> I foresee exciting times ahead, provided we still have a functioning civilization in which to enjoy them.
> For most of my professional life, this blog has been my forum, where anyone in the world could show up to raise any issue they wanted, as if we were tunic-wearing philosophers in the Athenian agora.
I don't agree with many of his posts but I think the blog is interesting in how personal it feels. Often I feel like all media is very cultivated but he seems very willing to put his own anxieties and foibles on the web.
Does Musk understand this? Maybe not. It's not evident so far. He certainly lives in a fictional world of the right wing's devising. Will someone else be able to penetrate that bubble to make him understand it? Will he care if they do? Guess we'll find out.
Given that this is Scott Aaronson, does he suggest we'll break cryptography and destroy the foundations of the modern internet?
If topological qubits turn out to be so much more reliable then it doesn't really matter how much time was spent trying to make other types of qubits more reliable. It's not really a head start, is it?
Or are there other problems besides preventing unwanted decoherence that might take that much time to solve?
So, he is saying that this approach will only pay off if topological qubits are a fundamentally better approach than the others being tried. If they turn out to be, say, merely twice as good as trapped ion qubits, they'll still only get to the achievements of current trapped ion designs with another, say, 10-15 years of continued investment.
The utility of traditional qubits depends entirely on how reliable and long-lived they are, and how to can scale to larger numbers of qubits. These topological qubits are effectively 100% reliable, infinite duration, and scale like semiconductors. According to the marketing literature, at least…
Note also that this isn’t a simulated result. Microsoft has an 8-qubit chip they are making available on Azure.
IBM sells you 400 qubits with huge coherence problems. When IBM had an 8-qubit chip, they were also pretty stable.
https://www.ft.com/content/a60f44f5-81ca-4e66-8193-64c956b09...
Microsoft is saying: we did it!
Everyone else is saying: prove it!
The only expert in the FT article is Dr. Sankar Das Sarma who (from Wikipedia)
"In collaboration with Chetan Nayak and Michael Freedman of Microsoft Research, Das Sarma introduced the ν = 5 / 2 topological qubit in 2005"
So you might understand why this FT article is not adding anything to the discussion, which does not discuss the theory but rather MS's claim of an actual breakthrough.They show a chip, we'd like proof of what the chip actually does