Re:A Letter to the American People
by groestl on Saturday March 01, 2025 @05:26PM
(#43224387)
Civil War
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I feel like we’re all to complicit for such drastic measure. Which makes it all even more depressing.
No reason for blue states to stay in the union if things continue down this path.
People are not neatly allocated according to state borders (and also not neatly along party lines).
if history is any guide that sorts itself out pretty quickly
And the sorting is, in essence, my point.
I don't think it's that simple
Blue states just have bigger urban areas. It's an urban rural difference. I don't have the numbers off hand but I wouldn't be surprised if NY would be a red state if you excluded Manhattan and the other boroughs
> I don't have the numbers off hand but I wouldn't be surprised if NY would be a red state if you excluded Manhattan and the other boroughs
"Other than that Mrs Lincoln, how was the play?"
It always surprises me when people's mental model of fair say is divided by land area and not by population.
We're not talking about fair say, I'm talking about a civil war being unrealistic
I don't actually think that would have much impact on how realistic a civil war is.
I think that might impact the tactics of the war, or how bloody it is, but I don't think it makes it less possible to happen.
It's dangerously possible, and it's a deep concern of mine that we're headed in that direction.
Re:A Letter to the American People
by shepherdjerred on Saturday March 01, 2025 @05:43PM
(#43224627)
I'm all for a civil war after what Trump did to Zelensky. Absolutely disgusting.
It's more than that, it's unbelievably dangerous. There's a reason world leaders don't do stuff like that in public, we just signaled loud and clear we're absolutely not to be trusted. If China wants to make a move on Taiwan, the DPRK wants to shell Seoul, or Russia wants to test Article 5 they just got a lot more confident in our lack of conviction. And all our allies had better be drawing up contingencies that don't involve us coming to their aid.
Maybe, maybe not. They may also conclude Trump is unhinged and can flip on a dime, and it would be risky to predict his response.