Really it's more like three questions.
1. Easier? I guess that depends how you define ease, but it largely depends on what resources you have available to you. If I'm Meta and I already have a ton of compute and AI training expertise but don't have relationships with all of the airports, stadiums, etc., their approach is probably easier. You'd have to spin up new teams of people all over the world to get beacons everywhere you want them.
2. Cost-effective? I don't know enough about the costs of your solution to give an accurate answer here, but again it just seems like they're probably already spending resources training models on a huge number of images of the world, so maybe not a lot of incremental cost here.
3. Cost efficient? I would assume your approach wins here.
A large part of the variation I found was due to how individual users held their phones, and the resulting signal attenuation.
[1] https://hackaday.com/2015/12/18/immersive-theatre-via-ibeaco...
It's not a big problem if you want to equip one venue or a couple, but scaling the operation means these side-effects scale too, and we had to work on solutions to handle those, rather than working on our core competency of mesh wi-fi. Unsurprisingly the project was scrapped despite being technically feasible on a small scale - we had a couple of sites.
Virtualizing a physical space gives you more flexibility. It keeps most problems in the software engineering space and limits physical requirements (eg someone might still need to walk around an airport to update the model, but I can't think of any other major ones).
That said, AI is sexy (right now), Meta is heavy in the MR space and the tech is reusable, even if it's not the most energy-efficient solution.
(disclaimer: just my personal ramblings, I don't work on project Aria)
This is where I think the gap is. We only have to train one model for all environments, not per
How do the costs compare for training one big model vs installing billions of beacons?
Also consider the pace at which model sizes, training, and operating costs are falling
The data will all be relative to initial positions and it will have drifts, but how those affect your research goals will be use case dependent(esp. since this is pitched for researches than as ready to go entertainment).
The headset needs the inside out tracking anyway to draw specially locked virtual objects.
To create a fresh spatial anchor at home on mobile hardware is maybe 1 second of compute time. But that doesn't really matter because the anchors would be shared across every user and computed offline beforehand.
As far as scaling the device itself can be used to crowdsource these anchors so it's not even close that the visual solution wins out.
That said beacons are probably better for supporting handset platforms. Powering up modern cell phone cameras to use AR is pretty slow and tedious for the user.
With glasses, you can map the space while identifying POIs—-with beacons you can’t.
Unfortunately, no one really cares about energy use.
I think you are asking the wrong question. The right question is: "Which approach will people use?"
Doesn't matter if it is the easiest cheapest most energy efficient thing, if people don't use it.
Also exist some nuances, as some cities are flat but others have large hills, so need to place few beacons on sides of hill (rough surface need much more beacons).
Practically, I have experience in project to deploy LoraWan network in large city Kiev, and one concurrent bought research from cellular network planners and for first look they drawn ~300 access points to have more than 99% coverage.
Well, Meta poured a shit ton of money into making Quest base station free and they got there. We use to use valve setup for our robotics applications but we swapped it out with Quest cause honestly Quest was as good but much more easy to setup and operate.
The bitter lesson is that don’t bet against data or compute. Also, I don’t think you’d have to train a AI model for each location at every time in the future. Things get more efficient, etc.
2) Is a $1-??? business requiring a few dedicated nerds working on CV with inf more applications and doesn't require "invading" physical buildings you dont own.
It's their purpose in VR/AR to have cheap indoor location, for them it's one more step in that direction. Eventually they will achieve doing it with little compute.
In over a decade of indoor robotics I have _never_ seen a beacon-based solution that practically scales (even marker-based solutions are challenging). And it's not because the tech is even bad – it's just that any process that involves _installing things_ is a PITA and wildly more expensive and time-consuming that it should be.
This kind of sucks but it is an unfortunately reality, in my experience at least.
Anything you want to track in the meat realm, especially a place like an airport, the airtag or google equivalent mesh networks are going to be far more dense than your beacons and last forever with no power required.
In Project Aria video, they claim to have installed beacons at an airport to enable indoor location, only to dismiss it as something that "doesn't scale."
Instead, they say they "trained" an AI model using vision from glasses, allowing for vision-based localization.
So, here’s an honest question: which approach is actually easier, more cost-effective, and energy-efficient?
1) Deploying 100 or even 1,000 wireless, battery-operated beacons that last 5–7 years—something a non-tech person can set up in a day or two.
2) Training an AI model for each airport, then constantly burning compute power from camera-equipped glasses or phones that barely last a few hours.
Thoughts?