News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by Aurornis on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:44PM (#43237037)
Spending time in a company that designs and manufactures real products will cure anyone of this conspiracy theory. There’s probably an exception for companies that don’t have any warranty and don’t have to suffer returns (e.g. the stuff you buy from Temu). Any company that has to build a reputation and suffer the economic consequences of warranty claims will not be doing anything to intentionally make their products break down over time.

Once you’re close to the engineering side of physical products you also realize how hard it would be to make products that break down precisely after the warranty period is up. Most failure modes get spread out over a very long time (years/decades). Attempts at intentional obsolescence would start cutting into your warranty period very easily.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by hsbauauvhabzb on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:05PM (#43237200)
The cost of improved quality still need only offset the cost of returns within the warranty period and opinion on reasonable product lifetime though. At some point the cost of better quality will be greater than the profit margin a company is willing to accept and a consumer is willing to pay, but it’s in the companies best interest to get that as close to a number that passes the pub test (e.g., an ‘untentional’ bug bricking the firmware the day after warrantee expires)

I’m not convinced some of my very expensive smart products aren’t intentionally degrading over time, given fw is introducing more functional bugs.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by NullPrefix on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:56PM (#43237130)
Do you think the fact that new cars have engines that are not rebuildable but only replaceable is just a coincidence? With every year car manufacturers get more insight in how and when things break, thus allowing the use of more plastic parts in the engine bay
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by Spooky23 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:16PM (#43237265)
Almost any car can go 200,000 miles these days and exceptions (Hyundai/Kia engines, Nissan transmissions) are well known and excoriated.

Pre OBD2 cars just didn’t do that. 100k was a significant milestone for the life of the car. Today, it’s a preventative maintenance milestone.

Shitty plastic parts aren’t a feature of modern cars, just lousy companies. I had a 1991 Dodge Spirit in college and high school that had a little plastic part in the distributor that broke when it got hot.

When it did, the car would just stop if you hit a puddle or turned right quickly. It did so enough that I kept two spares in the trunk. One time the car died on the ramp from the GW Bridge to the West Side Drive. I just stopped on the ramp and fixed it, pissing off hundreds of people in the process.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by shermantanktop on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:19PM (#43238256)
Great story. The GW bridge is one of the most stressful driving-in-city-you-don’t-know-well experiences I’ve ever had. We were literally shouting at google maps as it blithely delivered nonsense while we were surrounded by cars who wanted very much not to let us change lanes.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by NullPrefix on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:39PM (#43237404)
>Almost any car can go 200,000 miles these days and exceptions

Doubt that

>Pre OBD2 cars just didn’t do that

In Eastern Europe, if the car has 200k-300k km on the odomoter, it only means one thing - the odometer is turned back. Pre OBD2 doing 500k and up is pretty normal here.

>little plastic part in the distributor

Distributor was always plastic, afaik. I'm talking about plastic water pumps on the new BMWs

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by WrongAssumption on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:10PM (#43237910)
"How Many Miles Does a Car Last?

The Bureau of Transportation indicates that the average age across the board for vehicles still on the road is just over 11 years according to Autotrader, and the average may be approaching 12 years. Standard cars in this day and age are expected to keep running up to 200,000 miles, while cars with electric engines are expected to last for up to 300,000 miles."

https://www.caranddriver.com/research/a32758625/how-many-mil...

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by kube-system on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:26AM (#43241492)
Old BMWs have plastic water pumps. That’s hardly something new.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by SR2Z on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:02PM (#43237174)
It's not a coincidence - new cars have turbochargers and electronic engine control that provide huge performance/efficiency gains and necessarily are harder to repair.

Your average shitty 4-banger from the 80s or 90s is not remotely comparable to a new engine - in almost every respect (including reliability!) the new one is better.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by NullPrefix on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:40PM (#43237409)
New engines also have thin blocks, which cannot be honed
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by Peanuts99 on Monday March 03, 2025 @05:44AM (#43240470)
New engines don't ever need to be honed. You can change the performance parameters in software easily enough.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by NullPrefix on Monday March 03, 2025 @03:25PM (#43246259)
honing is part of rebuild
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by SR2Z on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:44AM (#43252058)
Yes, and who exactly is going to rebuild a $2000 engine instead of buying a new one?

The labor costs ALONE make that a horrible idea for anyone who isn't a mechanic already - and if an engine lasts ten years the depreciation on the car is intense enough that it doesn't matter.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by NullPrefix on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @08:44PM (#43261663)
I doubt you could buy a new engine for $2k. And this whole thing that you are arguing for, it's called throwaway products
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by marcus0x62 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:52PM (#43237791)
Turbochargers date back to the 1920s, and I'd rather troubleshoot a modern EFI/GDI system than a carburetor any day of the week.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by SR2Z on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:40PM (#43244442)
Sure they're old, but my understanding is that outside of diesels and aircraft they were too fiddly and unreliable to put in common use.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by eviks on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:18PM (#43237606)
> Any company that has to build a reputation and suffer the economic consequences of warranty claims

What are the economic consequences of warranty claims if you products are cheapened to fail after the warranty expires?

Have you not heard of enough of penny-pinching electronics fails (a device worth hundreds $ failing due to low quality part worth cents)?

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by margalabargala on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:21PM (#43238265)
The argument is, cheapening your products to break after the warranty expired is sufficiently hard that it would result in plenty of products breaking before the warranty expires.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by eviks on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:31PM (#43238318)
It's not rocket science

First, you're not blind - you can test your product to see what the "plenty" is.

Second, many components have rated use, so it's easy to estimate mean time to fail and pick the one beyond the warranty period with whatever buffer you like. It's not like you need seconds level of precision here!

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by stouset on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:44PM (#43238378)
Might I suggest reading about the normal distribution?

Or, I don’t know, perhaps giving slightly greater consideration to the people in this thread who’ve actually worked on physical device engineering?

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by eviks on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:55PM (#43238434)
The level of consideration matches the level of argumentation, e.g., it's obvious you failed in your interpretative nitpicking on the word "mean" and think "reading about the normal distribution" means anything in this context.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by stouset on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:20AM (#43238529)
Appropriately for the topic, I tailored the level of consideration to just barely exceed that of your original argument. So, next to none.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by eviks on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:48AM (#43238677)
Are you replying to yourself? You were the one demanding consideration, not me!
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by nickff on Monday March 03, 2025 @02:25AM (#43239160)
Please design a physical product to reliably fail after a specific and precise amount of time (not usage, because that’s easier and not what you’re arguing), then come back and describe how easily you accomplished that feat. Everyone reading this thread who has worked in device design knows that your assertions are completely and utterly misguided.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by eviks on Monday March 03, 2025 @02:40AM (#43239234)
Right after you explain how in this imaginary world of 0 knowledge where you're not even capable of translating usage into time companies set a warranty to 3 years (>legal min) instead of 13; and why there are warranty limitations for heavy use.

(and no, you don't need "reliably ... specific and precise", those are just artifical constraints you've added)

And don't speak for everyone, not everyone is so clueless re. business decisions just because they've designed some hardware.

Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by stouset on Monday March 03, 2025 @03:12PM (#43246109)
“I know so much more about this topic from some casual Googling than people who actually do this for a living, so please listen to me.”
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by shermantanktop on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:15PM (#43238235)
I think the point is that Hanlon’s Razor applies here. Though there are definitely cases like this, I’m not sure how one could prove that the penny-pincher was intentionally oblivious to the damage from failure.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by Marsymars on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:26PM (#43237655)
I agree with your overall sentiment, but I can't help but feel that when companies offer single-year warranties it's because they haven't put in the engineering to keep the failure rate down over what's actually a reasonable-for-the-consumer lifespan for the product.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by jwagenet on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:26AM (#43243364)
Or perhaps a manufacturer has determined the customer isn’t willing to pay a premium for the engineering or material costs required to increase lifespan.
Re:Gooey rubber that's slowly ruining old hard drives by Salgat on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:50PM (#43238415)
When peoplespeak of planned obsolescence, they're discussing how companies pay the bare minimum to make a part that functions within the warranty period. They aren't doing it to fail the part prematurely, they'd doing it to pinch pennies in the manufacturing costs.