News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by jl6 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @04:28AM (#43228788)
The bit I find amazing in these galaxy fields is the apparent randomness of the orientation of each galaxy. Why is this? Are we seeing a remnant of chaotic behavior where tiny random variations at the smallest scale in the early universe led to the wildly diverse objects that we see today? There is great variation in the color, size, and shape of galaxies too, but somehow it’s the apparent orientation that baffles my intuition.
Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by UltraSane on Sunday March 02, 2025 @04:40AM (#43228862)
The location of galaxies is thought to have been triggered by quantum fluctuations in the earliest moments of the universe that caused matter to be denser in some locations. But why would you expect galaxies to NOT be randomly oriented?
Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by kryogen1c on Sunday March 02, 2025 @05:24AM (#43229064)
> why would you expect galaxies to NOT be randomly oriented?

Well that depends on what your intuition about randomness is, doesn't it?

Flipping a coin is not random, but you can't tell me the answer before it happens.

Similarly, galaxy orientation is not random, but predicting the world we perceive is perhaps not so easy.

Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by jl6 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @04:55AM (#43228928)
I guess I shouldn’t have that expectation. Perhaps it’s because on Earth we see nearby objects aligning with each other because they have been shaped by similar forces, or because they influence each other. But perhaps galaxies don’t interact with each other enough to result in any kind of alignment.
Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by evanb on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:55AM (#43230035)
Molecules of nitrogen and oxygen both have a distinguished axis (along the bond), but because they're gaseous there's no reason to expect them to align throughout the atmosphere.

So too with galaxies---which, from a cosmological perspective, are essentially infinitesimal dust.

Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by UltraSane on Sunday March 02, 2025 @05:15AM (#43229025)
The planets in our solar system all orbit on the same plane because they all formed from the same dust cloud that was rotating in the same plane.
Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by orra on Sunday March 02, 2025 @05:26AM (#43229075)
Indeed. And to elaborate: the random collisions which flattened the solar system (or galaxy) over billions of years all conserved angular momentum.

Minute Physics have a nice video on this: https://youtube.com/watch?v=tmNXKqeUtJM

Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by prerok on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:24AM (#43230272)
Nice video, thanks for sharing.

And just to clarify to GP, the original dust was not in the same plane and the video explains why it ends up in the same plane.

Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by jrootabega on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:35AM (#43231446)
Might be begging the question. Perhaps it's not really that random. We common people don't usually get pictures that convey depth and orientation, and probably wouldn't care even if we did. Might only be as random as a solar system with varying orbital inclinations and directions.

If not, the forces that turn some solar systems and galaxies into rotating disks might not act the same at the supergalactic scale in time and space?

Re:Euclid finds complete Einstein Ring in NGC galaxy by mr_mitm on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:39AM (#43232174)
Funny you should ask. Euclid specifically measures the ellipticity of billions of galaxies.

Because the light traverses regions of lower and higher density (made up mostly of dark matter), we see a gravitational lensing effect. Sources of gravity distort the image behind the "lens". The article describes a strong lensing effect, which is pretty self-evident. By analyzing correlations of galaxy ellipticities we can measure an effect which is only apparent as a statistical effect. You'd expect no intrinsic correlation of the apparent ellipticity between galaxies (because they can be millions of light-years apart), but this so called weak lensing effect does create a correlation. I basically think of it as observing perfect ellipses through slightly obscure glass and deducing from that the exact shape of the glass.

Thanks to Euclid's data, we will be able to create a sort of 3D map of the total matter distribution (dark and baryonic), which will in turn tell us how the universe evolved better than any other probe. We hope to learn more about dark energy in this way.