News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by m348e912 on Monday March 10, 2025 @05:57PM (#43326562)
In 1847, one of the bleakest years of the Irish famine, Khaleefah Abdul-Majid I, Sultan of an Ottoman Empire offered £10,000 (which was quite a sum at the time) to help alleviate the suffering of the Irish people.

Queen Victoria, upon learning of this, requested that he reduce his donation to a more modest £1,000, so as not to embarrass her own relatively meagre offering of £2,000. Reluctantly, the Sultan agreed, but bolstered his contribution by secretly sending five ships loaded with food.

https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Britain-refuse-Ottomans-aid-to...

My conclusion is that the famine was as much political as it was environmental. (as they often are)

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:49PM (#43327029)
I agree with your conclusion, but this story is very badly sourced and really should not be used [0]. We only have two sources from the 1800s that claim it: one is contemporary but provides no attribution and we have no reason to believe they had firsthand knowledge. The other is 40 years later and is attributed to a conversation with the son of the sultan's personal physician. Yeah.

With such bad evidence for such an incendiary claim, I think we're better off sticking with the enormous amount of other evidence that policy caused the famine and letting this particular story die.

(What is true and backed up by evidence is that the sultan sent £1k. The rest has no reliable source.)

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ireland%E2%80%93Turkey_relat...

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by smcin on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:09PM (#43328443)
The Ottoman Sultan's donation (or the US$170/£111 famously donated by a group of Native American Choctaw Nation, which is verified historical fact [0][1][2], or the £14,000 donated by Calcutta in 1846 [0], which is > Queen Victoria's subsequent 1848 donation) have nothing to do with arguing that British policy caused the famine.

They're (verified) anecdotes showing the British Crown was embarrassed that their own charitable donations to a famine that killed 1 in 8 Irish people, were not that much and could be rivaled or outdonated (Calcutta) by private groups, even groups like the Choctaw who had just survived the Trail of Tears forced displacement/genocide 16 years before. (This is commemorated today by sculptures in Midleton, County Cork, Ireland "Kindred Spirits" and a companion sculpture in Tuskahoma, OK "Choctaw Ireland Monument"). By implication the Crown wasn't at all exercised about changing the setup in Ireland where most of the population were tenant farmers on the 90% of the land was foreign-owned. The landlords made a lot of money on exporting grain (esp. during the Napoleonic Wars until the price crashed). The tenants had essentially zero political representation in Westminster.

Nearly two centuries later, Ireland's population (all-island, Republic + NI) has still not recovered to the pre-Famine peak (1841, 8.175m est.) [3]. Predicted to finally happen sometime in the 2050s.

Curious if anyone has documented the massive imbalance in ownership in land in pre-Famine Ireland and compared it to other historical situations (Russia, colonial Americas, Africa, India, 1930s Ukraine) and their eventual outcomes.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland)#Charity

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Choctaw_Nation_of_Oklahoma#For...

[2]: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-40304645

[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_population_of_Irela...

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:29PM (#43328561)
> They're (verified) anecdotes showing the British Crown was embarrassed

Again, to be clear, this anecdote is not verified. It is extremely poorly sourced, not much more than an urban legend. The only attribution for the story dating to the 19th century is a claim that someone heard it from the sultan's physician's son, and that claim is put forward more than 40 years after the events.

The existence of donations, verified or otherwise, does not independently show that the British government attempted to prevent aid from reaching Ireland because they were embarrassed about how little they had contributed. That is the claim that OP puts forward with their story, that is the claim that I'm responding to. I'm not questioning that others did send donations or that some of those donations exceeded those put forward by the British government.

All of that is true, but it being true does not justify perpetuating unsubstantiated stories that happen to support the same conclusion. As you have amply demonstrated, there's enough good evidence in favor of the conclusion that we don't need to rely on bad evidence.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by smcin on Monday March 10, 2025 @11:07PM (#43328779)
> > They're (verified) anecdotes showing the British Crown was embarrassed

"They" in my sentence clearly refers to "(or the Choctaw US$170/£111"... or Calcutta 1846 £14,000 donations" - not the Ottoman Sultan's generous donation or the anecdote about being pressured by the Crown to reduce it.

> The existence of donations, verified or otherwise, does not independently show that the British government attempted to prevent aid from reaching Ireland because they were embarrassed about how little they had contributed. That is the claim that OP puts forward with their story, that is to claim that I'm responding to.

But it's also claimed the Sultan's ships had to sail secretly, and north of Dublin to Drogheda, instead of simply unloading in Dublin, which would be faster and infinitely more logical (because the famine areas were in the west/southwest/south, not the northeast). So no, that would be a second piece of corroboration that he had needed to make the donation secretly (Why? Unless he had a fetish for being the Bruce Wayne of the 1840s. It makes no sense unless there was a reason.)

If I ever get a time machine I guess I'm dialing it to Sultan Abdülmecid's and Queen Victoria's residences in 1847 to plant listening devices to settle this for once and all. :)

But either way, even if the Ottomans never existed, the British Crown response was embarrassing, everything else is a sidebar. This all feels like it needs an AI treatment starring Joan Sims as Queen Victoria in one of the British "Carry On" comedies, and Syd James as the Sultan, and Paul Whitehouse ("Ralph and Ted") as token Irish tenant farmer. "Carry On Famine Relief".

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Monday March 10, 2025 @11:18PM (#43328846)
> "They" in my sentence clearly refers to "(or the Choctaw US$170/£111"... or Calcutta 1846 £14,000 donations" - not the Ottoman Sultan's generous donation or the anecdote about being pressured by the Crown to reduce it.

Oh, I was interpreting your comment as relevant to mine rather than completely tangential. My mistake, as you were.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by smcin on Monday March 10, 2025 @11:43PM (#43328952)
My comment is directly responsive to yours (and you now have triplicate threads where you're repeatedly challenging why): under all circumstances the Crown's response was inadequate, and disputing the anecdote about the Crown allegedly pressuring the Sultan to reduce his donation is an unnecessary sidebar to reaching that exact conclusion.

Further I showed you an independent piece of corroboration about whether the Sultan had to donate in secret, so it's absolutely not single-sourced to "one anecdote forty lears later by the Sultan's son."

Here's more corroboration by Drogheda people (and former President McAleese) that the Ottoman famine relief ships did in fact land in Drogheda (and inexplicably, not Dublin): https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/ireland-remembers-how-19th-c... Since there is zero reason to waste time sailing urgently-needed food aid ships north past Dublin to a smaller port (Drogheda) from which it would take longer to distribute, that raises the obvious question why they did that. Go look at any map of Ireland to verify that, instead of mocking that.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by xinuc on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @01:08AM (#43329323)
As they say, you can not make a blind man see
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by xinuc on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @01:18AM (#43329363)
Charity and the Great Hunger in Ireland: The Kindness of Strangers. By Christine Kinealy

https://books.google.co.id/books?id=GnksAQAAQBAJ&lpg=PR4&hl=...

> He had originally offered £10,000 to the British Relief Association and some ships laden with provisions, but had been advised by British diplomats that British Royal protocol meant that nobody should contribute more than the Queen. It was suggested that he gave half the sum contributed by Victoria.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @07:56AM (#43331555)
That was published in 2013. Do you have a physical copy that would allow you to see footnote 64 and see where this author got the story?

(The Google book has a lot of footnote 64s at the bottom, but it's impossible to see which corresponds to which chapter or to know if the 64 we're looking for is even there at all.)

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by westonmyers on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @03:23PM (#43336090)
Chapter 5-64: The Albion. A Journal of News, Politics and Literature, 21 July 1849.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by genewitch on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:02PM (#43326610)
I wrote a song called greenocide where my Irish friend explained this in a particularly straightforward way.

The English already owned all the land so they figured let the Irish die out. In essence.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by mritun on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:41PM (#43326950)
That’s pretty much what the British did in Bengal.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by FjordWarden on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:21PM (#43326785)
Something even more remarkable, the Indians that where only a few years ago forcibly relocated and experienced their own starvations during the events of the Trail of Teers, collected about 700$ in donations and send it as aid to the starving Irish in a grand gesture of empathy amongst oppressed people.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by spacebanana7 on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:14PM (#43326714)
Is there an academic source available for that?
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:20PM (#43326775)
Wikipedia says that the provenance is... sketchy, to say the least:

> The claim that he had wanted to give £10,000 first appears in Taylor & Mackay's Life and Times of Sir Robert Peel (1851), but the book is not referenced and no source is given. A second source, dating to 1894, is more explicit: the Irish nationalist William J. O'Neill Daunt claimed to have heard from the son of the sultan's personal physician that he "had intended to give £10,000 to the famine-stricken Irish, but was deterred by the English ambassador, Lord Cowley, as Her Majesty, who had only subscribed £1000, would have been annoyed had a foreign sovereign given a larger sum…"

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ireland%E2%80%93Turkey_relat...

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by s_dev on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:20PM (#43326782)
https://www.mfa.gov.tr/relations-between-turkiye-and-ireland...

The 1,000 Pound claim at least can be sourced from this website.

It very much was policy that killed the Irish and not the lack of food. Ireland exported enough food to feed the country four times over -- during the Famine.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:24PM (#43326816)
This source notably does not make the claim that the amount was lowered in response to a request from Queen Victoria, which is the actually damning claim.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by thfuran on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:28PM (#43326847)
That entire claim is unnecessary for the given conclusion, which is substantiated by other evidence.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by kortilla on Monday March 10, 2025 @08:16PM (#43327755)
Then there is no reason to include that part. It changes the entire tone of the British govt’s response.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by smcin on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:19PM (#43328503)
Are we 100% in agreement that Queen Victoria's donation in 1848 was inadequate to prevent 1 million people from starving to death, and that Britain had direct responsibility for the gross inequality in land ownership that constituted Ireland in the 1840s, whereas the Ottoman Sultans, or Calcutta (or the Choctaw Nation) had zero responsibility?

I mean we could look at British spending (govt and crown) in the period 1845-52. Or note that Queen Victoria was one of the wealthiest women in the world, and Parliament granted her an annuity of £385,000 per year.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by kortilla on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:27PM (#43328548)
Yes, but the notion that a donation 10x larger was declined for optics is so fundamentally different from those claims I can’t even believe that there is any confusion here about how ridiculous including that is.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by smcin on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:37PM (#43328616)
Why isn't "How did Queen Victoria spend her yearly £385,000 in 1845, and 1846, and 1847, and 1848" infinitely more relevant to deciding whether her documented lack of meaningful intervention should be considered embarrassing or not? I don't accept your framing at all.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queen_Victoria#Marriage_and_pu...

(Didn't know there were attempts to assassinate her in 1840, 1842, 1849 and 1850. Mostly by English people, btw.)

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:39PM (#43328633)
No one is questioning that all of this is relevant to the famine. All we're saying is that this specific story quoted by OP is most likely fictitious, so we're better off focusing on all of the other evidence and facts (such as the facts that you're bringing up).

I honestly have no clue what you're trying to argue here: No one is actually arguing with any of your points, nor did either of us give any indication that we would disagree with them in comments before you came. What you're bringing up is essentially a non-sequitur to what this subthread is actually about.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by smcin on Monday March 10, 2025 @11:32PM (#43328905)
Conversely, I'm saying that disputing the anecdote about allegedly pressuring the Sultan to reduce his donation is an unnecessary sidebar to reaching the inescapable conclusion that the Crown's response was embarrassing and dwarfed by other donations (e.g. Calcutta).

(We have multiple threads on this, if you want to respond let's pick one to make primary.)

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Monday March 10, 2025 @11:55PM (#43329000)
And as I've said, we agree, so I see no need to pick a thread to reply.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by kortilla on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:58PM (#43382844)
The sidebar is necessary because it’s an unsubstantiated claim that dilutes the actual discussion.

It’s like slipping in an anecdote that she also ate children for breakfast. It’s right to call out incorrect stuff added even if it’s “supporting” the larger argument.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:29PM (#43326859)
Agreed. So there's no need to perpetuate claims whose provenance is "someone 40 years later claimed to have heard this from the sultan's physician's son" (see my reply to GP). We have plenty else to use.
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by smcin on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:25PM (#43328536)
You seriously don't think that Calcutta donating more (£14,000) in 1846 and two years earlier than Queen Victoria (1848) isn't a damning fact? (and the Calcutta donation is a verified fact. So no need to dispute the anecdote about the Sultan's donation.)
Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by lolinder on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:34PM (#43328602)
As I mentioned in my response to your other comment, the controversial part of the anecdote is the claim that Victoria actually intercepted sent aid and convinced someone through diplomatic pressure to lower their intended donation.

OP does not bring up any additional donations besides the purported attempted donation from the sultan, so I'm not sure why you're bringing that up as some kind of controversial thing: You're literally the first person to mention it here.

As I've said in my other comments, there's plenty of evidence that the British government both did far less than they should have to help with the famine and there's also evidence that they willfully exacerbated it. I fully accept and appreciate that. I have no clue why you're waving that evidence at me as some kind of gotcha when the only thing I'm disputing is this single specific story.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by smcin on Monday March 10, 2025 @11:30PM (#43328897)
I specifically brought up the other donations to show that the Crown's response was inadequate, and the Calcutta donation in 1846 was both earlier and larger, this not only before Queen Victoria had not yet donated but not yet started (in 1847) encouraging Protestant landowners to fundraise in lieu of donating herself...

So under all circumstances her behavior wasn't impressive. Ok? I'm suggesting that disputing the anecdote about allegedly pressuring the Sultan to reduce his donation is an unnecessary sidebar to reaching the same conclusion.

Re:What made the Irish famine so deadly by SwtCyber on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @02:57AM (#43329863)
When political pride outweighs human lives, you know something is deeply broken. Definitely reinforces the idea that famines are rarely just about food shortages