few were.

Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by seanp2k2 on Monday March 17, 2025 @04:35PM (#43392481)
Guess who the boss of the US Marshals is? Former Trump attorney and 2020 election denier Pam Bondi. Good luck with that.
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by kccoder on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:50PM (#43401630)
Disagree. The executive disregarding the constitution (judicial oversight) is a coup. Arresting the offenders is bringing the government back into constitutional order. Seems the opposite of a coup to me.
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by apical_dendrite on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:20PM (#43384873)
The US Marshalls are part of the Department of Justice, so in a criminal contempt case, the DOJ would be effectively arresting itself. Also, the President can pardon anyone of any federal crime for any reason without any possibility of judicial review. So criminal remedies seem ineffective.

As for fines - it looks like they're capped at $1000, and depending on the circumstances, the government might just be paying that fine to itself. So that doesn't seem effective either. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/402

Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by unsnap_biceps on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:14PM (#43384850)
Congress is intended to be able to enforce via impeachment, but if congress declines to impeach, there's really no consequences for the executive branch.
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by electric_mayhem on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:19PM (#43384865)
Can we recall the elected officials who are shirking their duty to impeach an executive who is behaving unlawfully?
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by xnx on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:31PM (#43384931)
The 2A crowd has thoughts about this
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by bediger4000 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:40PM (#43384982)
Yeah, thoughts and prayers. I'll believe the 2A crowd if they ever do something.
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by yongjik on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:34AM (#43385243)
You have more faith in them than I do. I wouldn't be surprised if the 2A crowd rise up, in a year or two, to defend America's Lord and Savior Trump from leftist thugs.
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by int_19h on Monday March 17, 2025 @02:08AM (#43385594)
The only officials who matter here are congressmen, and there's no provision in the US Constitution that would allow for a recall. The only legal mechanism for removal is expulsion, which must be voted on by the rest of Congress, so...
Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by jfengel on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:47AM (#43388572)
No, we can't. It's unconstitutional.

Besides... even where recalls are allowed, it's only by their own district. The Congressmen were just elected, and their constituents generally approve of this. A recall effort would certainly fail.

In theory they could be expelled by Congress itself. But obviously that's not going to happen.

Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by molticrystal on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:02AM (#43385088)
When a President ignores judicial orders, the consequences for the executive and its agencies depend on Congressional checks. The Constitution allows Congress to push back through legislation or impeachment, the latter being the big stick if a President flouts courts too openly. Agencies under executive control might face court-ordered penalties or injunctions, but if the President digs in, Congress can respond, perhaps by cutting funds or passing laws to enforce compliance. In reality, though, Congressional action crawls, and partisan gridlock (think loyalists to an ideology) often stalls it. The judiciary’s remedies are shaky: courts can issue contempt rulings, criminal ones with jail time or civil ones with fines, but enforcement needs executive cooperation, which a rogue President can block. Deference to courts is largely a convention, a very strong convention especially since the 1803 Madison judicial review case, but not a strict explicit in the constitution requirement for the executive. There is nothing to compel the President to obey judicial orders. History shows this tension (Jackson’s supposed “John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it”) and the judiciary’s practical limits against a stubborn executive.

That vulnerability grows with the President’s pardon power under Article II, Section 2, which says they “shall have Power to grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offenses against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment.” This lets them wipe out federal convictions, potentially shielding themselves or cronies from criminal contempt for defying courts (imagine pardoning loyalists who break laws for the President). It doesn’t touch civil rulings like injunctions, but it’s a gaping loophole for abuse. Deference to courts is just a norm, not a rule; the Constitution doesn’t demand compliance. Most Presidents go along because courts interpret laws and Congressional intent, but a reckless one could spit in the face of that interpretation of the intent of Congress and test the limits, daring Congress to respond.

Congress could, in theory, support that defiance with a simple majority to pass laws. The House needs just 218 of 435, and the Senate could too if it dumped the filibuster, a 60-vote hurdle for most bills now. The Constitution lets each chamber set its own rules, so a partisan majority could greenlight executive overreach. They don’t, not because they can’t, but because both sides dread the backlash when power swaps (Democrats wouldn’t want Republicans rewriting rules unchecked either). This self-restraint, not just constitutional design, stops the system from crumbling under a President who’d rather torch norms than respect them.

Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by zonian on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:17PM (#43384861)
FDR threatened to pack the court with judges sympathetic to his policies. The Supreme Court Court backed down and ruled, in essence, the New Deal legal. In theory a court can issue arrest warrants but that isn’t going to happen with Trump. SCOTUS has already ruled that Presidents are largely immune to arrest and the President can pardon whomever he wants. Thus, effectively there is no legal mechanism for enforcement.

Much of the American system relies on established political norms for governance. Pretty much all of these norms are being gutted. No one knows what the long term impact will be but I believe the republic as we knew it is dead.

Re:Brown University Professor Is Deported Despite a Judge's ... by defrost on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:46PM (#43385009)
Five days ago US Republicans "stopped time" with respect to a clock running that required a response to an appeal against Trump's tariffs.

~ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43358343

  Each day for the remainder of the first session of the 119th Congress shall not constitute a calendar day for purposes of section 202 of the National Emergencies Act (50 U.S.C. 1622) with respect to a joint resolution terminating a national emergency declared by the President on February 1, 2025.
~ https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-resolutio...

"Each day [..] shall not constitute a calendar day"