News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by alwayslikethis on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:59PM (#43275408)
I'm not talking about Apple here.

This is what you said:

> Any sufficiently popular alternative would be subject to the same issue: you can't backdoor encryption without making it insecure.

I'm just saying this is not true because you can have a company without any legal presence, thus susceptibility to law enforcement, in the UK. The legal issue will be shifted onto the user, but it's hard to go after millions of users compared to one big company.

The parallel with piracy is that they also tend to be operated from beyond the jurisdiction of countries enforcing the copyright.

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by ben_w on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @10:22PM (#43276061)
That didn't work out for X in Brazil. The government of a sovereign nation can just require you to have a presence to do business there.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by alwayslikethis on Thursday March 06, 2025 @06:32AM (#43278958)
That's mostly because of them using Musk's other business as leverage. A good company created explicitly to operate like this has no such vulnerability. The UK can try to stop them by trying to block the IPs or whatever, and the company is in turn free to try to circumvent it. The only issue is they may be banned from App store, which is a self-inflicted problem caused by Apple.
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by immibis on Friday March 07, 2025 @04:01PM (#43294606)
They simply blocked the whole of X in the whole of Brazil. They made it a crime to circumvent the block, so of course you could still access it with a VPN, as long as you didn't log into any account tied to your presence in Brazil, making it useless for politicians and the like. They didn't need to "use another business as leverage."
Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by robertlagrant on Thursday March 06, 2025 @05:47AM (#43278618)
> you can have a company without any legal presence, thus susceptibility to law enforcement, in the UK

This is true, although you'd need to sideload to avoid things like "UK government bans this app from the UK app store".

Re:NCSC, GCHQ, UK Gov't expunge advice to "use Apple encrypt... by Filligree on Thursday March 06, 2025 @01:33PM (#43283482)
Or worse, “UK government requires the App Store version to be backdoored”.