News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by kajecounterhack on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:55PM (#43238147)
> it's really difficult to build things to last.

Having a non-user replaceable battery is a really easy way to ensure a product stops working after 3-4 years though.

And the criticism is typically directed at companies like Apple, who does make things that last physically, but then force you to upgrade by way of battery.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by pinkmuffinere on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:08PM (#43238199)
Both can be true: planned obsolescence is real, but building things to last is difficult too.

IMO the durability problems in early generations of products tend to be "real", because there are still real engineering problems that aren't understood, and there isn't (generally) a super limited market. Once the engineering problems are solved and the market is fully saturated, there is suddenly an incentive to add planned obsolescence. I don't have any data to back up this claim though.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by jordanb on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:39PM (#43238363)
A more accurate term is "value engineering."

If you have a product that's been in the market for a while and it looks like it's meeting service life expectations you start looking at it trying to find ways to save money by substituting cheaper parts. You swap out metal gears for plastic gears, for instance.

If these parts have a shorter service life, but the service life is still longer than the warranty, then maybe that's a win in two ways for the manufacturer.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by pinkmuffinere on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:11AM (#43238503)
Wow that's super interesting! I've never heard of this, but the appeal is immediately obvious. Thanks for commenting, gonna have to do a Wikipedia binge.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by folsom on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:57AM (#43238738)
I think of it as a continuous feedback loop between engineering, finance, and QA that ultimately ends in a product being manufactured as inexpensively as possible without dying in the warranty period.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by xethos on Monday March 03, 2025 @05:45AM (#43240474)
> You swap out metal gears for plastic gears, for instance.

Great, till the motor that drives the gears jams. When the gears are metal,the expensive part (the motor) is more likely to lose. When the gears are plastic, the motor survives and you need to replace the gears with nylon ones or 3D print your own.

The plastic gears may not always be designed as a sacrificial part, but most consumers unfairly dismiss the possibility immediately

This comes down to warranty too. If it fails during the warranty period, which one does the OEM want to pay to replace: the expensive motor, or the cheap gearing?

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by BizarroLand on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @01:05PM (#43258027)
Honestly, though, nothing has come along or happened to create the need for more power than what was found in the iphone 6 or 7.

Modern phones are examples of too much power for too little reason as far as I am concerned.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by nicoburns on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:57AM (#43238739)
You're never really forced to upgrade because of battery. If you don't want to get Apple to replace it (which though expensive is still much cheaper than a new phone), then you can take it to your local phone repair shop which will do it for not much more than the cost of a replacement battery.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by yard2010 on Monday March 03, 2025 @02:55AM (#43239333)
In some versions of the iPhone the screen is maliciously connected to the board with strong adhesive making these replacements not easy at all.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by Someone on Monday March 03, 2025 @04:05AM (#43239835)
> the screen is maliciously connected to the board with strong adhesive

That’s not necessarily malice. Using lots of glue makes the device stronger, and making glue that a) glues really well (if there’s as good as no bezel, how is the screen staying attached to the phone otherwise?), b) lasts for years in any climate and c) can be easily removed isn’t an easy problem.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by KETHERCORTEX on Monday March 03, 2025 @04:54AM (#43240135)
Using glue is an anti-repair malice by itself. On my planet screws and gaskets were invented long ago.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by mschuster91 on Monday March 03, 2025 @06:01AM (#43240556)
Screws are visible from the outside though.

In any case, all it takes to repair a phone with a glued screen is a two face suction grip for about 20 dollars and an ordinary hair dryer.

The nasty part of a phone repair, I will admit that, is scraping off the glue gunk - I had to repair a Google Pixel once where the battery was dead, and during removing the glue on the display unit border I apparently managed to damage the seal between the OLED display and the glass, exposing the OLED to oxygen which led to eventual oxidization and a new display panel.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by ryukafalz on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:49AM (#43241239)
> Screws are visible from the outside though.

Which is a positive in my book, it means I know where to start if I need to get into the thing.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by EndShell on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:20AM (#43241453)
It not that easy with their glued in batteries on some Macbook Pros. You have to essentially use alcohol to remove the glue to replace the battery. Absolute PITA. They could have used 4 screws and it would be easy to replace.

Apple has a high profit margin on their products so I expect better. This isn’t a cheap laptop from a supermarket.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by mschuster91 on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:11AM (#43241885)
Agreed but on the other side it makes the manufacturing more complex - another plastic part and screws as well as the time needed compared to just gluing in the battery.

I suspect this is a classic example of corporate beancounting at work, even if it just a dollar or two per machine, at Apple's volume of millions of machines that's nothing to sneeze at.

To fix it, we need laws that require a certain repairability score for all devices sold. Then doing the "right thing" would be a KPI that competes with pure financial incentives.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by EndShell on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:21AM (#43242576)
> Agreed but on the other side it makes the manufacturing more complex - another plastic part and screws as well as the time needed compared to just gluing in the battery. > > I suspect this is a classic example of corporate beancounting at work, even if it just a dollar or two per machine, at Apple's volume of millions of machines that's nothing to sneeze at.

They make a high margin on each device and other manufacturers can manage it fine at similar price points. I believe it was deliberate, they back tracked after being highly criticised for it.

> To fix it, we need laws that require a certain repairability score for all devices sold. Then doing the "right thing" would be a KPI that competes with pure financial incentives.

If people are concerned about repairability they should seek out manufacturers that offer products where they have a good track record.

Laptops, tablets and phones are seen as partly consumable by the majority of people and they replace them every few years. I am not saying that it is right, I am just saying that is the reality. Also not every problem can be legislated away and if you make something a KPI it will be gamed.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by Someone on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:22AM (#43241467)
Engineering is a matter of trade-offs.

So, how do you screw a thin piece of glass onto a phone that doesn’t have bevels to speak of in such a way that you can put it into your pocket for years, and push a finger on the center of the screen tens of thousands of times without breaking?

Also, if there’s room below the screen, the screen will bend more than when there isn’t, and that will affect longevity.

I’m not claiming using glue wasn’t done out of malice, just that we can’t say it is.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by Gigachad on Monday March 03, 2025 @03:46AM (#43239716)
It’s fairly easy to open. They designed it so a cheap and inexperienced worker in the Apple Store can replace the battery quickly and without issues.

They also made a massive improvement by designing an adhesive for the battery that detaches with electricity. So you no longer have to use pull tabs or heat.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by tlavoie on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:42PM (#43244469)
Are Mac laptops still glued together? My 2013 MBP needed a new battery, which required replacing the following as one unit: battery, keyboard, top case, trackpad. The reason is that it was all one blob. (And then the charging circuit on the motherboard died, and I moved on to ThinkPads I can upgrade and deal with myself.)
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by StressedDev on Monday March 03, 2025 @05:48PM (#43247782)
My last iPhone’s battery lasted about 5.5 years before it needed to be replaced. Replacing it cost about $90 + tax at the Apple store. The bottom line is Apple products do last and if you need a new battery, you can get one.