News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by ziddoap on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:15PM (#43272532)
>UK users would not be beholden to Apple for E2EE if their clients had legitimate alternatives to the first-party iCloud service.

Any sufficiently popular alternative would be subject to the same issue: you can't backdoor encryption without making it insecure.

>There would be no world where Apple could even threaten to disable it.

Your framing of this seems to blame Apple, and I don't understand why.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by alwayslikethis on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:32PM (#43274263)
You can have a service beyond the reach of UK law enforcement. Somehow piracy on the clearnet never really stopped with it being illegal in most countries.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by tree_enjoyer on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @07:48PM (#43274784)
If you're a company with offices, personnel, and assets in the UK, well your "service" may be beyond the reach, but the rest isn't.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by ziddoap on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:28PM (#43275148)
You're suggesting that Apple, a giant publicly traded company with known people that can be summoned to court and assets located in places that can be seized, should ignore lawful orders from a country they are operating in?

Can I ask you how you think that would play out?

>Somehow piracy on the clearnet never really stopped with it being illegal in most countries.

I'm sure you can spot the difference between a small group of people running a piracy site and a multinational company selling physical devices in physical stores.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by alwayslikethis on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:59PM (#43275408)
I'm not talking about Apple here.

This is what you said:

> Any sufficiently popular alternative would be subject to the same issue: you can't backdoor encryption without making it insecure.

I'm just saying this is not true because you can have a company without any legal presence, thus susceptibility to law enforcement, in the UK. The legal issue will be shifted onto the user, but it's hard to go after millions of users compared to one big company.

The parallel with piracy is that they also tend to be operated from beyond the jurisdiction of countries enforcing the copyright.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by ben_w on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @10:22PM (#43276061)
That didn't work out for X in Brazil. The government of a sovereign nation can just require you to have a presence to do business there.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by alwayslikethis on Thursday March 06, 2025 @06:32AM (#43278958)
That's mostly because of them using Musk's other business as leverage. A good company created explicitly to operate like this has no such vulnerability. The UK can try to stop them by trying to block the IPs or whatever, and the company is in turn free to try to circumvent it. The only issue is they may be banned from App store, which is a self-inflicted problem caused by Apple.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by immibis on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:01PM (#43294606)
They simply blocked the whole of X in the whole of Brazil. They made it a crime to circumvent the block, so of course you could still access it with a VPN, as long as you didn't log into any account tied to your presence in Brazil, making it useless for politicians and the like. They didn't need to "use another business as leverage."
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by robertlagrant on Thursday March 06, 2025 @05:47AM (#43278618)
> you can have a company without any legal presence, thus susceptibility to law enforcement, in the UK

This is true, although you'd need to sideload to avoid things like "UK government bans this app from the UK app store".

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by Filligree on Thursday March 06, 2025 @01:33PM (#43283482)
Or worse, “UK government requires the App Store version to be backdoored”.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by wqaatwt on Thursday March 06, 2025 @04:16AM (#43278107)
> should ignore lawful orders from a country they are operating in?

By allowing users to install arbitrary software on their computers which is not directly controlled by them?

That certainly would be shocking and unheard of.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by genewitch on Saturday March 08, 2025 @03:49AM (#43298638)
"Lawful" "order" is cute.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by lll-o-lll on Thursday March 06, 2025 @02:59AM (#43277631)
> you can't backdoor encryption without making it insecure.

That’s not really true is it? If I have a building where every room has its own key, but there is also a “master key” that can open all doors; then it’s not “insecure”. You want to be pretty bl—dy careful with that master key, sure, but the idea isn’t crazy.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by akimbostrawman on Thursday March 06, 2025 @07:22AM (#43279397)
Even the most secure masterkey can just be stolen.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/EternalBlue

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by ziddoap on Thursday March 06, 2025 @09:05AM (#43280316)
It is absolutely a crazy idea.

Physical analogies don't really work in this situation because of the scale, and the payout.

A physical master key for a building has a few hundred thousand/a few million people that could potentially access it. The payout is low (i.e. the motivation is low on average)

An encryption backdoor to phones has a few billion people that could potentially access it. From anywhere in the world. The payout is huge (access to all iPhones).

Multiple entire governments would dedicate tens of millions of dollars and thousands of people to gain access to a ubiquitous backdoor on something like a phone. The same just isn't true with your building analogy -- they are completely different.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by lll-o-lll on Thursday March 06, 2025 @05:05PM (#43285527)
It doesn’t have to be one key for all, one key for a bucket, per user if needs be. Can’t these master keys be in offline HSM’s? I get your argument, but it doesn’t seem an impossible problem to solve.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by immibis on Saturday March 08, 2025 @08:31AM (#43300113)
So the UK government would buy one HSM for every UK citizen and store their backdoor access key on there?

And put the HSMs where? In a big room? Protected by a door, with one key?

Or maybe each of the 650 elected politicians gets to hold 10 HSMs, each holding 10,000 keys? That way, by distributing trust, we can be completely sure that politicians are always snooping on about 10% of everyone's mails, instead of worrying about whether it's 100% or 0% at any particular moment.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by gopher_space on Thursday March 06, 2025 @05:30PM (#43285693)
More to the point, a master key is a management tool for infrastructure maintenance. Its relationship to security is that I can securely keep all the monkeys organized in my monkey hut. The master key exists in a world where you can throw a brick through a window.

Security *around* the master key is entirely about pinning liability to one human being at a time. Security through hot potato.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by qwertox on Thursday March 06, 2025 @01:50PM (#43283730)
That master key sounds like a high value target, if it can open so many doors. Are you sure the one who guards that key is storing it securely enough and not just in a keyring together with other "important" keys he sometimes carries around needlessly? Are you sure he can't be coerced into "borrowing" it to someone, or handing it over to the police without first letting a lawyer check the warrants?

Have you considered that the locks need to have a weaker security if a key must exist which can open all the doors in the building?

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by BrandoElFollito on Friday March 07, 2025 @01:33AM (#43287780)
This is a very good answer.

The last part is probe to discussion, though. You need to make the lock weaker, yes, but maybe just a little bit and you maybe need 4.5 days to open it vs. the 5 days when there is no master key. It is a matter of math (mechanics in that case) and risk assessment.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by vunderba on Thursday March 06, 2025 @03:26PM (#43284759)
The ability to steal the master key by virtue of it being a physical object is SEVERAL orders of magnitude lower than a "virtual master key" that is potentially vulnerable to the entire online community.

If you consolidate security into a singular "skeleton key" - you 100% weaken your security.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by genewitch on Saturday March 08, 2025 @03:51AM (#43298643)
It's (perhaps not?) well known that locks that are master keyed are inherently less secure than locks that aren't

It requires roughly half the picking effort.

in a lock you have multiple sets of pins. the key pushes pins, and if it pushes all the pins so that the top of the pin is at the boundary of the lock (the shear line), the lock turns.

There is a spring that pushes a connected pin down, which is what actually prevents the lock from turning. These are called driver pins. there is a separate pin(s) that the key actually interfaces with. The key pushes the pins until the driver pin moves past the shear line, when all driver pins and key pins are not interfering with the shear line, you can rotate/whatever the key and it is unlocked.

A master-keyed lock has additional discs inside the keyway, usually below the normal pins (closest to the key.) The discs are added based on the amount of extra movement needed to accept both the non-master, and the master key. So a master keyed lock has two, separate shearing points, the top of the regular pin, and the top of the master disc. This means there are at least two set-points for picking to get the driver pin out of the way - where the driver pin is flush with the shear line (as it would be with a regular, non-master key,) and where the normal pin's lower face is flush with the shear line (as it would be when a master key is inserted).