News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amateur Telescope Making Main Page by throw73849488 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @08:54AM (#43352810)
A bit messy is understatement. And finishing such project without a good guidance is almost impossible. At final stage a few bad moves can destroy week of work! It is setting up newcomers for failure and burnout.

We made our own mirrors, because there was no other option a few decades ago.

But today mirrors are cheap, and they come with aluminum coating and rest of the telescope!

Re:Amateur Telescope Making Main Page by chantepierre on Thursday March 13, 2025 @09:15AM (#43352989)
It's not about price, but enjoying the process, or making instruments that just are not commercially available. Amateurs are constantly pushing the limits of optical designs.

Here is a recent groundbreaking example from Rik Ter Horst, a 10" f/20 kutter with toroidal secondary : https://www.cloudynights.com/topic/935825-a-250-mm-f20-kutte...

I did not do anything that impressive but enjoy my own set of non-standard scopes :

- A 8" f/3.5 hyperbolic primary + ross corrector

- a 6" f/2.8 with permanently mounted 4-element corrector

and am working on a 16.5" f/3.3 that will have a permanent Paracorr II lens group.

The only messy moment was my first mirror when I learned to cut pitch, but grit and glass dust itself are no problem thanks to the wet process.

You are right though on the last bits of figuring, it's a psychological challenge and my first mirror took 3 attempts over 18 months.

Re:Amateur Telescope Making Main Page by Tepix on Thursday March 13, 2025 @09:15AM (#43352984)
I'm not in the loop, are 14 inch or larger mirrors affordable nowadays?
Re:Amateur Telescope Making Main Page by dylan604 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @09:50AM (#43353342)
Just because this was your experience does not mean others should not try, and frankly, your posts suggesting others not try is disgusting. You're on a forum for people with a hacking ethos. That's pretty much the "hold my beer" mindset with a facade of classiness in front of it.

Also, rather than saying such negative things like "don't do it", you could have wrapped up your negative experience into a parable for people to learn from before embarking upon their own journey. Just because you didn't prepare for the results of grinding something to a fine dust/powder doesn't mean others won't prepare for that. Especially after what could have been a much more positive outcome from your negative experience. Don't be a downer.

This would be haha funny if you were trying to stoke that "don't tell me no" as reverse psychology.