News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by supriyo-biswas on Friday March 07, 2025 @03:01PM (#43293880)
At my former employer, there was a team who were very much into resume-driven development and wrote projects in Go even when Java would have been the better alternative considering the overall department and maintenance team expertise, all the while they were informally grumbling about how Go doesn’t have the features they need…
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by darkhorse222 on Friday March 07, 2025 @03:40PM (#43294355)
I see that a lot from the Go crowd. That's why I consider any strong opinions on languages to be a poor indicator for ability. Sure there's differences, but a language does not make the engineer. Someone who is attracted to flashy stuff makes for an indulgent planner.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by scubbo on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:03PM (#43294625)
> That's why I consider any strong opinions on languages to be a poor indicator for ability.

Hmm. Can't say I agree here - at least not with the literal text of what you've written (although maybe we agree in spirit). I agree that _simplistic_ strong opinions about languages are a sign of poor thoughtfulness ("<thing> is good and <other thing> is bad") - but I'd very much expect a Staff+ engineer to have enough experience to have strong opinions about the _relative_ strengths of various languages, where they're appropriate to use and where a different language would be better. Bonus points if they can tell me the worst aspects about their favourite one.

Maybe we're using "opinion" differently, and you'd call what I described there "facts" rather than opinions. In which case - yeah, fair!

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by mikepurvis on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:19PM (#43294815)
Absolutely. Anyone senior should be able to fairly quickly get a handle on the requirements for a particular project and put forward a well-reasoned opinion on an appropriate tech stack for it. There might be some blank space in there for "I've heard of X and Y that actually might fit this use case slightly better, so it's probably worth a brief investigation of those options, but I've used Z before so I know about the corner cases we may run into, and that has value too."
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pdimitar on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:31PM (#43294954)
And I see people who assume choosing a language was done for "flashy stuff" the less capable.

See, we can all generalize. Not productive.

Only thing I ever saw from Golang devs was pragmatism. I myself go either for Elixir or Rust and to me Golang sits in a weird middle but I've also written 20+ small tools for myself in Golang and have seen how much quicker and more productive I was when I was not obsessed with complete correctness (throwaway script-like programs, small-to-mid[ish]-sized projects, internal tools etc.)

You would do well to stop stereotyping people based on their choice of language.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by zozbot234 on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:39PM (#43295039)
> how much quicker and more productive I was when I was not obsessed with complete correctness

That's pretty much another way of saying that stuff becomes a whole lot quicker and easier when you end up getting things wrong. Which may even be true, as far as it goes. It's just not very helpful.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pdimitar on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:47PM (#43295103)
Obviously. But I did qualify my statement. There are projects where you're OK with not getting everything right from the get go.

FWIW I very much share your exact thoughts on Rust skewing metrics because it makes things too easy and because stuff almost immediately moves to maintenance mode. But that being said, we still have some tasks where we need something yesterday and we can't argue with the shot-callers about it. (And again, some personal projects where the value is low and you derive more of it if you try quickly.)

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by darkhorse222 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @10:53AM (#43301119)
I am a builder trained as a computer engineer. I scoff at languages as abstractions over fundamentals that do not change. This isn't like a hammer and a screwdriver, it's like fifteen different hammers. Just give me the thing, I'll build the house. A guy spends three hours talking about the hammer, he's probably not focused on building the house. Tool preferences show ego of the builder.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pdimitar on Saturday March 08, 2025 @11:09AM (#43301240)
> Just give me the thing, I'll build the house.

What do you think all programming discussions about languages, typing systems, runtime, tooling etc. aim for?

EXACTLY THAT.

If it was as easy as "just give me thing" then programming would have been a solved and 100% automated problem long time ago.

Your comment comes across as "if only we could fly, we would have no ground road traffic jams". I mean, obviously, yeah, but we can't fly.

Your comment also comes across a bit elitistic and from the POV of an ivory tower. Don't know if that was your goal, if not, I'd advise you to state things a bit more humbly.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by darkhorse222 on Sunday March 09, 2025 @09:53PM (#43316179)
I'm not seeking your advice. When I look at a cathedral built out of sand and call it meaningless that is not elitist, that is humble. Engineers who think their tools make all the difference are the pretentious ones. Things are not that complicated.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pdimitar on Sunday March 09, 2025 @09:57PM (#43316213)
Too much generalization. Not interesting and not a discussion. No idea why you even bothered to reply.

I stated an opinion. You can reject it silently. Having the last word is not such a badass move as many people think. :)

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by BobbyJo on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:48PM (#43295108)
Language matters quite a bit when deciding how to build an application though. I see having no strong opinions on language to be a sign the person hasn't developed a wide enough variety of projects to get a feel for their strengths and weaknesses.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by ipaddr on Friday March 07, 2025 @07:50PM (#43296468)
The more senior I get the less opinionated I am. Someone wants to do something in some different or some different way.. why not. In the end the language matters little the tech stack doesn't matter unless you are going down a specific path and even then it probably doesn't matter that much if you have a choice on what to use.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by BobbyJo on Saturday March 08, 2025 @02:15AM (#43298225)
I honestly couldn't disagree more. Having built very similar systems in Golang, Python, and Java in different companies, and having used MongoDB and other NoSQLs as well as Postgres to similar ends, I have very strong preferences about which I'd rather use in the future.

Even simple requirements can rule out languages for me. Like, if you need async or concurrency, Python is awful. If you need SQL in your code, Golang isn't great. If you are building a simple CRUD backend, Java is waste of time. If you aren't doing anything compute heavy or embedded, why even consider C++ or Rust. The list goes on.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by tbossanova on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:21AM (#43298761)
So what are the strengths of those languages?
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by BobbyJo on Saturday March 08, 2025 @11:57AM (#43301588)
Python is great for library orchestration and has tons of support for almost anything you need. So if you aren't building a large application and don't need concurrency, its great. Java is great for building large applications with large teams, since it limits how code is shared and how libraries are built, and has a culture of convention. Golang has greate concurrency support and meta programming support, so its awesome for web servers and plugging into systems that incorporate orchestration technologies. C++ and Rust are fast and efficient as hell when you need that. JavaScript is your only viable option when you need complex and interactive UI that's OS agnostic.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by ljm on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:39AM (#43299121)
There’s also the practicality of hiring or maintenance as well as what you get from the ecosystem, as well as understanding the wider business context.

I might personally love to kick off a greenfield project with Elixir, and it might tick all the technical boxes and meet the requirements. But then I have to pay a premium for senior engineers that know elixir or have to price in the time needed to upskill.

Or I could just do it in Rails where I can dip into a much larger talent pool and still meet the requirements. Much more boring but can get the job done just as well.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by darkhorse222 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @10:59AM (#43301166)
I think you overemphasize the pain. A good design will handle lots.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by BobbyJo on Saturday March 08, 2025 @11:52AM (#43301537)
Languages influence design, and application influences design. That means they influence each other.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by ipaddr on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:02PM (#43303941)
You are trying to choose between languages based on differentiation. This language is better for x so it should be used or it's a waste time or capability.

But in reality it rarely matters. If you were only allowed to use Java as a backend and your competitors could use anything your company would succeed or fail based on marketing and sales. The backend doesn't matter as long as they both have the same features.

I understand developer preference and different languages make things easier and make programming funnier. Languages have different limits.

As you become more senior you realize getting around those limits is part of the magic. If you come on to a project where the existing developer wants to write the backend in javascript because that's what they know I would rather use Javascript then wasting time trying to push a more 'pure' choice. Because in the end I am capable of writing it and what we will be judged on is if it works to achieve an objective not if it was the best language choice when using differentiation.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by BobbyJo on Monday March 10, 2025 @03:59PM (#43325307)
Then why do companies try to move so fast if if doesn't matter? Seems like your opinion runs counter to the observed behavior of the entire software industry.

If speed of execution matters, then the language and tools you use for something also matters.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by ohgr on Friday March 07, 2025 @05:16PM (#43295379)
Yeah. I have a list of things I won’t work with. That’s what experience looks like.

(Mostly .Net, PHP and Ruby)

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by rurp on Friday March 07, 2025 @03:50PM (#43294482)
I've seen the exact same pattern play out with different tools. The team used a shiny new immature platform for nice sounding reasons and then spent 80% of their time reinventing wheels that have already been solved in any number of places.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by synergy20 on Friday March 07, 2025 @03:45PM (#43294423)
golang is decent and is the only new lang climbed up to 7th in popularity, it does shine at what it's good at
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pclmulqdq on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:15PM (#43294760)
The go and rust crowds both love writing things in their own language for its own sake. Not because it's a good choice. For a large web backend, go is great. For many other things it's terrible.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pdimitar on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:34PM (#43294979)
> The go and rust crowds both love writing things in their own language for its own sake

Hard to take you seriously when you do such weird generalized takes.

While it's a sad fact that fanboys and zealots absolutely do exist, most devs can't afford to be such and have to be pragmatic. They pick languages based on merit and analysis.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pclmulqdq on Friday March 07, 2025 @05:34PM (#43295542)
Most of the people who use Go and Rust do it for pragmatic reasons. That doesn't influence the culture of the zealots in each community.

You should search for headlines on HN that say "written in Go" or "written in Rust" and then compare that to the number of headlines that say "written in JavaScript" or "written in Kotlin."

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by nativeit on Friday March 07, 2025 @07:12PM (#43296215)
I understand the criticism that languages should be pragmatic choices they serve the strengths of the project at hand, but I guess I always found most projects boasting they’re written in a specific language or framework are doing so precisely because of the overarching interest in the language itself, which seems like a perfectly valid justification for such projects to me.

I’ve seen the more cynical hype-driven stuff, but it’s inevitably superficial on first glance, where I have seen some real curiosity and exploration in many “Project X - Built In Rust/Go/Cobol/D/Whatever” and I think they’re exploring the dynamics of the language and tooling as much as anything else.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by whstl on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:28AM (#43299054)
This is not a sign or a proof of zealotry.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pdimitar on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:08AM (#43299259)
Those headlines help me understand what I am getting so I seriously have no idea what argument you are trying to make.

You do seem to say Golang and/or Rust devs are zealots which, if it is indeed what you are saying, is boring and plain false.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by hibikir on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:22PM (#43296960)
You are very fortunate: In my 20 year career, I've spent most of it surrounded by zealots, including at very well known firms. I am currently surrounded by multiple teams with extremely tight ideas of what languages they want to work in. All different ideas, yet they are working basically with the same constraints: it's not as if they ware doing very different work where another team's language would be unfit for purpose. The performance is similar, and they are basically in a culture war. They have passionate arguments listing why a different team's choice is all wrong: None hold any real water.

I am especially valuable because I am fine reading and writing any of the languages involved. The management likes that, but there's a lot of difficulties solving the tribal problem, as the leads are basically all crazy zealots, and it's not as if purging one or two factions of zealots would avoid further zealotry from the survivors. The fact that I can work across all their tech doesn't make me many friends, as my work across systems shows their arguments have little merit.

For most work, in most cases, most languages are just fine. The completely wrong tool for the job is pretty rare, and the winning argument in most places is "we have the most people that have experience with tool X, or really want to try exciting new thing Y", for whatever the problem is, and whatever X might be.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pdimitar on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:07AM (#43299251)
What's preventing you from working in a less dysfunctional place, exactly?
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by zozbot234 on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:34PM (#43294982)
Rust is pretty antithetical to resume-driven development because a lot of the stuff that's written in Rust is too well-written and free of the usual kinds of software defects. It immediately becomes "done" and enters low-effort maintenance mode, there's just very little reason to get involved with it anymore since "it just works". Believe it or not, this whole dynamic is behind a lot of the complaints about Rust in the workplace. It's literally making things too easy.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by ipaddr on Friday March 07, 2025 @07:57PM (#43296516)
It's like a perl script you wrote on acid. It's done because you cannot enter that mindspace anymore and the code you created is like the output of an encrypted password with no path back.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pclmulqdq on Friday March 07, 2025 @05:36PM (#43295559)
I have to say that the median crate I interact with has the following readme:

" Version 0.2 - Unstable/buggy/slow unless you use exactly like the example - not going to get updated because I moved on to something else"

Rust is another programming language. It's easier to write code without a certain class of bugs, but that doesn't mean version 0.2 of a casual project is going to be bug-free.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by LPisGood on Friday March 07, 2025 @05:20PM (#43295419)
It’s not that I don’t believe you, hut that I’m having trouble seeing how what you say could be true.

Rust projects immediately become “done”??? They don’t also having changing requirements and dependencies? Why aren’t everyone at the best shops using it for everything if it massively eliminates work load?

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by conjectures on Friday March 07, 2025 @05:57PM (#43295717)
Not from what I've seen. The compiler is slow af which plays badly with how fussy the thing is.

It's easy to have no defects in functionality you never got around to writing because you ran out of time.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by rescbr on Friday March 07, 2025 @08:36PM (#43296702)
So it makes you think before typing and compiling the code?

Doesn’t look like a con to me :)

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by conjectures on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @06:40AM (#43331101)
Here's a great life hack for you. Set a 15s delay whenever you type in an editor. That way you'll think more before writing code.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by ohgr on Friday March 07, 2025 @05:17PM (#43295393)
Having watched two entirely fucked up Rust projects get written off I think you need to get out more.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by FpUser on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:57PM (#43297099)
What a load of BS. Even if initial time saving was true because of "no bugs feature" and it is not. Any software product that serves real business needs usually constantly evolves. Most of the time is spent on planning new features and integrating those into existing architecture.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by tcmart14 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @02:10AM (#43298198)
Yup. It's easy to write a to-do app. What is hard is 10 years later of features and needing to add more. While also dealing with the architecture short sightedness and pitfalls. Anyone who has worked on legacy software knows, at some point, all architectural decisions eventually become architectural pitfalls, primarily because requirements and customers change. It becomes a point where, its not really the code that's the issue, its design and customers' changing requirements.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by dambi0 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:25AM (#43299044)
Are you saying that Rust is always the right choice for any problem? If not what’s the link between the merits of any technology and the guarantee that the selection was not resume driven?
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by ljm on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:52AM (#43299182)
A sibling thread talks about language zealotry and this is a textbook example.

I didn’t realise that the only requirement for well-written code is to have an expressive type system and memory safety.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by Eggpants on Saturday March 08, 2025 @09:27AM (#43300492)
You forgot the /s
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by whstl on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:35PM (#43294996)
Life is too short to program on languages one doesn't love.

Those people, if they really exist, are right.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by pclmulqdq on Friday March 07, 2025 @07:07PM (#43296187)
To be honest, I agree with you, and I think this is the right approach to life if you have a strong preference for languages. I think this only gets a bad name when people aren't upfront about their preferences and skills, with a lot of people having bad experiences with a go zealot at some point.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by whstl on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:30AM (#43299070)
It seems the zealotry here is not coming from the Go and Rust people, though. From another message, your measure of presence of zealots is by the amount of "HN titles".

Rewriting something in Go or Rust and announcing it is not being a Zealot.

Being enthusiastic about something shouldn't be a cause for us to judge them like this. We should be happy about them.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by mvdtnz on Friday March 07, 2025 @03:49PM (#43294470)
You're missing the point completely.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by whstl on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:25PM (#43294884)
I have lot of sympathy for resume-driven developers. They're just answering to the labor market. More power to them.

When companies do what the market expect we praise them. When it's workers, we scorn them. This attitude is seriously fucked up.

When companies start hiring based on experience, adaptability, curiosity, potential and curiosity then you get to complain. Until that, anyone doing it should be considered a fucking genius.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by usefulcat on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:48PM (#43295106)
Pretty sure most of the resentment comes from working with such people. Which I think is understandable.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by whstl on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:54PM (#43295169)
Understandable, but still wrongfully blaming a player rather than the game itself.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by marsovo on Friday March 07, 2025 @07:24PM (#43296287)
I don't think it's wrong to blame people who make life more difficult for others for their own aggrandizement

The game doesn't exist without players. I could make more money if I worked at Meta or Amazon, but at what cost?

I understand the realities of Game Theory, but then one could argue that being blamed and criticized for one's choices is also part of the game. "Mr Wolfcastle, how do you sleep at night?" "On a big pile of money with many beautiful ladies"

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by ipaddr on Friday March 07, 2025 @07:41PM (#43296406)
You are more likely to leave tech/full time employment after working at a FAANG. Either you made enough,it burnt you out, everywhere else seems down, etc. You go to another FAANG or try a startup or leave altogether.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by whstl on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:35AM (#43299391)
> I don't think it's wrong to blame people who make life more difficult for others for their own aggrandizement

It is, and this is highly judgmental and offensive. Nobody is doing this for "aggrandizement".

Also, all of this is just rationalization, and will keep being until:

1) People start blaming companies for not having the spine to say no to misguided projects by employees.

2) People start blaming Companies for not having the spine to hire people based on past experiences with the craft of programming itself, but rather asking them to have a certain box ticked in their CV.

If one wants to program in X in order to better feed their family and the market says they need to have used X professionally, it is in their right to do X at the workplace.

This is not only expected of them, this is how the whole industry is set up.

They're just following the rules, period.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by namaria on Sunday March 09, 2025 @08:21AM (#43308475)
> People start blaming companies

For maximizing their gains in spite of wider consequences? Why? I thought that was genius level behavior in your book.

Why do you feel compelled to denounce this behavior on one side and praise it on another? That seems to be the very hypocrisy that you are shaking your fists against.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by fallingknife on Friday March 07, 2025 @05:07PM (#43295298)
What good does that do on a resume? I thought learning a new language on the job was pretty standard.
Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by supriyo-biswas on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:35PM (#43297527)
Where I'm from, the recruiters often use dumb questions like "How many years of experience do you have with X?" where any answer below their threshold is an immediate ground for rejection.

Learning new technologies on the go is pretty much the standard, but it's something that employers don't understand.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by ohgr on Friday March 07, 2025 @05:13PM (#43295353)
We have those! Turn up, make some micro-services or AWS crap pile we don’t need to solve a simple problem, then fuck off somewhere else and leave everyone else to clean it up.

Worst one is the data pipeline we have. It’s some AWS lambda mess which uses curl to download a file from somewhere and put it into S3. Then another lambda turns up at some point and parses that out and pokes it into DynamoDB. This fucks up at least once a month because the guy who wrote the parser uses 80s BASIC style string manipulation and luck. Then another thing reads that out of DynamoDB and makes a CSV (sometimes escaped improperly) and puts that into another bucket.

I of course entirely ignore this and use one entire line of R to do the same job

Along comes a senior spider and says “maybe we can fix all these problems with AI”. No you can stop hiring acronym collectors.

Re:Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI by conjectures on Friday March 07, 2025 @05:51PM (#43295669)
Ah, the good ole Rube Goldberg machine.