News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Real Chilling Effects by nobodywillobsrv on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:53AM (#43319026)
Might be a strawman, but it seems this kind of person reverses the order of time.

People worrying about free speech before (and now in the UK) are ignored, called hysterical etc ... yet the minute someone is worried about Orange Man it's legitimate worry and you are hypocritical if you feel schadenfreude a bit.

Denialism is a real poison. Sided worryists/denialists are the real problem.

I'm not sure how to call them out without engaging in the same games they play themselves.

There are groups doing great work though, like the FSU in the UK.

Re:Real Chilling Effects by _petronius on Monday March 10, 2025 @07:09AM (#43319140)
I think this is confusing two things, intentionally:

1. Free speech in the public sphere includes the right of people offended by your speech to express that they are offended (to speak back). People like Toby Young (founder of the FSU), and those who decry "cancel culture" do not like this, but it is part of what constitutes genuine free expression.

2. Free speech against the government, which the government should not be allowed to punish people for, to enable a pluralistic and democratic society. E.g. someone like Mahmoud Khalil who was recently arrested for his political views on Palestine (in violation of both the principles of free speech and his rights as a green card holder).

People angry about #1 (arguing) tend to conflate it with #2 (genuine censorship), and accuse people who accuse those approximately equal (or less) in power than them as equivalent to draconian speech-controllers. People angry about #2 are pointing out a genuine power imbalance, and the damage to democratic society.

Elon Musk embodies this perfectly: he argues in favor of free speech when people tell him his opinions are objectionable, but actively censors speech on Twitter that he doesn't like. In one situation, he simply wants people to receive his speech without speaking back, in another, he wants to stifle discussion.

Speech is not a unidirectional activity. In order for it to be valuable and protected, the act of speaking in public is the act of listening to criticisms of what you say.

Re:Real Chilling Effects by llamaimperative on Monday March 10, 2025 @07:36AM (#43319393)
To add some nuance about the US’s 1st Amendment: it is not just speech against the government that is protected. It is that all speech is protected from the government.

The government also is not allowed to imprison you or threaten you for speech about another private party, for example.

Re:Real Chilling Effects by suraci on Monday March 10, 2025 @07:45AM (#43319478)
pro-palestinian protestors were arrested under biden admin too, does it mean there's 'limited' free speech at the biden era?

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/2000-people-arrested-na...

i mean, how much free it should be to be free speech, how far it can be 'limited' but still is free speech

I'm not defending for trump or elon musk, in case you want to know it

Re:Real Chilling Effects by llamaimperative on Monday March 10, 2025 @07:35PM (#43327455)
You actually think there’s no difference between Department of Homeland Security’s federal agents and a local municipal (or sometimes even campus) police force arresting someone?

Arresting someone for a crime is obviously not a problem, and generally protestors commit all sorts of minor nuisance civil violations for which they get arrested, booked, and released — all of which must be done without regard to the content of the speech being exercised during the violation. Deploying federal officers to go hunt down specific individuals and then disappearing them across state lines and modifying their immigration status without due process is absolutely unequivocally in a totally different league.

Trump has specifically said he’s going after people for the content of their speech. This is illegal and is totally different from what happened under Biden.

Re:Real Chilling Effects by nindalf on Monday March 10, 2025 @07:24AM (#43319278)
Randall Munroe explained freedom of speech better than I could - https://xkcd.com/1357/

You seem to be invoking the tired old trope of "both sides bad". But they're not. The government pardoning rioters and punishing law firms is not the same as individuals saying "you know what, fuck Roseanne Barr, I don't want to watch her show anymore."

You're tying yourself in knots to establish a false equivalence between the two. But it's clear as day that they're not.

Re:Real Chilling Effects by scandox on Monday March 10, 2025 @07:45AM (#43319474)
Can you not see how what that XKCD says which sounds so reasonable and innocuous will look to the people on the receiving end: that they are being shamed by an aggressive, vocal minority because of the views they sincerely hold? That this intolerance or deplatorming or whatever it gets called is likely to start as mere people not liking what you say and end in burning? Maybe both sides aren't as bad as each other but they're sure as blind as each other.
Re:Real Chilling Effects by kolektiv on Monday March 10, 2025 @07:53AM (#43319535)
What do you propose as an alternative? That people should have listen to/host a certain percentage of unpopular views regardless of will? There is nothing stopping you creating your own platform, or finding one where you're welcome - if that fails to get much traction, it's probably because your message isn't very popular, and the people opposed to it perhaps weren't a minority.

What is it that you should do with, let's say, Nazis? Should the rest of society not make it clear that they consider them abhorrent?

Re:Real Chilling Effects by scandox on Monday March 10, 2025 @08:10AM (#43319708)
There's no reason to reach for the Nazis. As an example they are the reverse of clarifying.

What I've seen the last 15 years is both right and left aggressively hollowing out the centre. Views that would have been vaguely centre right in the Clinton era described as fascistic. Views that would have been faintly centre left treated as communist propaganda. And the contempt and hatred on both sides showed me that nobody despite their protestations would have any problem with their opponents being subjected to any kind of suppression if they had the power to do so...

Edit: to answer your question I do not have the solution but I believe better psychology and more respect for the other view point is certainly the starting point.

Re:Real Chilling Effects by nindalf on Monday March 10, 2025 @09:37AM (#43320470)
I'm going to paste in the xkcd transcript here, just so we're on the same page.

> Public Service Announcement: The Right to Free Speech means the government can't arrest you for what you say. It doesn't mean that anyone else has to listen to your bullshit, or host you while you share it. The 1st Amendment doesn't shield you from criticism or consequences. If you're yelled at, boycotted, have your show canceled, or get banned from an Internet community, your free speech rights aren't being violated. It's just that the people listening think you're an asshole, and they're showing you the door.

If we don't like someone, we don't need to support them right? If I'm right wing, and I don't like Taylor Swift's views on politics, I don't need to support her. More than that, there's nothing wrong with me telling my friends "guys, don't go to her concerts, she's a terrible person." This is fine! It is completely ok! Taylor Swift might be in dire financial straits because we don't give her our money, but that's the consequence of her sharing views that her fans don't.

Of course in an ideal world we separate the art from the artist etc, but we don't need to. It's part of our right to free speech to associate only with those we want to.

And certainly let's not try to set up a false equivalence between boycotting (or "cancelling") Swift with the Federal Government penalising lawyers for doing their jobs. Anyone entering a thread about Trump weaponising the government talking about "muh cancel culture did it first", that's a low quality contribution that only empowers Trump and his lackeys.

Re:Real Chilling Effects by scandox on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:11AM (#43320849)
What I'm saying is that the poor psychology and overreach of one side empowered him in the first place. And I see no sign of those people understanding their role in that dynamic.
Re:Real Chilling Effects by nindalf on Monday March 10, 2025 @11:44AM (#43321807)
I hear you.

I'm saying you're mistaken.

Just because Trump justifies his terrible acts by pointing out to DEI, cancel culture or whatever, doesn't mean those things were wrong. You're thinking of an alternate history where there was no cancel culture and there would be no Trump, and therefore the people who cancelled anyone are responsible for Trump.

No. Trump voters are responsible for Trump. Trump is responsible for Trump. Someone who said "fuck Roseanne Barr, I'll never watch her show again" has 0 responsibility.

Re:Real Chilling Effects by guelo on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:40PM (#43326936)
That's bully mentality, that the bully was provoked and is somewhat justified.
Re:Real Chilling Effects by nindalf on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @01:40AM (#43329492)
Just hypothetically, if people stopped buying Teslas because they didn’t like the CEO, and the stock price fell 50% in 2 months, is that cancel culture too? Is that “poor psychology”? Are we “overreaching”? Should we go out there and buy Teslas and Tesla stock so that the CEO’s feelings don’t get hurt?

Come on man, be real. Stop it with the enlightened centrism.

Re:Real Chilling Effects by renata on Monday March 10, 2025 @01:49PM (#43323232)
But if you own the biggest social network in the world and say "Taylor Swift is no longer allowed to advertise or promote her music on this platform", just because you don't agree with her politics, people might see that as censorship, or at least shady.
Re:Real Chilling Effects by nindalf on Monday March 10, 2025 @01:54PM (#43323329)
That is true, a social network doing it is not the same as an individual doing it.

But social networks are businesses too, right. They're beholden to advertisers, just like network TV. So what they allow is constrained by what advertisers will accept. And lastly, the network is beholden to its own users. If the users don't like being surrounded by Nazis, they'll leave.

Compare Twitter when it was bought to it now. On any metric it's much worse. Lower revenue, 10x lower valuation. It's a cesspit, but at least no right winger is censored right! That's something.